Experiments to Reduce the Over-Reporting of Voting: A Pipeline to the Truth

Hanmer, Michael J.; Banks, Antoine J.; White, Ismail K.
January 2014
Political Analysis;Jan2014, Vol. 22 Issue 1, p130
Academic Journal
Voting is a fundamental part of any democratic society. But survey-based measures of voting are problematic because a substantial proportion of nonvoters report that they voted. This over-reporting has consequences for our understanding of voting as well as the behaviors and attitudes associated with voting. Relying on the “bogus pipeline” approach, we investigate whether altering the wording of the turnout question can cause respondents to provide more accurate responses. We attempt to reduce over-reporting simply by changing the wording of the vote question by highlighting to the respondent that: (1) we can in fact find out, via public records, whether or not they voted; and (2) we (survey administrators) know some people who say they voted did not. We examine these questions through a survey on US voting-age citizens after the 2010 midterm elections, in which we ask them about voting in those elections. Our evidence shows that the question noting we would check the records improved the accuracy of the reports by reducing the over-reporting of turnout.


Related Articles

  • Reducing the Costs of Participation. Giammo, Joseph D.; Brox, Brian J. // Political Research Quarterly;Jun2010, Vol. 63 Issue 2, p295 

    The authors address the puzzle of why governments have implemented methods of early voting when those methods appear not to have an effect on turnout. Using an aggregate analysis, the authors find that early voting seems to produce a short-lived increase in turnout that disappears by the second...

  • THE VOTER AS JUROR: Attributing Responsibility for Economic Conditions. Peffley, Mark // Political Behavior;1984, Vol. 6 Issue 3, p275 

    One assumption of Key's "reward-punishment" theory that has attracted comparatively little attention is that voters hold the incumbent party responsible for gil manner of economic fluctuations. A brief review of the survey literature in economic voting indicates that this assumption is in need...

  • Too clever by half? The impact of weighting and adjustments on the accuracy of the final polls. Curtice, John; Sparrow, Nick // International Journal of Market Research;2010, Vol. 52 Issue 5, p678 

    The article evaluates the effect of weighting and adjustment methods used during the 2010 election in Great Britain on the accuracy of public opinion polls. Published vote intentions are compared to aggregate voting outcomes for three political parties. The impact of weights and adjustments on...

  • When Ballot Issues Matter: Social Issue Ballot Measures and Their Impact on Turnout. Biggers, Daniel // Political Behavior;Mar2011, Vol. 33 Issue 1, p3 

    Evidence for whether direct democracy positively affects turnout is mixed, which can be attributed to a theoretical ambiguity about the proper way to measure the institution. The most common measure, a count of the number of initiatives on the ballot, is incomplete, because it unrealistically...

  • METHODS TESTED DURING 1940 CAMPAIGN. Crossley, Archibald M. // Public Opinion Quarterly;3/1/41, Vol. 5 Issue 1, p83 

    The article delineates methods used in testing opinion in nineteen pivotal states in the U.S. during the 1940 Presidential elections, and sketches the trend of voting decisions in these states. It primarily investigates on the public opinion poll strategy adopted by Crossley Inc., a national...

  • Election 2006.  // National Journal;10/21/2006, Vol. 38 Issue 42, p73 

    The article highlights the result of a survey on voter interest to the November 2006 congressional elections in the U.S. A new survey suggests that the current tide of anti-incumbent sentiment will encourage voters to vote this November. A Pew Research Center poll conducted with the Associated...

  • Electoral Salience and Vote Overreporting: Another Look at the Problem of Validity in Voter Turnout Studies. Górecki, Maciej A. // International Journal of Public Opinion Research;Winter2011, Vol. 23 Issue 4, p544 

    The article focuses on a study which examined the impact of two variables, education and party contact, on overreporting of voter turnout in the U.S. Two sets of elections were explored, while both self-reported and validated turnout measures were adopted in this study. Results of the study...

  • ECONOMIC SELF-INTEREST AND THE VOTE: Evidence and Meaning. Feldman, Stanley // Political Behavior;1984, Vol. 6 Issue 3, p229 

    The issue of personal economic self-Interest - people responding politically to changes in their financial well-being-has been a central focus In the economic voting literature. In a recent article, Kramer (1983) contended that people may be acting in a personally self- interested manner despite...

  • Markos Runs the Numbers: Romney's Latino Problem Looks Insurmountable.  // La Prensa San Diego;3/23/2012, Vol. 36 Issue 12, p5 

    The article focuses on the analysis of an electoral map depicting a polling related to the Latino voter turnout for the elections to be held in the U.S. in November 2012.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics