Beyond Bailouts: Federal Tools for Preventing State Budget Crises

Galle, Brian; Stark, Kirk J.
June 2012
Indiana Law Journal;Spring2012, Vol. 87 Issue 2, p599
Academic Journal
More than two years after the official end of the Great Recession, state governments still face significant budget deficits that cannot be addressed without further drastic spending cuts or substantial revenue increases. The structural origins of the ongoing state fiscal crisis are well known. Excessively procyclical revenue structures, combined with spending obligations that increase with economic downturns, have resulted in a budget dynamic for the states that is not sustainable over the long term. The consensus solution to this problem is for states to save money during boom times (via budget stabilization or "rainy day" funds) and to draw on those savings during recessions. Unfortunately, numerous studies have shown that states do not save anywhere close to an adequate amount for this to be an effective strategy. As a result, during each of the past several downturns, states have turned to the federal government for fiscal assistance-often derisively termed "bailouts "-to address fiscal imbalances. Yet these bailouts have their own problems, including creating an incentive for states not to establish adequate rainy day funds, which in turn increases the likelihood offuture bailout demands. To escape from this vicious cycle, we propose a set offederal policy reforms to facilitate state savings. We offer a menu of policy options, rather than a single solution, because we argue that existing evidence does not clearly explain why states do not save. Therefore, we first analyze the possible sources offailure and then tailor a number of remedies for each; in nearly all cases, it is clear that states would be unable to overcome the problem on their own, making federal intervention particularly apt.


Related Articles

  • 60-Second Expert: The Political Consequences of Stagnation. Bello, Walden // Foreign Policy in Focus;9/10/2010, p1 

    The article examines the political impact of the economic stagnation following the global financial crisis. Although economic upturns were posted at the end of 2009, the halt of public stimulus funding in various countries, including the U.S. and China, has spurred double-dip recession fears....

  • Lots of Creatures Are Stirring In All of The House. Hague, Brian // Credit Union Journal;12/21/2009, Vol. 13 Issue 51, p8 

    In this article, the author comments on efficacy of the government's bailout programs to address economic crisis in the U.S. The author believes that the bailout initiative is not effective in saving companies affected by recession because some have not recovered from delinquency and debt....

  • Global Political Outlook.  // Taiwan Defence & Security Report;Q3 2010, p9 

    The article presents an overview of the global political condition for the third quarter of 2010. It mentions the need for governments to cut spending to bring budget deficits under control on the aftermath of the 2008-2009 recession. It mentions that main risks to watch which include Iran's...

  • THE EFFECT OF THE FINANCIAL CRISIS ON CROATIA'S PRIMARY BUDGET DEFICIT AND PUBLIC DEBT. Sopek, Petar // Financial Theory & Practice;2009, Vol. 33 Issue 3, p273 

    The basic aim of this article is to consider the effect of the current financial crisis on the movements and sustainability of the public debt in the period up to 2013. It is shown that changes in the public debt come from the effect of the primary deficit created, stockflow adjustment, the real...

  • What lies beneath. Ben-Ami, Daniel // Fund Strategy;12/13/2010, p12 

    The article focuses on the ailing economic condition in Great Britain during the global financial crisis. It mentions the negative effects of the said economic turbulence in other European countries, particularly Ireland and Greece. In addition, it cites the implementation of austerity in terms...

  • UK Fiscal Policy After the Global Financial Crisis. Sawyer, Malcolm // Contributions to Political Economy;Jun2011, Vol. 30 Issue 1, p13 

    The paper briefly reviews the fiscal policy in the UK prior to the onset of the financial crisis, and then during and after the crisis. It then advocates the case for the need for continuing budget deficits, which leads into the dangers of attempting to eliminate structural budget deficits. A...

  • Fiscal fantasy. Hinz, Greg // Crain's Chicago Business;1/18/2010, Vol. 33 Issue 3, p2 

    In this article, the author reflects upon the need for tax increases in Illinois, to face the challenges posed by current slowdown. He talks about the budget gaps and bankruptcy conditions prevailing in the state, and discusses the suggestions given in favor of spending cuts. He also discusses...

  • BAILOUT OR BANKRUPTCY? Miron, Jeffrey A. // CATO Journal;Winter2009, Vol. 29 Issue 1, p1 

    The article discusses the causes of the U.S. financial crisis and presents an analysis of the U.S. government's bailout plan of troubled financial institutions. The author states that U.S. policymakers, rather than bailing out large banks, should have allowed the standard bankruptcy process to...

  • EDITORIAL: NEARING THE BOTTOM? Elmeskov, Jorgen // OECD Economic Outlook;Jun2009, Vol. 2009 Issue 1, p6 

    The author reflects on the economic conditions in OECD and non-OECD countries. The author examines growth projections as well as the impact of the global financial crisis. The author also mentions several factors that should be considered to stabilize the financial system including the panoply...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics