Patent's Role in the Case of Carbon Leakage: Beyond the Orthodox View

Jinheng Feng; Ying Shen
January 2014
Annual International Conference on Law, Regulations & Public Pol;2014, p77
Carbon leakage discussed here refers to the increase of carbon emissions outside a country (or a region) with an ambitious carbon pricing regime, such as an emissions trading scheme (ETS) or a carbon tax. There are three channels through which carbon leakage is affected, i.e. the energy price channel, the trade leakage channel (or the competitiveness leakage channel) and the technology and policy spillover channel. Compared to the first two channels, which would lead to the increase of carbon leakage, the third channel is an effective approach to reduce the potential carbon leakage. Particularly, the technology spill-over channel plays an important role in preventing and combating carbon leakage. As probably the most relevant conventional policy tool to environmentally sound technologies (ESTs), patent law is expected to play an important role to facilitate the reduction of carbon leakage. However, the role of patent law in the context of climate change has always been controversial; the overprotection of patents dominated by developed countries has especially been regarded as an impediment of transfer of ESTs to developing countries. Therefore, justification of patent's role in the case of carbon leakage has become a theme of debate in current legal scholarship. This article is formed in this context. It first makes a brief introduction to the three channels affecting carbon leakage. Based on this introduction, the policy functions of patent law will be discussed to justify the patent's importance in combating carbon leakage. Beyond the orthodox view, an unconventional perspective is introduced in this article. Subsequently, one aspect among many proposals regarding the protection scope of patent will be suggested relating to the carbon leakage issue. Finally, a conclusion is given to present the opinions of the authors.


Related Articles

  • A Developmental Approach to the Patent-Antitrust Interface. Cheng, Thomas K. // Northwestern Journal of International Law & Business;Fall2012, Vol. 33 Issue 1, p1 

    The article presents a set of guiding principles regarding the patent-antitrust interface in developing countries. It mentions that any credible approaches to the patent-antitrust interface in developing countries should incorporate development considerations. It highlights that developing...

  • Indian patenting activity in international and domestic patent system: Contemporary scenario. Bhattacharya, Sujit; Garg, K. C.; Sharma, S. C.; Dutt, Bharvi // Current Science (00113891);5/25/2007, Vol. 92 Issue 10, p1366 

    A detailed assessment of Indian patenting activity over the period 1990-2002 was undertaken by (a) examining patents granted by the US, European and Indian Patent Office; (b) delineating patents under various types, i.e. entity-wise (Indian organizations, foreign R&D centres in India, resident...

  • Developing world gets patent aid. Butler, Declan // Nature;2/7/2002, Vol. 415 Issue 6872, p563 

    Reports on plans for the establishment of the international organization Management of Intellectual Property in Health Research & Development, aimed at assisting governments in developing countries to negotiate better patent deals for drug access. Major financier of the organization; Estimated...

  • Product Patents on drugs and Medicines - A critique. Patil, Dinesh kumar D. // Indian Streams Research Journal;Aug2012, Vol. 2 Issue 7, Special section p1 

    India has shifted to a new product patent regime from process patents which was considered as a transition period from 1995-200, All the developing countries and least developed countries were under an obligation to amend the Patent Laws in their respective countries to meet the norms of minimum...

  • Climate change death toll rising.  // Asian Pacific Post;3/19/2009, p10 

    This article reports on the growing number of deaths in low-income countries due to climate change, according to the World Health Organisation.

  • More Climate Change Meetings Considered.  // Coal Age;Jul99, Vol. 104 Issue 7, p12 

    Provides information on the voiced support of some developing countries to a series of meetings on global climate change in Bonn, Germany. Actions taken by the G-77/China developing country group; Role of Michael Grub, author of the book `The Kyoto Protocol: A Guide and Assessment.'

  • Climate change and agriculture in developing countries. Antle, John M. // American Journal of Agricultural Economics;Aug95, Vol. 77 Issue 3, p741 

    Examines the impact of climate change on agriculture in developing countries. Impacts on tropical agriculture; Long-term trends in technology and productivity; Modeling adaptation of managed ecosystems.

  • Who pays for disasters?  // Natural Hazards Observer;Jan2014, Vol. 38 Issue 3, p15 

    The article reports on the responsibility of developing nations for the prevention of climate change and weather-related loss events.

  • COPYRIGHT AS A RULE OF EVIDENCE. Lichtman, Douglas // Duke Law Journal;Feb2003, Vol. 52 Issue 4, p683 

    Many copyright doctrines serve to exclude from the copyright regime cases particularly prone to evidentiary complexity. The implicit logic is that, for these cases, the social costs of litigation would likely outweigh the social benefits derived from offering copyright protection in the first...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics