The effect of conceptual and contextual familiarity on transfer performance

Kulasegaram, Kulamakan; Min, Cynthia; Ames, Kimberly; Howey, Elizabeth; Neville, Alan; Norman, Geoffrey
October 2012
Advances in Health Sciences Education;Oct2012, Vol. 17 Issue 4, p489
Academic Journal
Applying a previously learned concept to a novel problem is an important but difficult process called transfer. It is suggested that a commonsense analogy aids in transfer by linking novel concepts to familiar ones. How the context of practice affects transfer when learning using analogies is still unclear. This study investigated the effect of a commonsense analogy and context familiarity for transfer of physiological concepts. First year psychology students ( n = 24) learned three concepts: Starling's law, Laplace's law, and laminar-turbulent flow. The control group saw standard explanations while the intervention group saw an additional commonsense analogy. The context of learning was the organ system used for two practice clinical cases which differed for all concepts. Testing consisted of 12 new clinical cases. Starling's law cases used the organ system from practice while the other concepts presented in both novel and familiar organ systems. Half of the sample repeated testing after 1 week delay. The outcome was ratings of explanations of cases on a 0-3 scale. The effect of analogy was significant (Mean = 1.24 with, 0.86 without, F(1,22) = 4.26, p < 0.05) but not after delay (means of 1.08 and 0.75 respectively, F = (1,10), p = 0.06) There was significant effect for familiar context (Same = 1.23 (Starling), different = 0.68 (Laplace) and 0.73 (laminar-turbulent flow) ( F(2,44) = 5.14, p < 0.01). Laplace's law and laminar turbulent flow cases in the familiar organ system had means of 1.65 and 1.77 respectively compared to novel cases with means of 0.74 and 0.68 ( F(1,22) = 35.64, p < 0.0001). Similar effects were observed after delay. There was significant decay in performance after delay for all participants (immediate = 1.17, delayed = 0.91, F = 11.9 (1,10) p < 0.01). Common analogies aid conceptual understanding necessary for transfer. Despite conceptual aids, solving transfer problems is difficult.


Related Articles

  • How Effective is Example Generation for Learning Declarative Concepts? Rawson, Katherine; Dunlosky, John // Educational Psychology Review;Sep2016, Vol. 28 Issue 3, p649 

    Declarative concepts (i.e., key terms and corresponding definitions for abstract concepts) represent foundational knowledge that students learn in many content domains. Thus, investigating techniques to enhance concept learning is of critical importance. Various theoretical accounts support the...

  • Examining the Relationship of Scientific Reasoning with Physics Problem Solving. Fabby, Carol; Koenig, Kathleen // Journal of STEM Education: Innovations & Research;Oct-Dec2015, Vol. 16 Issue 4, p20 

    Recent research suggests students with more formal reasoning patterns are more proficient learners. However, little research has been done to establish a relationship between scientific reasoning and problem solving abilities by novices. In this exploratory study, we compared scientific...

  • Cognições espaciais sobre perspectiva em contexto concreto e multimídia. Rodrigues Alexandre, Juliana; Coelho de Souza, Maria Thereza Costa // Psicologia: Teoria e Prática;2011, Vol. 13 Issue 3, p41 

    This research focused on the projective space representation in two contexts: concrete and virtual ones. Two techniques were used to analyse children's capacity to adopt one other point of view: the Zone Trash 3 game and an adapted version of Piaget's classic test The Three Montains, on which...

  • How Multiple External Representations Can Help or Constrain Learning in Science. Corradi, David; Trinenuh, Dawit Tibebu; Clarebout, Gcraldine; Elen, Jan // Journal of Cognitive Education & Psychology;2014, Vol. 13 Issue 3, p411 

    Redundant information has been found to be an important factor that can limit or enhance learning with multiple external representations (MER). As such, it is seen as a crucial factor in understanding how MER can help increase conceptual understanding with low prior knowledge learners,...

  • An Investigation of the Students of Primary School Problem Solving Abilities Depending on Need for Cognition. Polat, Ruşen Hatay; Tümkaya, Songül // Ilkogretim Online;2010, Vol. 9 Issue 1, Special section p346 

    This research aims to examine if there is a significant difference between "the problem solving abilities" of the undergraduates in primary school depending on variables of father's education level, mother's education level, class level, gender and need for cognition level. The paradigm of this...

  • The Relation between Use of Meta-Cognitive Awareness in L2Reading and Motivation among Undergraduate Students. Yaghoobi, Shahla; Yarahmadi, Anahita // Caspian Journal of Applied Sciences Research;2013, Vol. 2 Issue 3, p57 

    Proficient strategic reading, especially reading academic texts, needs some crucial factors such as motivation and meta-cognitive awareness. The aim of this study is to determine Iranian University students' meta-cognitive awareness and the reading strategy most frequently used (Problem-solving,...

  • Practice effects in medical school entrance testing with the undergraduate medicine and health sciences admission test (UMAT). Puddey, Ian B.; Mercer, Annette; Andrich, David; Styles, Irene // BMC Medical Education;2014, Vol. 14 Issue 1, p1 

    Background: The UMAT is widely used for selection into undergraduate medical and dental courses in Australia and New Zealand (NZ). It tests aptitudes thought to be especially relevant to medical studies and consists of 3 sections - logical reasoning and problem solving (UMAT-1), understanding...

  • The Holistic Approach to Clinical Problem Using Fishbone Format: A Simple Way for Clinical Reasoning. Bawazir, Omar A. R. // Education in Medicine Journal;2014, Vol. 6 Issue 3, pe72 

    Introduction: Clinical reasoning (CR) is the cornerstone of medical curricula. It is the cognitive process of solving patient's problem. Different teaching methods are advocated to teach clinical reasoning. Each has its advantages and disadvantages. Aim: to introduce and discuss the fishbone...

  • The application of problem sessions in a hybrid instruction design within the forensic medicine and clinical toxicology curriculum: The Ain Shams experience. Ahmed, Samar A. // Indian Journal of Forensic Medicine & Toxicology;Jan-Jun2011, Vol. 5 Issue 1, p118 

    Context: Using problem sessions as a method of instruction and incorporating it into the body of the curricula, as a hybrid instruction design is not as well established as PBL. Objective: This study aims at studying the effect of the hybrid curriculum design using problem session on the...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics