TITLE

CARBON OFFSETS ARE A BRIDGE TOO FAR IN THE TRADABLE PROPERTY RIGHTS REVOLUTION

AUTHOR(S)
McNish, Tyler
PUB. DATE
July 2012
SOURCE
Harvard Environmental Law Review;2012, Vol. 36 Issue 2, p387
SOURCE TYPE
Academic Journal
DOC. TYPE
Article
ABSTRACT
Tradable property rights-based carbon offsets are widely used as a policy tool for combating the greenhouse gas emissions that cause climate change. However, academics, non-governmental organizations, and market participants have criticized carbon offset mechanisms' economic inefficiency and dubious environmental benefits. This Article traces these criticisms to the microeconomic structure of the offset market. Offsets were envisioned as a way to use self-regulating market forces to stimulate investment in emissions mitigation projects efficiently, but tradable property rights are inherently ill-suited to that task. Consequently, policymakers ended up designing a Rube Goldbergesque scheme that is neither efficient nor self-regulating. The financial intermediation industry through which offsets are certified and traded consumes approximately thirty percent of all carbon offset funding, such that less than seventy cents out of each dollar invested in international greenhouse gas mitigation reaches its target. At the same time, the private sector-led system inappropriately cabins the authority of public sector regulators -- the only market participants with an incentive to ensure the environmental quality of the assets exchanged. Systemic risk is also a concern: the offset mechanism's substitution of abstract, tradable securities for simpler contract-based lending bears an uncanny resemblance to developments in the securitized mortgage lending industry prior to the 2008 crisis. Direct subsidies issued to emissions-reducing projects by a publicly-administered fund could likely achieve better environmental outcomes at lower cost.
ACCESSION #
79892023

 

Related Articles

  • Coming clean for a price. Anderson, Grant // EcoGeneration;Aug2014, Issue 83, p44 

    The article discusses the author's views on whether large emitters of greenhouse gases will participate in the Australian Government's proposed Emissions Reduction Fund and the possible risks and benefits of that. Details include the costs associated with improving a facility's emissions...

  • France's environmental policies: Internalising global and local externalities.  // OECD Economic Surveys: France;Mar2011, p127 

    The article discusses the environmental policies of France in 2011. It says that the strong commitment of the French government to substantially reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions is reflected in its long-term objective of a 75% reduction from 1990 levels to be achieved by 2050. The options...

  • Is cap-and-trade the most efficient system to reduce carbon emissions? Ellerman, Denny; Parry, Ian W. H. // Americas Quarterly;Summer2009, Vol. 3 Issue 3, p18 

    The article offers information on the perspective shared by the author regarding the efficacy of cap-and-trade scheme in reducing carbon emissions in the U.S. The author mentions that it is considered the most effectual means of mitigation carbon dioxide emissions because it is the only...

  • Carbon trading needs a multi-level approach. Maslin, Mark; Scott, Joanne // Nature;7/28/2011, Vol. 475 Issue 7357, p445 

    The article offers information on government policy regarding carbon trading and carbon emission. It says that the expansion of trading in carbon emission was not affected by the failure of the international negotiations on binding the targets for national carbon-emission. It states that carbon...

  • An International Regime in Crisis. Rich, Bruce // Environmental Forum;May/Jun2011, Vol. 28 Issue 3, p20 

    The article presents a reprint of the article "An International Regime in Crisis," by Bruce Rich, which appeared in the May/June 2011 issue of "The Environmental Forum." It discusses the Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) which is based on the principle that greenhouse gas (GHG) reduction...

  • Carbon offsets paper: Request for public comments.  // Energy Management News;Jun2014, Vol. 20 Issue 2, p13 

    The article focuses on the Carbon Offsets Paper, published by the South Africa's National Treasury for public comment and states that the paper outlines proposals for a carbon offset scheme that will enable businesses to lower their carbon tax liability and make investments that will reduce...

  • MPs call for tough carbon budgets -- but not now.  // ENDS (Environmental Data Services);Jan2010, Issue 420, p50 

    This section offers a couple of news briefs pertaining to key issues involving the House of Commons Environmental Audit Committee in Great Britain, as of January 2010. EAC made a call for stricter budgets and targets to reduce greenhouse gas emissions because of fears that the British government...

  • On to Copenhagen. Pope, Carl // Sierra;Sep/Oct2009, Vol. 94 Issue 5, p6 

    The author expresses opinions regarding global warming, associated U.S. legislative efforts, and the United Nations Climate Conference scheduled for December 2009 in Copenhagen, Denmark. The author discusses 4 fallacies about climate change that he believes complicate global negotiations. They...

  • Bonding for Climate Plan. Phillips, Ted // Bond Buyer;8/10/2009, Vol. 369 Issue 33163, p9 

    The article reports on the approval of a bill aimed at reducing greenhouse gas emission by 80% in New York. Governor David Paterson inked an executive order that creates a commission that will draft a plan to meet greenhouse gas emission benchmark by September 2010. The said mandate will expand...

Share

Read the Article

Courtesy of THE LIBRARY OF VIRGINIA

Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics