TITLE

ADDRESSING WHAT ISN'T THERE: HOW DISTRICT COURTS MANAGE THE THREAT OF RULE 68'S COST-SHIFTING PROVISION IN THE CONTEXT OF CLASS ACTIONS

AUTHOR(S)
Starcher, Jack
PUB. DATE
January 2014
SOURCE
Columbia Law Review;Jan2014, Vol. 114 Issue 1, p129
SOURCE TYPE
Academic Journal
DOC. TYPE
Article
ABSTRACT
For almost two decades now, courts have struggled with a seemingly irreconcilable conflict between Rule 23 class actions and Rule 68 offers of judgment. The apparent tension between these two rules arises in the limbo between the filing of a putative class representative's complaint and the court's resolution of the class certification motion. During this time the class has not yet been certified, so defendants are able to make Rule 68 offers to putative class representatives as individuals. Rule 68's cost-shifting provision then pressures putative class representatives to settle before class certification can be completed. In this way an individual Rule 68 settlement offer can "pick off" a putative class representative before a court is able to consider the merits of class certification. Thus, when a Rule 68 "pick off offer is made to a putative class representative, judges are forced to balance the prosettlement objectives of Rule 68 against the benefits of Rule 23 class actions and the need to protect putative class members. This issue has come to the attention of district courts through motions to strike these individual offers. These offers, plaintiffs argue, exert inappropriate pressure on putative class representatives and should be preemptively stricken to protect the putative class. While most district courts to confront this issue agree with plaintiffs and strike the Rule 68 "pick off" offer, this Note advocates for a different approach. By refusing to strike Rule 68 "pick off" offers and providing guidance to parties as to the effect of the offer, courts can simultaneously respect the purposes of both Rule 68 and Rule 23.
ACCESSION #
94074416

 

Related Articles

  • WITHOUT A LEG TO STAND ON? CLASS REPRESENTATIVES, FEDERAL COURTS, AND STANDING DESIDERATA. DeVougas, Daniel D. // Cornell Law Review;Mar2012, Vol. 97 Issue 3, p627 

    Class action litigation has become increasingly prominent within the last decade. Observing this reality, this Note explores an emerging trend at the district court level--specifically, that federal courts appear to be scrutinizing the standing of class representatives to decrease litigation...

  • AUCTIONING CLASS SETTLEMENTS. TIDMARSH, JAY // William & Mary Law Review;Oct2014, Vol. 56 Issue 1, p227 

    Although class actions promise better deterrence at a lower cost, they are infected with problems that can keep them from delivering on this promise. One of these problems occurs when the agents for the class--the class representative and class counsel--advance their own interests at the expense...

  • What Goes Around, Comes Around: From the Rector of Barkway to Knowles. Vairo, Georgene // Review of Litigation;Symposium2013, Vol. 32 Issue 4, p721 

    No abstract available.

  • Address exposure and discovery challenges early in class action litigation. Fisher, Eric S.; Grelecki, Ryan C. // Inside Counsel (SyndiGate Media Inc.);10/22/2015, p1 

    The article reports on the cost of class action litigation and pre-certification discovery process in the U.S. Topics discussed include the criteria that a plaintiff must meet before requesting for class action certification from the court, the results of a 2010 study conducted by the California...

  • Jacob v. Duane Reade, Inc.- Certifying a Class as to Liability Only? Spade, John R. // American Journal of Trial Advocacy;2015, Vol. 38 Issue 3, p585 

    The article discusses the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York's ruling in the case Jacob v. Duane Reade Inc. which deals employee misclassifications, overtime compensation, and an assessment of whether Rule 23(c)(4) of the U.S. Federal Rules of Civil Procedure case be...

  • SHIFT HAPPENS: PRESSURE ON FOREIGN ATTORNEY-FEE PARADIGMS FROM CLASS ACTIONS. Rowe Jr., Thomas D. // Duke Journal of Comparative & International Law;Summer2003, Vol. 13 Issue 3, p125 

    The article discusses the class-action device used in the American civil litigation which concerns with the liability of the attorney's fee and the financial practices in applying class action suits in the U.S. It highlights the practices in civil litigation wherein the losers will pay portion...

  • Identity Crisis: Class Certification, Aggregate Proof, and How Rule 23 May Be Self-Defeating the Policy for Which It Was Established. Whitbeck, J. Britton // Pace Law Review;Mar2012, Vol. 32 Issue 2, p488 

    The article discusses American class action lawsuits and class certification under Rule 23 of the U.S. Federal Rules of Civil Procedure as of March 2012, focusing on the role of aggregate proof in the certification of classes. A historical overview of class action litigation is presented,...

  • SIMPLIFIED PLEADING, MEANINGFUL DAYS IN COURT, AND TRIALS ON THE MERITS: REFLECTIONS ON THE DEFORMATION OF FEDERAL PROCEDURE. MILLER, ARTHUR R. // New York University Law Review;Apr2013, Vol. 88 Issue 1, p286 

    When the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure were promulgated in 1938, they reflected a policy of citizen access for civil disputes and sought to promote their resolution on the merits rather than on the basis of the technicalities that characterized earlier procedural systems.The federal courts...

  • DISCRETION IN CLASS CERTIFICATION. BARRINGTON WOLFF, TOBIAS // University of Pennsylvania Law Review;Jun2014, Vol. 162 Issue 7, p1897 

    The article discusses an abuse of discretion standard in class certification in America, focusing on the class action-related jurisprudence of various U.S. federal and district courts, as well as information about Rule 23 of the U.S. Federal Rules of Civil Procedure which deals with class action...

Share

Read the Article

Courtesy of THE LIBRARY OF VIRGINIA

Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics