Sharing Our Body and blood: Organ Donation and Feminist Critiques of Sacrifice

Mongoven, Ann
February 2003
Journal of Medicine & Philosophy;Feb2003, Vol. 28 Issue 1, p89
Academic Journal
Feminist analysis of cultural mythology surrounding organ donation of offers a critical perspective on current U.S. transplant policy. My argument is three-pronged. First, I argue that organ donation is appropriately understood as a sacrifice. Structurally, donation accords both to general and to specifically Christian archetypes of sacrifice. The characterization of donation as sacrifice resonates in the cultural psyche even though it is absent in public rhetoric. Second, I characterize widespread feminist concerns about the over-glorification of sacrifice. These concerns provide a helpful framework for considering about the over-glorification of sacrifice. These concerns provide a helpful framework for considering whether the sacrifice of organ donation is over-florified in our culture. Third, I consider several specific aspects of organ recruitment and organ allocation. Each demonstrates an over-glorification of sacrifice that leads to a dangerous "routinization" of sacrifice. None of these excesses are addressable without due attention to the symbolic important of organ donation and transplantation. I close by suggesting lessons my analysis offers to Christian churches who support donation, to the discourse of bioethics, and to the general public.


Related Articles

  • European kidney market. Dorozynski, Alexander // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);11/11/89, Vol. 299 Issue 6709, p1182 

    Reports the scandal involving a kidney donor in France. Formulation of a project on bioethics; Characterization of the purchase of organs as criminal; Adoption of a charter to defend ethical principles of voluntary and anonymous organ donation.

  • Courage and character, leaders and legends: an interview with Arthur Caplan, PhD. Ohler, Linda // Progress in Transplantation;Dec2014, Vol. 24 Issue 4, p308 

    The author reflects on the career of transplant and medical ethics professional Arthur Caplan. She suggests that Caplan has shown courage in sharing his perspectives on transplantation topics for nearly 40 years. She argues that as a result of Caplan's character and convictions he has been able...

  • Bioethics in and from Asia. Macer, Darryl // Journal of Medical Ethics;Aug99, Vol. 25 Issue 4, p293 

    Provides information on bioethics in Asia. Discussion on the use of brain-dead organ donors; Role of media in influencing bioethical decisions in all countries; Diversity of bioethics.

  • The ethics of poverty and the poverty of ethics: the case of Palestinian prisoners in Israel seeking to sell their kidneys in order to feed their children. Epstein, Miran // Journal of Medical Ethics;Aug2007, Vol. 33 Issue 8, p473 

    The article discusses the new regulations that address the need for live kidney and other organ donors and the influence of poverty in selling organs in order to sustain a family. There are bioethical arguments underlying the option of selling organs which add to the dilemma that impose tragedy...

  • Organ Donation and Global Bioethics. Iltis, Ana S. // Journal of Medicine & Philosophy;Apr2010, Vol. 35 Issue 2, p213 

    The article discusses the organ donation practice employed by China and the efforts to create a global bioethics particularly by Westerners. It highlights the Chinese practice of using organs taken from executed prisoners which has been condemned by many throughout the world. Particular focus is...

  • Money for organs attracts `dodgy donors'. Coghlan, Andy // New Scientist;4/22/95, Vol. 146 Issue 1974, p8 

    Reports on the warning issued by the Nuffield Council on Bioethics against the sale of blood, organs and tissues in Great Britain. Abuses that could arise from the commercial trade of human tissue; Need for Great Britain to resist moves towards the American system of human tissue sale; Ethical...

  • What should we do with donated embryos that may be genetically affected? De Lacey, Sheryl; Norman, R. J. // Human Reproduction;Vol. 19 Issue 5, p1065 

    The ethical and legal issues arising from genetic screening in embryo donation are discussed in relation to two recent cases where embryos with uncertain genetic health were offered for donation.

  • ESHRE Task Force on Ethics and Law 12: Oocyte donation for non-reproductive purposes. ESHRE Task Force on Ethics and Law including; G. Pennings; G. de Wert; F. Shenfield; J. Cohen; B. Tarlatzis; P. Devroey // Human Reproduction;May2007, Vol. 22 Issue 5, p1210 

    The present paper focuses on oocyte donation for non-reproductive purposes, i.e. research and future therapy. The general principles of research ethics apply to these interventions. The proportionality principle demands that any possible harms to the oocyte donors should be proportionate to the...

  • The Ethics of Limiting Informed Debate: Censorship of Select Medical Publications in the Interest of Organ Transplantation. Potts, Michael; Verheijde, Joseph L.; Rady, Mohamed Y.; Evans, David W. // Journal of Medicine & Philosophy;Dec2013, Vol. 38 Issue 6, p625 

    Recently, several articles in the scholarly literature on medical ethics proclaim the need for “responsible scholarship” in the debate over the proper criteria for death, in which “responsible scholarship” is defined in terms of support for current neurological criteria...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics