Scarce vaccine supplies in an influenza pandemic should not be distributed randomly: reply to McLachlan

Wardrope, Alistair
December 2012
Journal of Medical Ethics;Dec2012, Vol. 38 Issue 12, p765
Academic Journal
In a recent paper, Hugh McLachlan argues from a deontological perspective that the most ethical means of distributing scarce supplies of an effective vaccine in the context of an influenza pandemic would be via an equal lottery. I argue that, even if one accepts McLachlan's ethical theory, it does not follow that one should accept the vaccine lottery. McLachlan's argument relies upon two suppressed premises which, I maintain, one need not accept; and it misconstrues vaccination programmes as clinical interventions targeted solely at protecting the health of vaccinated individuals, rather than as public health interventions targeted at protecting the health of the population as a whole.


Related Articles

  • Pandemic Influenza Vaccine: The US Government Is Not Doing Enough. Osterholm, M. T. // Clinical Pharmacology & Therapeutics;Dec2007, Vol. 82 Issue 6, p635 

    The article reflects on pandemic influenza vaccine and the approaches taken by the U.S. government. It mentions that the current situation of H5N1 avian influenza virus infections in humans and animals in Asia and Europe gives a glimpse of pandemics in future. It opines that neither governments...

  • Mutant menace.  // Down to Earth;3/16/2015, Vol. 23 Issue 21, p31 

    The article focuses on the unpredictable nature of influenza viruses, making them difficult to prevent and manage. Topics discussed include the deterioration of the efficacy of seasonal influenza vaccines to protect the public from avian or swine influenza viruses, the need to raise awareness on...

  • Toward a universal influenza vaccine: from the perspective of protective efficacy. Yo Han Jang; Baik Lin Seong // Clinical & Experimental Vaccine Research;Jul2013, Vol. 2 Issue 2, p71 

    The authors comment on the efforts to develop a universal vaccine against influenza viruses. They describe the threat of pandemics caused by influenza viruses. They explain the factors that prevent the development of a universal influenza vaccine that offers protection against all subtypes. They...

  • The Importance of Including Swine and Poultry Workers in Influenza Vaccination Programs. Gray, G. C.; Baker, W. S. // Clinical Pharmacology & Therapeutics;Dec2007, Vol. 82 Issue 6, p638 

    Sensing the threat of an influenza pandemic, many countries are developing influenza pandemic prevention and control strategies. Such plans often focus efforts on detecting outbreaks and protecting leaders, health-care workers, and outbreak responders. Considering recent research, we argue that...

  • Mitigation Strategies for Pandemic Influenza A: Balancing Conflicting Policy Objectives. Hollingsworth, T. Déirdre; Klinkenberg, Don; Heesterbeek, Hans; Anderson, Roy M. // PLoS Computational Biology;Feb2011, Vol. 7 Issue 2, p1 

    Mitigation of a severe influenza pandemic can be achieved using a range of interventions to reduce transmission. Interventions can reduce the impact of an outbreak and buy time until vaccines are developed, but they may have high social and economic costs. The non-linear effect on the epidemic...

  • Prior Population Immunity Reduces the Expected Impact of CTL-Inducing Vaccines for Pandemic Influenza Control. Bolton, Kirsty J.; McCaw, James M.; Brown, Lorena; Jackson, David; Kedzierska, Katherine; McVernon, Jodie // PLoS ONE;Mar2015, Vol. 10 Issue 3, p1 

    Vaccines that trigger an influenza-specific cytotoxic T cell (CTL) response may aid pandemic control by limiting the transmission of novel influenza A viruses (IAV). We consider interventions with hypothetical CTL-inducing vaccines in a range of epidemiologically plausible pandemic scenarios. We...

  • Understandings of influenza and influenza vaccination among high-risk urban dwelling Thai adults: a qualitative study. Payaprom, Y.; Bennett, P.; Burnard, P.; Alabaster, E.; Tantipong, H. // Journal of Public Health;Mar2010, Vol. 32 Issue 1, p26 

    Background: The 2004 outbreak of influenza A H5N1 and the WHO's recommendation for national pandemic plans has led the Thai Ministry of Public Health to develop an influenza vaccination programme for high-risk adults. To date there is no available information to guide this intervention, and how...

  • Facemasks, Hand Hygiene, and Influenza among Young Adults: A Randomized Intervention Trial. Aiello, Allison E.; Perez, Vanessa; Coulborn, Rebecca M.; Davis, Brian M.; Uddin, Monica; Monto, Arnold S. // PLoS ONE;Jan2012, Vol. 7 Issue 1, p1 

    Limited vaccine availability and the potential for resistance to antiviral medications have led to calls for establishing the efficacy of non-pharmaceutical measures formitigating pandemic influenza. Our objectivewas to examine if the use of facemasks and hand hygiene reduced rates of...

  • A Serine12Stop mutation in PB1-F2 of the 2009 pandemic (H1N1) influenza A: a possible reason for its enhanced transmission and pathogenicity to humans. Ramakrishnan, Muthannan A.; Gramer, Marie R.; Goyal, Sagar M.; Sreevatsan, Srinand // Journal of Veterinary Science;2009, Vol. 10 Issue 4, p349 

    As the scientific community scrambles to define the ancestry and lineages of the eight segments of new pandemic H1N1 strain, we looked for unique genetic events in this virus's genome to explain the newly found enhanced virulence and transmissibility among humans. Genome annotations of this...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics