Development of an analytic rating scale for Japanese L1 writing

Sasaki, M.; Hirose, K.
October 1999
Language Testing;Oct99, Vol. 16 Issue 4, p457
Academic Journal
The present study developed an analytic rating scale for Japanese university students’ first language (L1) expository writing. Research proceeded in four stages. In Stage 1, we devised a questionnaire to investigate Japanese L1 teachers’ criteria for evaluating expository writing. A total of 102 teachers responded to the questionnaire, and rated the 35 related descriptions according to their importance. In Stage 2, based on the questionnaire results, we either eliminated or reorganized these 35 descriptions under six analytic criteria: 1) Clarity of the theme; 2) Appeal to the readers; 3) Expression; 4) Organization; 5) Knowledge of language forms; and 6) Social awareness. Then, in Stage 3, we attempted to investigate possible weighting of these six criteria. We asked 106 teachers to rate two to four compositions with varied profiles using both a holistic scale and the obtained analytic scale. The results showed that the explanatory power of each criterion can vary from composition to composition, and thus we concluded that the six criteria should have equal weighting. Finally, in Stage 4, we pilot-tested the obtained scale using a new set of 69 compositions. The results indicate that the present scale is both valid and reliable, and that it is superior to a traditional analytic scale in capturing such composition qualities as appeal to the readers and social awareness.


Related Articles

  • Struggling readers get hooked on writing. Furr, Derek; Bauman, Gail A. // Reading Teacher;Mar2003, Vol. 56 Issue 6, p518 

    Describes an expository writing lesson, taught in the context of a modified writing workshop that motivates students to compose meaningful essays. Importance of self-pacing and independent learning; Difficulties experienced by students in deciding what to write; Means for a student to discover...

  • Discourse Complexity of College Writers With and Without Disabilities. Gregg, Noel; Coleman, Chris; Stennett, Robert B.; Davis, Mark // Journal of Learning Disabilities;Jan/Feb2002, Vol. 35 Issue 1, p23 

    The purpose of this study was to examine specific word- and sentence-level features most frequently used in the expository writing of four groups of college writers. Three groups were writers who demonstrated disabilities. Group 1 students (n = 87) demonstrated learning disabilities (LD); Group...

  • Was I Really Bragging? Schlabach, Rachel // Campus Life;May/Jun2000, Vol. 58 Issue 9, p8 

    Focuses on a female student's dismay over a teacher's assessment of her expository writing paper. Discussion of some of the essays in class; Arrogance of the student; Failure of the student to mention her faith.

  • Teaching expository text structures through information trade book retellings. Moss, Barbara // Reading Teacher;May2004, Vol. 57 Issue 8, p710 

    Discusses how teachers can use information trade book retellings to improve student comprehension of expository text structures. Factors that contribute to the increase of teachers interested in developing student understanding of expository text; Common expository text structures that are...

  • Inviting Students to Talk About Expository Texts: A Comparison of Two Discourse Environments and Their Effects on Comprehension. Kucan, Linda; Beck, Isabel L. // Reading Research & Instruction;Spring2003, Vol. 42 Issue 3, p1 

    The purpose of this study was to investigate three questions related to talk and text comprehension. First, does the context in which students talk about text during reading affect their comprehension? Second, does talking about texts with peers influence the quality of students' talk? Third, do...

  • Viewing as a Cultural Tool in the Construction of Meaning with Expository Texts for Young Bilinguals. Moses, Lindsey // Journal of Language & Literacy Education / Ankara Universitesi S;Fall2013, Vol. 9 Issue 2, p72 

    This article provides a deeper understanding of how young bilinguals constructed meaning with expository texts in an inquiry-based setting over an academic year. An examination of classroom transcripts and analysis revealed how Viewing became the most frequently used literacy practice and a...

  • A dialogic approach to argumentation: Using a chat room to develop early adolescent student's argumentative writing. Morgan, Wendy; Beaumont, Glenn // Journal of Adolescent & Adult Literacy;Oct2003, Vol. 47 Issue 2, p146 

    Presents a study on the effect of using a chat room on argumentation skills of students. Strategies devised to develop the students' ability to write analytical expositions; Dialogic approach of using chat rooms; Factors that contributed to the effectiveness of online chats. INSET: USING A...

  • Chapter 14: Discourse Features of African American Students' Writings. Norment Jr., Nathaniel // Readings in African American Language: Aspects, Features & Persp;2005, Vol. 4, p275 

    Chapter 14 of the book "Readings in African American Language: Aspects, Features & Perspectives" is presented. It examines the relationship of culture and language background with rhetorical style discourse based on writings by African American students. The degree of similarity in the writing...

  • Reach for the Stars! Scahill, Marilyn P. // School Library Media Activities Monthly;Feb2006, Vol. 22 Issue 6, p16 

    The article presents a classroom activity in which students will record appropriate information using ethical practices. The students shall develop their own mock constellation based on the characteristics discovered about the real constellations and their myths in written and graphic formats...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics