TITLE

John Yoo's War Powers: The Law Review and the World

AUTHOR(S)
Alexande, Janet Cooper
PUB. DATE
April 2012
SOURCE
California Law Review;Apr2012, Vol. 100 Issue 2, p331
SOURCE TYPE
Academic Journal
DOC. TYPE
Essay
ABSTRACT
John Yoo's 1996 The Continuation of Politics by Other Means: The Original Understanding of War Powers is surely among the most consequential articles ever to appear in the California Law Review. Five years after its publication, Yoo became the principal theorist of the Bush administration's War on Terrorism policies. His expansive theory of presidential primacy became the legal basis for the most controversial of President Bush's policies, including the use of torture (or "enhanced interrogation"), indefinite detention without charge, warrantless wiretapping within the United States, and the claim that neither constitutional protections nor other provisions of domestic and international law constrain treatment of suspected terrorists. Yet the methodology and conclusions of War Powers have been subjected to comprehensive and devastating criticism, addressing issues ranging from selective use of evidence to fundamentally misunderstanding the Framers' rejection of monarchical prerogatives in constructing the executive power. Yoo's theory is based on a presumption that the Framers' design was to replicate the British government's allocation of powers between Parliament and the King. To reach the conclusion that the President has primacy in war, subject only to Congress's spending and impeachment power, Yoo ignores the many war powers expressly granted to Congress in Article I and disregards or dismisses the remarkably unanimous statements of prominent Founders disclaiming the British model. After reviewing the criticisms of Yoo's theory, this Essay reflects on how a flawed and eccentric historical theory came to underpin the government's conduct of war and foreign policy. Finally, this Essay examines the implications of this saga for law review publishing, as well as for the participation of legal academics in government and the formation of national policy.
ACCESSION #
74152437

 

Related Articles

  • More than 100 detainees "rendered" by U.S. with help from allies, including Canada. Ismi, Asad // CCPA Monitor;May2014, Vol. 21 Issue 1, p20 

    The article focuses on the declassification of a 480-page executive summary of the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) report, which inckude details on the interrogation, detention, and rendition of more than 100 CIA detainees. Topics include the agency's failure on the Global War on Terror in...

  • REFLECTIONS ON INCONSISTENCIES IN REMEDIAL RELIEF FOR HUMAN RIGHTS TRANSGRESSIONS RELATIVE TO SECURITY RISK AVERSION. Bejesky, Robert // Michigan State International Law Review;2015, Vol. 23 Issue 2, p293 

    The article focuses on the applicable law regarding the inconsistencies during the detention and interrogation of suspected terrorists and the assertions of presidential power for the punishment and remedial relief for human rights violations in the U.S. during the global war on terror.

  • The Usual Suspects. Beith, Malcolm // Newsweek (Pacific Edition);2/25/2002 (Pacific Edition), Vol. 139 Issue 8, p4 

    Discusses how Europe refuses to follow the United States by detaining terrorist suspects on inconclusive evidence, as evidenced by the freeing of suspected terrorist Lotfi Raissi in England. How U.S. authorities saw Raissi's case as proof of how many terrorists are at large in Europe; Comments...

  • The Usual Suspects. Beith, Malcolm // Newsweek (Atlantic Edition);2/25/2002 (Atlantic Edition), Vol. 139 Issue 8, p4 

    Discusses how Europe refuses to follow the United States by detaining terrorist suspects on inconclusive evidence, as evidenced by the freeing of suspected terrorist Lotfi Raissi in England. How U.S. authorities saw Raissi's case as proof of how many terrorists are at large in Europe; Comments...

  • Torture and the Rule of Law.  // America;8/3/2009, Vol. 201 Issue 3, p10 

    The article focuses on the three alternatives for addressing the issue of violations of civil liberties during the war on terror effort by Bush administration. Assistant Attorney General Jay S. Bybee issued the torture memorandum which implies the preventive action on the detention and...

  • THE ARCHITECTS. Krause, Jason // ABA Journal;Sep2007, Vol. 93 Issue 9, p27 

    The article provides information on the lawyers of the U.S. government who created the blueprint for the legal war on terror. John Yoo helped draft the opinions defining the U.S. legal approach to terror cases. In a January 9, 2002 memo, he declared the Geneva Conventions' strict limitations on...

  • War by Other Means: An Insider's Account of the War on Terror.  // Publishers Weekly;9/4/2006, Vol. 253 Issue 35, p54 

    The article reviews the book "War by Other Means: An Insider's Account of the War on Terror," by John Yoo.

  • The Myth of Bush's Torture Regime. MCCARTHY, ANDREW C. // National Review;12/29/2008, Vol. 60 Issue 24, p38 

    This article discusses the liberal response to the U.S. government's willingness to torture detainees held in the War on Terrorism and the Iraq War. Criticisms of U.S. Military policy regarding detainees in these conflicts are presented as misrepresentations of U.S. policy. The author considers...

  • PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY COMPLIANCE AND NATIONAL SECURITY ATTORNEYS: ADOPTING THE NORMATIVE FRAMEWORK OF INTERNALIZED LEGAL ETHICS. Petty, Keith A. // Utah Law Review;2011, Vol. 2011 Issue 4, p1563 

    No abstract available.

Share

Read the Article

Courtesy of THE LIBRARY OF VIRGINIA

Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics