The Relationship Between Leverage and Household Spending Behavior: Evidence from the 2007-2009 Survey of Consumer Finances

Dynan, Karen; Edelberg, Wendy
September 2013
Review (00149187);Sep/Oct2013, Vol. 95 Issue 5, p425
Trade Publication
Some recent studies suggest that high levels of household debt and leverage have contributed to the relatively sluggish growth of consumer spending in the past few years (Dynan, 2012; Mian, Rao, and Sufi, 2013). However, this conclusion has not been widely accepted because of the empirical challenges associated with identifying the relationship amid the dramatic and complicated changes in the household economic environment during the Great Recession and subsequent slow recovery. Leverage may indirectly influence spending by increasing borrowing constraints, impeding refinancing, and raising the likelihood that a household will face future borrowing constraints. Leverage may directly influence spending simply by making some households uncomfortable with their leverage compared with some behavioral benchmark. The authors use the 2007-09 Survey of Consumer Finances panel to explore these issues. They find that highly leveraged households were more likely to report cutting back their spending in 2009, even after controlling for other factors expected to influence spending, such as changes in income and wealth. In analyzing that relationship, the authors find evidence that leverage influenced household spending through several channels.


Related Articles

  • Consumers Off the Mat. Johnson, Robert // Morningstar StockInvestor;5/15/2010, Vol. 9 Issue 11, p10 

    The article provides the author's economic weather report on consumer spending in the U.S. He states one reason that recession was severe is due to the effect of negative feedback from news on consumers which concerns them to be conscious in spending their money. A table is presented which shows...

  • Mortgage Refinancing. Krainer, John; Marquis, Milton // FRBSF Economic Letter;10/3/2003, Vol. 2003 Issue 29, p1 

    Reports on the impact of economic downturn on the earnings of various mortgage firms in the U.S. Decrease of consumer spending; Factors affecting the refinancing decisions of the homeowners; Increase on the costs of houses.

  • MALAYSIA.  // Accountancy;Feb1998, Vol. 121 Issue 1254, p81 

    Reports on the British government's announcement of increases in monetary limits and fees under the Consumer Credit Act. Increase of the upper limit for regulated credit and hire agreements.

  • Household debt and consumer spending. Murphy, Robert G. // Business Economics;Jul98, Vol. 33 Issue 3, p38 

    Discusses the relation between consumer debt and predicting future consumer spending. Use of a total debt-service ratio in predicting consumer spending growth; Reason for the violations of the permanent-income theory of consumption; Research implications.

  • Consumer credit rose $9.7 billion in October. Ferris, Craig T. // Bond Buyer;12/08/98, Vol. 326 Issue 30535, p2 

    Reports on the rise in consumer credit in the United States in October 1998. Total outstanding credit.

  • Consumer credit binging balloons over summer. Welsh, James // Crain's Cleveland Business;10/04/99, Vol. 20 Issue 40, p38 

    Reports on the rise in consumer borrowing in the United States, in July 1999. Trends in consumer spending resulting to the increase; Annualized consumer borrowing at the end of the month; Factors contributing to increased consumer borrowing.

  • Consumer credit growth slows. Investor's Business Daily // Investors Business Daily;3/9/2015, pA02 

    The article reports on the increase in consumer debt by $11.6 billion, following an upward revised $17.9 billion gain in December 2014.

  • CONSUMER SCORECARD.  // Nation's Restaurant News;1/16/2006, Vol. 40 Issue 3, p3 

    The article presents a consumer scorecard that represents food purchased for immediate consumption at department, grocery and other stores.

  • CONTENTS.  // Consumer Behavior;2017/2018, Vol. 12, p5 

    A table of contents for the 2017-2018 issue of the periodical is presented.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics