Medicare Managed Care: Payment Rates, Local Fee-for-Service Spending, and Other Factors Affect Plans' Benefit Packages: HEHS-99-9R

Scanlon, William J.
October 1998
GAO Reports;10/9/1998, p1
Government Document
Pursuant to a congressional request, GAO provided information on Medicare's health maintenance organizations (HMO), focusing on: (1) the key differences between Medicare's traditional fee-for-service (FFS) and managed care programs; (2) how Medicare historically set the monthly capitation rates paid to managed care plans and why these rates varied among counties; (3) how the Balanced Budget Act of 1997 (BBA) affected rates and the rate-setting process; (4) how the Health Care Financing Administration (HCFA) approves managed care plans' benefits and premiums; and (5) what requirements HCFA places on plans to notify beneficiaries about impending benefit and premium changes. GAO noted that: (1) most Medicare beneficiaries can choose to receive health care services through a traditional FFS arrangement or a managed care organization; (2) there are several key differences between the two health care systems; (3) for beneficiaries, some of these differences involve trade-offs; (4) for example, compared to Medicare FFS, managed care plans typically cover more services and impose lower out-of-pocket cost; (5) however, a beneficiary in FFS can obtain care from any provider who receives Medicare payments, while a beneficiary in a managed care plan is typically limited to providers authorized by that plan; (6) another difference is how medical care is paid for; (7) in FFS, Medicare makes a separate payment for each covered service provided, while managed care plans receive a fixed monthly capitated payment for each beneficiary they enroll; (8) before 1998, payments to managed care plans were tightly linked to per capita Medicare FFS spending in each county to reflect the dramatic variation in health care costs and use; (9) as a result, capitation rates varied with the demographic characteristics of the beneficiary and his or her county of residence; (10) for example, in 1997, a managed care plan would receive $767 per month for serving a beneficiary in Richmond County (Staten Island), New York, compared to $221 for serving a similar beneficiary in Arthur County, Nebraska; (11) moreover, plans in relatively high-payment counties tend to offer a richer benefit package compared to plans in low-payment counties; (12) BBA will likely gradually reduce the geographic variation in managed care payments and benefit packages; (13) at the same time, because the legislation was designed to slow the growth of Medicare spending, benefit packages offered by managed care plans may become less generous; (14) managed care plans must contract with HCFA before they can serve Medicare beneficiaries; (15) contracts normally begin in January and run for 1 year; (16) at a minimum, plans must provide all FFS-covered benefits; (17) if HCFA determines a plan's projected Medicare profits will exceed its normal profit level, the plan is required to enhance its benefit package, set aside funds for future use, or both; (18) although plans can increase benefits or reduce the fees they charge at any time, they do so only with HCFA approval; and (19) in addition, Medicare requires that all plans notify members 30 days before a change takes place.


Related Articles

  • HMO Penetration, Hospital Competition, and Growth of Ambulatory Surgery Centers. Bian, John; Morrisey, Michael A. // Health Care Financing Review;Summer2006, Vol. 27 Issue 4, p111 

    Using metropolitan statistical area (MSA) panel data from 1992-2001 constructed from the 2002 Medicare Online Survey Certification and Reporting (OSCAR) System, we estimate the market effects of health maintenance organization (HMO) penetration and hospital competition on the growth of...

  • Medicare + Choice: Recent Payment Increases Had Little Effect on Benefits or Plan Availability in 2001: GAO-02-202.  // GAO Reports;11/21/2001, p1 

    The number of contracts under Medicare's managed care program--Medicare+Choice (M+C)--fell from 340 to 180 between 1998 and 2001. The reduction reflected decisions by some managed care organizations (MCOs) to terminate selected contracts or to discontinue service in some covered areas. Although...

  • Measures and Predictors of Medicare Knowledge: A Review of the Literature. Greenwald, Leslie M.; McCormack, Lauren A.; Uhrig, Jennifer D.; West, Nathan // Health Care Financing Review;Summer2006, Vol. 27 Issue 4, p1 

    As the Medicare Program evolves, adding new insurance options like regional preferred provider organizations (PPOs) and prescription drug benefits, beneficiaries have an even greater need to understand the program. However, past research suggests that many beneficiaries have limited...

  • Impartial perspective. Walker, Tracey // Managed Healthcare Executive;Jul2007, Vol. 17 Issue 7, p24 

    The article presents questions and answers related to Health Maintenance Organization (HMO) in the U.S. One person inquires about the premium costs and trends in states. Another person asks why employers continue to shoulder the majority of the cost increases. A reader questions about the...

  • Medicare and Managed Care Plans: Payments and Costs for Selected Hospitals: HEHS-00-177R.  // GAO Reports;9/1/2000, p1 

    Pursuant to a congressional request, GAO reviewed Medicare and managed care plan hospital costs and payments, focusing on: (1) the relationship between Medicare and managed care plan payments and costs; (2) managed care plan payments and the relative importance of managed care business; and (3)...

  • Medicare drop-outs are an ominous sign. Wechsler, Jill // Managed Healthcare;Jun99, Vol. 9 Issue 6, p14 

    Focuses on a report issued by the General Accounting Office on Medicare withdrawals. Reasons cited in the report regarding the plans and decisions to exit the Medicare+Choice program; Announcement of several Medicare managed care plans that they would not renew their Medicare contracts;...

  • Medicare pays more for inpatient care. Gardner, Jonathan // Modern Healthcare;09/04/2000, Vol. 30 Issue 37, p4 

    Focuses on a hospital finances report by the United States General Accounting Office which concluded that Medicare is a more generous payer than private managed-care plans. Key findings of the report; Number of hospitals surveyed; Reaction from the Federation of American Hospitals.

  • Managed Medicare in the Marketplace. Zablocki, Elaine // Managed Healthcare Executive;Sep2007, Vol. 17 Issue 9, p29 

    The article reports on the financial scrutiny confronting the Medicare Advantage (MA) plans in the U.S. It is inferred that MA antagonists claimed that it is overfunded. The Congress has passed a bill to cut funding levels for MA by $50 billion over five years and these funds would instead be...

  • Calcium Supplement and Bone Medication Use in a US Medicare Health Maintenance Organization. Dawson-Hughes, B.; Harris, S. S.; Dallal, G. E.; Lancaster, D. R.; Zhou, Qi // Osteoporosis International;Aug2002, Vol. 13 Issue 8, p657 

    : This study was conducted to determine the prevalence of the use of calcium supplements and of prescription medications to prevent or treat osteoporosis in men and women in a large New England Medicare Health Maintenance Organization (HMO). A two-page diet, medication use and medical history...


Read the Article

Other Topics