Nietzsche's Aesthetic Critique of Darwin

Pence, Charles H.
June 2011
History & Philosophy of the Life Sciences;2011, Vol. 33 Issue 2, p165
Academic Journal
Despite his position as one of the first philosophers to write in the "post- Darwinian" world, the critique of Darwin by Friedrich Nietzsche is often ignored for a host of unsatisfactory reasons. I argue that Nietzsche's critique of Darwin is important to the study of both Nietzsche's and Darwin's impact on philosophy. Further, I show that the central claims of Nietzsche's critique have been broadly misunderstood. I then present a new reading of Nietzsche's core criticism of Darwin. An important part of Nietzsche's response can best be understood as an aesthetic critique of Darwin, reacting to what he saw as Darwin having drained life of an essential component of objective aesthetic value. For Nietzsche, Darwin's theory is false because it is too intellectual, because it searches for rules, regulations, and uniformity in a realm where none of these are to be found - and, moreover, where they should not be found. Such a reading goes furthest toward making Nietzsche's criticism substantive and relevant. Finally, I attempt to relate this novel explanation of Nietzsche's critique to topics in contemporary philosophy of biology, particularly work on the evolutionary explanation of culture.


Related Articles

  • Nietzsche's Apollonian and Dionysian consciousness in the context of community and classroom samba. Naughton, Christopher // Action, Criticism & Theory for Music Education;Dec2006, Vol. 5 Issue 2, Special section p2 

    This article looks at two different concepts of music introduced by Friedrich Wilhem Nietzsche. According to the article, the concepts are titled Apollonian and Dionysian, named after the two Greek gods Apollo and Dionysus. It notes that Nietzsche recognized that aesthetic consciousness is an...

  • What is History?  // Introducing Nietzsche;2005, p24 

    The article focuses on Friedrich Nietzsche's views on the role of history in the evolution of nation's culture. Nietzsche put the blame on history in idealizing and imitating cultures of the great nations of the past. According to him, the so called modern world has no genuine culture it can...

  • Physiology as art: Nietzsche on form. Rampley, Matthew // British Journal of Aesthetics;Jul93, Vol. 33 Issue 3, p271 

    Examines Friedrich Nietzsche's critical reception of Kantian and post-Kantian aesthetics. Nietzsche's `all art is applied physiology' claim; Nietsche's writing affecting his critical aesthetics; Nietzsche outlining `knowing' as shaped by organic processes of the body; Active and reactive...

  • Genealogy, interpretation, historical masks. Gilmour, John C. // Historical Reflections;Fall95, Vol. 21 Issue 3, p493 

    Examines three themes that emerge in philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche's textual approach to historical interpretation. Ways in which the concept of history is affected by Nietzsche's genealogical and cultural analysis; Distinction between two different aspects of the history of punishment;...

  • Nietzsche's Schadenfreude. URE, MICHAEL // Journal of Nietzsche Studies;Spring2013, Vol. 44 Issue 1, p25 

    Recent scholarship shows that in the late 1870s and early 1880s Nietzsche attempted to make contemporary naturalism, especially various strands of evolutionary biology, the basis of a new method ofhistorical inquiry and a new style of moral criticism and experimentation. This scholarship...

  • Anti-Darwinian Evolution.  // Introducing Nietzsche;2005, p62 

    The article discusses philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche's anti Darwinian views on evolution claiming that humanity is only just emerging from its animal past and still in some ways inferior to the animals. With an over developed rational faculty and having been cut off from animal instinctual...

  • New Versions of the Interpretation of Human Nature. Gurevich, Pavel S. // Russian Social Science Review;Nov/Dec2014, Vol. 55 Issue 6, p29 

    The author traces the development of the concept of human nature from the traditional interpretation of man as the crown of creation, typical for classical philosophy, to the idea of the "death of man" proclaimed by postmodernists.

  • Naturalism and the Genealogy of Moral Institutions. Brandhorst, Mario // Journal of Nietzsche Studies;Autumn2010, Issue 40, p5 

    This article discusses two general strategies that have been pursued to explain how moral thought and moral institutions might have emerged. The first is found in the tradition of those whom Nietzsche calls "English psychologists"; the second is Nietzsche's own. I begin by giving an account of...

  • Untitled. DARWIN, CHARLES; NIETZSCHE, FRIEDRICH // 10 Mississippi;Aug2010, preceding p13 

    Excerpts from the books "The Voyage of the Beagle," by Charles Darwin and "On the Genealogy of Morality," by Friedrich Nietzsche are presented.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics