Curriculum Based Measurement of Reading: Consistency and Validity Across Best, Fastest, and Question Reading Conditions

Christ, Theodore J.; White, Mary Jane; Ardoin, Scott P.; Eckert, Tanya L.; VanDerHeyden, Amanda
December 2013
School Psychology Review;2013, Vol. 42 Issue 4, p415
Academic Journal
Curriculum based measurement of reading (CBM-R) is frequently used to screen and monitor progress. It is not clear whether students engage in speed reading during standard CBM-R administrations and whether CBM-R outcomes retain high criterion-related validity in such conditions. This study examined the reading performance of 239 second-to fifth-grade students with standard and modified CBM-R task demands. Students were instructed to do their best reading, fast accurate reading, or read with comprehension. Reading rate and comprehension performance was compared and evaluated along with criterion validity with the Gates MacGinitie Reading Comprehension Test. A repeated measures analysis of variance and test of simple effects were used to analyze performance within each grade. Statistically significant differences in reading rate (p < .05) were observed between the best and fastest reading conditions in all grades; differences were observed between best and comprehension conditions in only fourth grade. Criterion-related validity was moderately robust in all grades for all conditions (>0.60). The comprehension task did not improve the incremental validity when used with CBM-R. Students do not appear to engage in speed reading during standardized CBM-R administrations. Implications for practice and future research are discussed within the context of screening and progress monitoring respectively.


Related Articles

  • A dialogic account of reader–text interactions. Davis, Dennis S.; McElhone, Dot; Tenore, F. Blake // English Teaching: Practice & Critique (Emerald Group Publishing ;2015, Vol. 14 Issue 3, p335 

    Purpose – The purpose of this paper is to present a conceptualization of reading comprehension that extends beyond the traditional cognitive viewpoint on comprehension common in the field. Design/methodology/approach – Drawing on literature and theory from various perspectives...

  • Invariance levels across language versions of the PISA 2009 reading comprehension tests in Spain. Elosua Oliden, Paula; Mujika Lizaso, Josu // Psicothema;Aug2013, Vol. 25 Issue 3, p390 

    Background: The PISA project provides the basis for studying curriculum design and for comparing factors associated with school effectiveness. These studies are only valid if the different language versions are equivalent to each other. In Spain, the application of PISA in autonomous regions...

  • An Entrepreneurship Education Model For Trinidad and Tobago. Ramkissoon-Babwah, Natasha // Journal of Emerging Trends in Educational Research & Policy Stud;Jun2012, Vol. 3 Issue 3, p307 

    This paper proposes an Entrepreneurship Education Model for the developing country of Trinidad and Tobago. While it is understood that entrepreneurship education is critical in creating successful entrepreneurs, it is equally important that a systematic structure be designed to ensure effective...

  • Reading with meaning: the contributions of meaning-related variables at the word and subword levels to early Chinese reading comprehension. Zhang, Juan; McBride-Chang, Catherine; Tong, Xiuli; Wong, Anita; Shu, Hua; Fong, Cathy // Reading & Writing;Oct2012, Vol. 25 Issue 9, p2183 

    This study examined the associations of three levels of meaning acquisition, i.e., whole word (vocabulary), morpheme (morphological awareness), and semantic radical (orthography-semantic awareness) to early Chinese reading comprehension among 164 Hong Kong Chinese primary school students, ages 7...

  • The Content and Purposes of Talk that Accompanies Oral Reading Events: Insights from a Mother-Daughter Case Study. KABUTO, BOBBIE // Language & Literacy: A Canadian Educational E-Journal;2012, Vol. 14 Issue 3, p169 

    This article investigates the substance and possible purposes of talk that accompanies oral reading events within a mother-daughter case study. The findings presented in this paper are from a case study that was part of a larger Family Retrospective Miscue Analysis study that assisted parents in...

  • Teachers' Individual Practical Knowledge about Teaching Reading Comprehension. Rahmany, Ramin; Hassani, Mohammad Taghi; Fattahi, Hamid // Journal of Language Teaching & Research;2014, Vol. 5 Issue 2, p452 

    The present study was conducted to study language teachers' practical knowledge about the teaching of reading comprehension to engineering major students. The participants were 36 master and doctoral holders teaching ESP courses chosen from Payame Noor Universities of Kermanshah, Islamic Azad...

  • Effects of Note-taking and Extended Writing on Expository Text Comprehension: Who benefits? Hebert, Michael; Graham, Steve; Rigby-Wills, Hope; Ganson, Katie // Learning Disabilities -- A Contemporary Journal;Mar2014, Vol. 12 Issue 1, p43 

    Writing may be an especially useful tool for improving the reading comprehension of lower performing readers and students with disabilities. However, it is reasonable to expect that students with poor writing skills in particular, may actually be less adept at using writing to improve their...

  • Using Self-selected Literature to Teach Reading: Inspiring Engagement and Deep Thinking. PARKER, MITCHELL // Practically Primary;Oct2014, Vol. 19 Issue 3, p29 

    The article offers the author's insights regarding the link between self-selected literature and reading. Topics discussed include strategies on how to teach comprehensive reading, key pointers that should be considered on how to motivate students to engage in literature and reading, and the...

  • The New Science of Learning: Building Capacity, Building Fluency, Building Proficient Readers through Research. Miller, Steven // District Administration;Jun2014, Vol. 50 Issue 6, following p94 

    In this article, the author discusses the importance of understanding the actual physiology of learning and its impact on education. Topics discussed include implementation of reading comprehension tests, building communication skills, and need of implementing strategies for reducing reading...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics