Jarosz, John C.; Chapman, Michael J.
May 2013
Stanford Technology Law Review;May2013, p769
Academic Journal
Reasonable royalty damages are the predominant form of relief awarded in patent infringement cases and, of late, have been a lightning rod for assertions that the patent protection system is out of control. The primary tool used to assess reasonable royalty damages is the hypothetical negotiation construct arising from the seminal Georgia-Pacific Corp. v. United States Plywood Corp. decision in 1970. The construct provides that a reasonable royalty should be determined by hypothesizing an imaginary negotiation between a patent holder and an infringer over use of a patented invention at the time of first infringement. This Article examines the wisdom of the historically heavy reliance upon the construct. We question whether this construct is likely to achieve the ultimate goal of reasonable royalty damages-namely, to provide the patent holder with fair and adequate compensation for the unauthorized use of a patented invention. We find that the foundation for the construct is tenuous and that the use of the hypothetical negotiation construct introduces unnecessary and unproductive questions and conflict into the determination of reasonable royalty damages. We propose that the determination of reasonable royalty damages be based on a direct and objective assessment of a patent's (1) incremental benefits, (2) licensing comparables, and (3) design-around costs. We propose a balancing and weighing of the results of these different approaches without the introduction of artificial bargaining drama, guided by the objective of ensuring fair patent holder compensation in light of the infringement at issue.


Related Articles

  • PROTECTIA PENALA A DREPTULUI DE AUTOR SI COPIA PRIVATA. Grigorie, Ionel // Romanian Journal of Intellectual Property Law / Revista Romana d;2012, Issue 2, p76 

    The article underlines the importance of the protection of intellectual property rights which encourage the development of the culture and the economy. Also the author try to explain the notion of private copy and the, cases in which the violation of author's rights there are considering...

  • PHYSIOLOGICAL STEPS DOCTRINE. Torrance, Andrew W. // Berkeley Technology Law Journal;Fall2008, Vol. 23 Issue 4, p1471 

    The article discusses the unrecognized patent claims that involve within the human body. Limitations had been promulgated on inventions that pertain to the physiological functions of a human body, thus, hinder the development of surgery and medicine innovations and inventions. Other unpatentable...

  • Keeping Your Skepticism out of Court. Bowditch, Peter // Australasian Science;Oct2014, Vol. 35 Issue 8, p45 

    A personal narrative is presented which explores the author's experience of handling legal disputes concerning intellectual property infringement involving businesses.

  • Comments/Letters. Bridbury, Simon // EG: Estates Gazette;8/29/2015, Issue 860, p06 

    A letter to the editor is presented in response to the article "Putting Your Hands Up to the CMA for Infringement," in the August 15, 2015 issue.

  • Balancing interests in standard-essential patents. Lacavera, Catherine // InsideCounsel;Jul/Aug2015, Vol. 26 Issue 282, p34 

    The article discusses aspects of standard-essential patents (SEPs) in the U.S. It highlights the significant of SEP to the practice of a specification to the standard and obligation for standard-setting body participants. Information about the fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory (FRAND)...

  • RECONCILING FOREIGN AND DOMESTIC INFRINGEMENT. Chao, Bernard // UMKC Law Review;Spring2012, Vol. 80 Issue 3, p607 

    The article offers information on the reconcilation of foreign and domestic infringement faced by the patent holders in the U.S. It explains all theories related to direct and indirect infringement. Five categories under direct infringing conduct include, preparing, using, offering to sell,...

  • METHOD AND MADNESS IN COPYRIGHT LAW. Burk, Dan L. // Utah Law Review;2007, Vol. 2007 Issue 3, p587 

    The article presents an essay regarding the relevance and concept of the U.S. copyright law. It explores the impossibilities and philosophical presumptions about the natural reality that is integrated in the development of the statutes wherein it assumes the different mechanisms in accordance...

  • Indirect infringement. Becker, Daniel M. // Nature Reviews Drug Discovery;Mar2006, Vol. 5 Issue 3, p181 

    The article discusses the characteristics and prerequisites of indirect infringement of intellectual property rights under the U.S. patent law. Indirect infringement can be found when a party actively induces a third party to infringe a patent. There were two types indirect infringement,...

  • Evaluating China's Intellectual Property Protection Situation. Zhang, Jim J. // BioPharm International;Jan2008, Vol. 21 Issue 1, p74 

    The article discusses the history of intellectual property (IP) protection regulations in China. In 1984, the Chinese government established its first patent law because they realized the importance of protecting the rights of foreign companies collaborating with their Chinese partners and...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics