TITLE

THUCYDIDES AND LAW: A RESPONSE TO LEITER

AUTHOR(S)
Shanske, Darien
PUB. DATE
September 2013
SOURCE
Legal Theory;Sep2013, Vol. 19 Issue 3, p282
SOURCE TYPE
Academic Journal
DOC. TYPE
Article
ABSTRACT
Thucydides is the author of the most harrowing account of societal breakdown in antiquity. Brian Leiter has recently made the provocative claim that Thucydides’ analysis of such breakdowns indicates that morality is of little import in guiding behavior, including legal behavior. Yet Thucydides also narrates events, particularly in Athens, that indicate that something resembling morality can continue to guide action, including legal action, even at the worst of times. Thucydides provides tantalizing clues as to why he narrates events that only sometimes follow the path predicted by Leiter. In particular, Thucydides (accurately) portrays the law that suffuses Athenian life and saves Athens itself as, for the most part, informal and infused with moral concerns. Leiter's reading of Thucydides therefore not only is limited but misses implicit arguments that challenge Leiter's broader argument for a particular form of legal realism.
ACCESSION #
99116767

 

Related Articles

  • For the record.  // New Scientist;3/10/2007, Vol. 193 Issue 2594, p23 

    Corrections to articles published in the February 17, 2007 issue are presented including the geographical location of the Chinese province of Tangshan, and information about the earthquake-sensitive animals of the city of Helice, the correct attribution of which is Diodorus.

  • La sombra y la Nada: En torno a un Escolio de Nicolás Gómez Dávila. Serrano Ruiz-Calderón, José Miguel // Pensamiento y Cultura;2013, Vol. 16 Issue 2, p72 

    On occasion of the centennial of Colombian writer Nicolás Gómez Dávila, this article analyzes a scholion that summarizes his attitude toward the reality in which man is immersed. It says, "Between man and nothingness comes the shadow of God." On the one hand, this expresses the fear of...

  • An architectural history of metaphors. Fez-Barringten, Barie // AI & Society;Feb2011, Vol. 26 Issue 1, p103 

    This paper presents a review and an historical perspective on the architectural metaphor. It identifies common characteristics and peculiarities-as they apply to given historical periods-and analyses the similarities and divergences. The review provides a vocabulary, which will facilitate an...

  • MIGHT AND RIGHT: THUCYDIDES AND THE MELOS MASSACRE. Cartledge, Paul // History Today;May86, Vol. 36 Issue 5, p11 

    Focuses on the book 'Melian Dialogue,' by Thucydides. Influence of Thucydides in writing the book; Antiquities of Melos Island; Analysis of the book.

  • The limits of realism.  // Wilson Quarterly;Autumn92, Vol. 16 Issue 4, p127 

    Comments on the article `Varieties of Realism: Thucydides and Machiavelli,' by Steven Forde published in the May 1992 issue of `The Journal of Politics' on the role of realism in international politics. Influence of Greek historian Thucydides and Italian political theorist Nicolo Machiavelli;...

  • “Hope, Danger’s Comforter”: Thucydides, Hope, Politics. Schlosser, Joel Alden // Journal of Politics;Jan2013, Vol. 75 Issue 1, p169 

    With its ascendancy in American political discourse during the past few years, hope has become a watchword of politics, yet the rhetoric has failed to inquire into the actual function of hope in political life. This essay examines elpis, the Greek word for “hope,” in...

  • The Hellenic Disaster in Egypt. Holladay, A. J. // Journal of Hellenic Studies;1989, Vol. 109, p176 

    The article focuses on the gravity of the disaster suffered by the Athenians and their allies in Egypt in 454 B.C. According to Thucydides i 104, a whole fleet of 200 ships went to Egypt when the appeal came from Inaros. Meanwhile, the Athenians needed to discover and deal with the ships in...

  • Thucydidean Themes. Morley, Neville // Journal of Hellenic Studies;Nov2012, Vol. 132, p220 

    The article reviews the book "Thucydidean Themes," by S. Hornblower.

  • Narrator interventions in Thucydides. Gribble, David // Journal of Hellenic Studies;1998, Vol. 118, p41 

    Examines narrative writer Thucydides' rhetorical technique and sensitive interpretation of individual narrator interventions. Familiarity of the phenomenon of narrator intervention in history and in fiction; Establishment of the character of the narrating persona and the nature of the narrative...

Share

Read the Article

Courtesy of THE LIBRARY OF VIRGINIA

Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics