Low Carbohydrate versus Isoenergetic Balanced Diets for Reducing Weight and Cardiovascular Risk: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Naude, Celeste E.; Schoonees, Anel; Senekal, Marjanne; Young, Taryn; Garner, Paul; Volmink, Jimmy
July 2014
PLoS ONE;Jul2014, Vol. 9 Issue 7, p1
Academic Journal
Background: Some popular weight loss diets restricting carbohydrates (CHO) claim to be more effective, and have additional health benefits in preventing cardiovascular disease compared to balanced weight loss diets. Methods and Findings: We compared the effects of low CHO and isoenergetic balanced weight loss diets in overweight and obese adults assessed in randomised controlled trials (minimum follow-up of 12 weeks), and summarised the effects on weight, as well as cardiovascular and diabetes risk. Dietary criteria were derived from existing macronutrient recommendations. We searched Medline, EMBASE and CENTRAL (19 March 2014). Analysis was stratified by outcomes at 3–6 months and 1–2 years, and participants with diabetes were analysed separately. We evaluated dietary adherence and used GRADE to assess the quality of evidence. We calculated mean differences (MD) and performed random-effects meta-analysis. Nineteen trials were included (n = 3209); 3 had adequate allocation concealment. In non-diabetic participants, our analysis showed little or no difference in mean weight loss in the two groups at 3–6 months (MD 0.74 kg, 95%CI −1.49 to 0.01 kg; I2 = 53%; n = 1745, 14 trials; moderate quality evidence) and 1–2 years (MD 0.48 kg, 95%CI −1.44 kg to 0.49 kg; I2 = 12%; n = 1025; 7 trials, moderate quality evidence). Furthermore, little or no difference was detected at 3–6 months and 1–2 years for blood pressure, LDL, HDL and total cholesterol, triglycerides and fasting blood glucose (>914 participants). In diabetic participants, findings showed a similar pattern. Conclusions: Trials show weight loss in the short-term irrespective of whether the diet is low CHO or balanced. There is probably little or no difference in weight loss and changes in cardiovascular risk factors up to two years of follow-up when overweight and obese adults, with or without type 2 diabetes, are randomised to low CHO diets and isoenergetic balanced weight loss diets.


Related Articles

  • The Lowdown on Low-Carb Diets.  // Cleveland Clinic Men's Health Advisor;Jan2015, Vol. 17 Issue 1, p3 

    The article reports on the benefits of low-carbohydrates diets. Various studies citing greater improvements in cardiovascular risk factors and weight loss in people who adhered to a strict low-carbohydrate diet are noted. A sample of low-carbohydrate meal plan from Cleveland Clinic dietitian...

  • Effects of Low-Carbohydrate and Low-Fat Diets. Bazzano, Lydia A.; Tian Hu; Reynolds, Kristi; Lu Yao; Bunol, Calynn; Yanxi Liu; Chung-Shiuan Chen; Klag, Michael J.; Whelton, Paul K.; Jiang He // Annals of Internal Medicine;9/2/2014, Vol. 161 Issue 5, p309 

    Background: Low-carbohydrate diets are popular for weight loss, but their cardiovascular effects have not been well-studied, particularly in diverse populations. Objective: To examine the effects of a low-carbohydrate diet compared with a low-fat diet on body weight and cardiovascular risk...

  • Effect of dietary pulse intake on established therapeutic lipid targets for cardiovascular risk reduction: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Ha, Vanessa; Sievenpiper, John L.; de Souza, Russell J.; Jayalath, Viranda H.; Mirrahimi, Arash; Agarwal, Arnav; Chiavaroli, Laura; Blanco Mejia, Sonia; Sacks, Frank M.; Di Buono, Marco; Bernstein, Adam M.; Leiter, Lawrence A.; Kris-Etherton, Penny M.; Vuksan, Vladimir; Bazinet, Richard P.; Josse, Robert G.; Beyene, Joseph; Kendall, Cyril W. C.; Jenkins, David J. A. // CMAJ: Canadian Medical Association Journal;5/13/2014, Vol. 186 Issue 8, pE252 

    Background: Evidence from controlled trials encourages the intake of dietary pulses (beans, chickpeas, lentils and peas) as a method of improving dyslipidemia, but heart health guidelines have stopped short of ascribing specific benefits to this type of intervention or have graded the beneficial...

  • Project hÉ™li?dx/Healthy Hearts Across Generations: Development and Evaluation Design of a Tribally Based Cardiovascular Disease Prevention Intervention for American Indian Families. Walters, Karina; LaMarr, June; Levy, Rona; Pearson, Cynthia; Maresca, Teresa; Mohammed, Selina; Simoni, Jane; Evans-Campbell, Teresa; Fredriksen-Goldsen, Karen; Fryberg, Sheryl; Jobe, Jared // Journal of Primary Prevention;Aug2012, Vol. 33 Issue 4, p197 

    American Indian and Alaska Native (AIAN) populations are disproportionately at risk for cardiovascular disease (CVD), diabetes, and obesity, compared with the general US population. This article describes the həli?dx/Healthy Hearts Across Generations project, an AIAN-run, tribally based...

  • Effect of low-glycemic load diet on changes in cardiovascular risk factors in poorly controlled diabetic patients. Afaghi, Ahmad; Ziaee, Amir; Afaghi, Mahsa // Indian Journal of Endocrinology & Metabolism;Nov/Dec2012, Vol. 16 Issue 6, p991 

    Background: One dietary strategy aimed at improving both diabetes control and control of cardiovascular risk factors is the use of low glycemic index diets. These diets have been reported to be beneficial in controlling diabetes, and also increase high density lipoprotein cholesterol (HDL-C),...

  • Effects of Wheat and Oat-Based Whole Grain Foods on Serum Lipoprotein Size and Distribution in Overweight Middle Aged People: A Randomised Controlled Trial. Tighe, Paula; Duthie, Garry; Brittenden, Julie; Vaughan, Nicholas; Mutch, William; Simpson, William G.; Duthie, Susan; Horgan, Graham W.; Thies, Frank // PLoS ONE;Aug2013, Vol. 8 Issue 8, p1 

    Introduction: Epidemiological studies suggest three daily servings of whole-grain foods (WGF) might lower cardiovascular disease risk, at least partly by lowering serum lipid levels. We have assessed the effects of consuming three daily portions of wholegrain food (provided as wheat or a mixture...

  • Has carbohydrate-restriction been forgotten as a treatment for diabetes mellitus? A perspective on the ACCORD study design. Westman, Eric C.; Vernon, Mary C. // Nutrition & Metabolism;2008, Vol. 5, Special section p1 

    Prior to the discovery of medical treatment for diabetes, carbohydrate-restriction was the predominant treatment recommendation to treat diabetes mellitus. In this commentary we argue that carbohydrate-restriction should be reincorporated into contemporary treatment studies for diabetes mellitus.

  • LIFESTYLE FACTORS. Donhoffer, Hilda A.; Chan, Y. Michael; Radomski, Manny W. // Wellness Options;2006, Issue 28, p27 

    The article looks a how lifestyle factors, such as obesity and physical inactivity, play an important role in triggering the genetic factors of type 2 diabetes. According to the article, there is a high connection between type 2 diabetes and the consumption of calorie dense diets high in animal...

  • Summaries for Patients. Normal-Weight Central Obesity and Mortality.  // Annals of Internal Medicine;12/1/2015, Vol. 163 Issue 11, pI-30 

    The article offers information on a research on risk of death from cardiovascular disease based on different patterns of obesity. Topics discussed include increased risk of death from cardiovascular disease in people with central obesity, limitations on measurement of body fat distribution, and...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics