The Paradox of Institutional Conversion: The Evolution of Complementarity in the International Criminal Court

Bernard Jr., Prosper M.
December 2011
International Journal of Humanities & Social Science;Dec2011, Vol. 1 Issue 19, p203
Academic Journal
The understanding and practice of ICC complementarity changed in the first six years following the signing of the Rome Statute in 1998. The author argues that the shift to positive complementarity was the result of the Prosecutor's efforts to ensure that the up-in-coming tribunal developed a favorable anti-impunity reputation in the context of existing challenges and opportunities. However, the shift represents a double-edge sword. The paradox of institutional conversion is that the positive turn of complementarity has produced adverse unintended consequences which can potentially undermine the Rome Statute system's long-term credibility and viability-the very concerns that motivated complementarity's redirection in the first place.


Related Articles

  • ICC can still bring about 'a new age of accountability'.  // Lawyer;9/27/2010, Vol. 24 Issue 37, p6 

    In this article the author discusses the support of the world leaders and diplomats to the International Criminal Court's (ICC) goal of attaining justice which was discussed in the conference held in Kampala, Uganda in June 2010. ICC has organized the conference to be able to combat impunity and...

  • ASP 2011: COALITION CALLS ON STATES TO SECURE ICC'S FUTURE. Pace, William R. // Monitor;Nov2011-Apr2012, Issue 43, p1 

    The article reports on the calls on states to be hopeful for the future of the International Criminal Court (ICC). It points out that the proliferation of ICC states parties in 2011 reminds the universal nature of the Rome Statute (RS) system ideals. A major changeover of the leaders of the...

  • Principal points of treaty on International Criminal Court. Gerry, Alexander A.C. // Officer;Sep98, Vol. 74 Issue 8, p37 

    Discusses the debate over a proposed treaty for the creation of an International Criminal Court. Dissatisfaction of the United States and six other countries with the terms of the final compromise on the treaty; Concern about the length of the ratification process; Limited jurisdiction of the...

  • AFRICA/ICC Ghana bends the knee to USA. Mbakwe, Tom // New African;Dec2003, Issue 424, p23 

    Reports on the debate regarding the refusal of the Ghana government to surrender American citizens for trial at the International Criminal Court. Immunity agreement with the U.S.; Obligations of the African country to the Rome Treaty; Contradiction to the fundamental American percepts and basic...

  • ICC considers approval for global bar. Nuthall, Keith // Lawyer;9/22/2003, Vol. 17 Issue 37, p7 

    Reports that the International Criminal Court's decision-making body, the States Parties, is debating on whether to recognize an International Criminal Bar as an official advisory body for maintaining a list of available defense counsel.

  • THE RIGHT THING THE WRONG WAY. Wilkins, Richard G. // World & I;Oct2002, Vol. 17 Issue 10, p265 

    Considers the implications of the Statute of the International Criminal Court (ICC). Genesis of the ICC; Jurisdiction claimed by the ICC; Concerns raised by the prosecutorial structure established by the ICC statute.

  • The International Criminal Court. Hunt, David // Journal of International Criminal Justice;Mar2004, Vol. 2 Issue 1, p56 

    The adoption of the Statute of the International Criminal Court in Rome on 17 July 1998 opened up new hopes and raised new challenges for international criminal justice. Unlike the Statutes of the ad hoc Tribunals for the former Yugoslavia and for Rwanda, which were adopted by resolutions of the...

  • Beating about the Bush.  // Ecologist;Oct2001, Vol. 31 Issue 8, p12 

    Reports that United States (U.S.) House Republican leaders intend to block payments to the United Nations unless the Bush administration agrees to legislation aimed at undercutting the treaty binding them to the International Criminal Court. Information on the legislation; Implications of...

  • THE INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL COURT AND THE EVOLUTION OF THE IDEA OF COMBATING IMPUNITY: AN ASSESSMENT 15 YEARS AFTER THE ROME CONFERENCE. Galvão Teles, Patrícia // Janus.Net: e-Journal of International Relations;Nov2014-Apr2015, Vol. 5 Issue 2, p1 

    This article1 evaluates the International Criminal Court's first years of operation, taking stock of the institution's activity. It describes and analyzes the main challenges which confronts this institution, namely: a) universality, complementarity and cooperation; and b) peace and justice. In...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics