The clinical case report: a review of its merits and limitations

Nissen, Trygve; Wynn, Rolf
May 2014
BMC Research Notes;2014, Vol. 7 Issue 1, p2
Academic Journal
Background The clinical case report has a long-standing tradition in the medical literature. While its scientific significance has become smaller as more advanced research methods have gained ground, case reports are still presented in many medical journals. Some scholars point to its limited value for medical progress, while others assert that the genre is undervalued. We aimed to present the various points of view regarding the merits and limitations of the case report genre. We searched Google Scholar, PubMed and select textbooks on epidemiology and medical research for articles and book-chapters discussing the merits and limitations of clinical case reports and case series. Results The major merits of case reporting were these: Detecting novelties, generating hypotheses, pharmacovigilance, high applicability when other research designs are not possible to carry out, allowing emphasis on the narrative aspect (in-depth understanding), and educational value. The major limitations were: Lack of ability to generalize, no possibility to establish cause-effect relationship, danger of over-interpretation, publication bias, retrospective design, and distraction of reader when focusing on the unusual. Conclusions Despite having lost its central role in medical literature in the 20th century, the genre still appears popular. It is a valuable part of the various research methods, especially since it complements other approaches. Furthermore, it also contributes in areas of medicine that are not specifically research-related, e.g. as an educational tool. Revision of the case report has been attempted in order to integrate the biomedical model with the narrative approach, but without significant success. The future prospects of the case report could possibly be in new applications of the genre, i.e. exclusive case report databases available online, and open access for clinicians and researchers.


Related Articles

  • Healthcare-related factors affecting the management of HIV infected patients: a systematic review of qualitative evidence. Cheema, Ejaz; Abbas, Asraa; Al-Hamid, Abdullah // International Journal of STD & AIDS;Dec2019, Vol. 30 Issue 14, p1350 

    Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection is a major health concern that is associated with high mortality and socioeconomic burden on both patients and healthcare authorities. This systematic review aimed to qualitatively explore the healthcare-related factors influencing the management of...

  • Sands of Change: Overcoming First World Hegemony Over Knowledge. Murgai, Justin Gaurav; Baker, Charles W. // Journal of Workplace Rights;2011/2012, Vol. 16 Issue 3/4, p439 

    Today, a clear Euro-American hegemony can be seen in anthropological knowledge over what is published and read globally. Online databases such as the Web of Science and Google Scholar, where most published books and articles and works cited come from the Euro-American core, illustrate this fact....

  • The Use of Bibliometrics to Measure Research Performance in Education Sciences. Diem, Andrea; Wolter, Stefan // Research in Higher Education;Feb2013, Vol. 54 Issue 1, p86 

    This paper investigates the fitness-for-purpose and soundness of bibliometric parameters for measuring and elucidating the research performance of individual researchers in the field of education sciences in Switzerland. In order to take into account the specificities of publication practices of...

  • La producción científica iberoamericana en ciencias de la nutrición: La indización en PubMed y Google Scholar. Franco-Pérez, Alvaro Moisés; Sanz-Valero, Javier; Wanden-Berghe, Carmina; Melian-Fleitas, Liliana // Nutricion Hospitalaria;nov2014, Vol. 30 Issue 5, p1165 

    Objective: Analyze by bibliometric technique, the Iberoamerican scientific literature related to the nutritional sciences and retrieved on main search engines with free access through Internet (PubMed and Google Scholar). Method: Bibliometric analysis of scientific production recovered in the...

  • E-government implementation: A bird's eye view of issues relating to costs, opportunities, benefits and risks. Weerakkody, Vishanth; Irani, Zahir; Lee, Habin; Osman, Ibrahim; Hindi, Nitham // Information Systems Frontiers;Aug2015, Vol. 17 Issue 4, p889 

    After more than a decade of comprehensive research work in the area of electronic government (e-government), no attempt has yet been made to undertake a systematic literature review on the costs, opportunities, benefits and risks that influence the implementation of e-government. This is...

  • Distribution, Contents, and Types of Mycosporine-Like Amino Acids (MAAs) in Marine Macroalgae and a Database for MAAs Based on These Characteristics. Sun, Yingying; Zhang, Naisheng; Zhou, Jing; Dong, Shasha; Zhang, Xin; Guo, Lei; Guo, Ganlin // Marine Drugs;Jan2020, Vol. 18 Issue 1, p43 

    Mycosporine-like amino acids (MAAs), maximally absorbed in the wavelength region of 310–360 nm, are widely distributed in algae, phytoplankton and microorganisms, as a class of possible multi-functional compounds. In this work, based on the Web of Science, Springer, Google Scholar, and...

  • Tools and instruments for needs assessment, monitoring and evaluation of health research capacity development activities at the individual and organizational level: a systematic review. Huber, Johanna; Nepal, Sushil; Bauer, Daniel; Wessels, Insa; Fischer, Martin R.; Kiessling, Claudia // Health Research Policy & Systems;12/21/2015, Vol. 13, p1 

    Background: In the past decades, various frameworks, methods, indicators, and tools have been developed to assess the needs as well as to monitor and evaluate (needs assessment, monitoring and evaluation; "NaME") health research capacity development (HRCD) activities. This...

  • Lactose Intolerance and Oral Health: A Public Health Promotional Perspective. Vasthare, Ramprasad; Choong, Elaine Karman; Nayak, Prajna P.; Bhagavath, Ramya; Shanthi // Indian Journal of Public Health Research & Development;May2019, Vol. 10 Issue 5, p221 

    Introduction: The percentage of individuals with lactose intolerance and milk allergy is rising in the populations world wide, with some races showing more predilection towards intolerance. It is being increasingly seen in adults, in addition to its known effects on children. Objective: To...

  • Can I Cancel My Print Case Reporter Collection? Galfano, Paul // AALL Spectrum;Apr2013, Vol. 17 Issue 6, p24 

    The author looks at whether print volumes of legal information such as case reporters can be replaced by free online services such as electronic books (e-books), databases, and social media. He notes that online legal resources can be used rather than continuing with expensive, space-consuming...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics