Ferrajoli's Argument for Structural Entrenchment

Ferrara, Alessandro
November 2011
Res Publica (13564765);Nov2011, Vol. 17 Issue 4, p377
Academic Journal
This paper engages with Ferrajoli's contribution to the philosophical debate on constitutional democracy and in particular his conception of 'structural entrenchment', or the basis upon which one can defend the normativity of the Constitution as 'higher law', which can trump or limit legislation, without infringing democratic principles. Ferrajoli's own understanding of 'structural entrenchment' is compared to Rawls's and Dworkin's arguments in support of it. Ferrajoli's position is neither grounded on a philosophy of history, as in Rawls, nor on a version of moral realism, as for Dworkin, but on a formal understanding of the nature of fundamental rights, and in a conception of democratic sovereignty as 'joint ownership.'


Related Articles

  • IL NOME DELLE COSE. IN MARGINE A PRINCIPIA IURIS DI LUIGI FERRAJOLI. Pintore, Anna // Sociologia del Diritto;2009, Vol. 36 Issue 2, p27 

    The author examines certain aspects of the axiomatic theory of law developed in Luigi Ferrajoli's monumental Principia Iuris, dwelling in particular on the theme of lacunae, on the concept of expectation, on conflicts between rights and on the definition of democracy. All these topics orbit...

  • CONSTITUTIONALITY CONTROL OF THE LEGISLATIVE INITIATIVES OF THE CITIZENS IN ROMANIA. Valea, Daniela Cristina // Juridical Current;2012, Vol. 15 Issue 1, p35 

    According to the Constitution of Romania, republished, "national sovereignty belongs to the Romanian person who exercises it through their representative authorities &hellip and through referendum". The aspect corresponds to the reality of any modern democratic system, being actually a form of...

  • Who Are the People? Feffer, John // Foreign Policy in Focus;3/12/2014, p3 

    The article talks about the process by which people become "The People" due to the ongoing conflicts in Ukraine, Venezuela, and Egypt as of March 12, 2104. Discussed are how people accomplish transformation which mystifies political scientists, the lack of instruction manual on how to coax...

  • Constitución y democracia. ¿Límites y vínculos? Díaz, Adrián Rentería // CONfines de Relaciones Internacionales y Ciencia Política;ago-dic2007, Vol. 4 Issue 6, p11 

    There has been a process of change in the notion of constitutionalism since the middle of the 20th century, setting itself apart from its previous conceptualization which was distinguished by its stiffness and the existence of an organ responsible of surveilling the supremacy of the Constitution...

  • CHAPTER TWO: Protecting the Constitution and Democracy. Barak, Aharon // Judge in a Democracy;2008, p20 

    Chapter 2 of the book "The Judge in a Democracy," by Aharon Barak is presented. It mentions the second role of the judge, which is to protect the constitution and democracy. It presents the two aspects of democracy such as exercising the sovereignty of the people and reflecting in the rule of...

  • Eighteenth Amendment in the Constitution of Pakistan: Success and Controversies. Hussain, Mahboob; Kokab, Rizwan Ullah // Asian Social Science;Jan2012, Vol. 8 Issue 1, p81 

    The paper is a critical analysis of the 18th Amendment in the Constitution of Pakistan. The Amendment made after months of deliberations and consensus of a committee represented by all political parties in the parliament has, as claimed by its authors, cleaned the Constitution with the later...

  • Deliberative Democracy and Weak Courts: Constitutional Design in Nascent Democracies. Tupaz, A. Edsel C. F. // Ateneo Law Journal;Sep2008, Vol. 53 Issue 2, p343 

    The article argues that weak courts with a relatively loose requirements for constitutional amendment but with an entrenched core basic rights and institutions encourage dialogical democratic practices. It notes dialogical constitutionalism as a state of affairs where the citizens of a divided...

  • Direito das Minorias Interpretado: o compromisso democrático do direito brasileiro. Moreira Martins, Argemiro Cardoso; Mituzani, Larissa // Revista Seqüência;2011, Vol. 32 Issue 63, p319 

    The category of minority is used as argumentative reinforcement in Law for the defense of fundamental rights. It is destined to groups that were historically marginalized, and claim for public recognition of their peculiarities and the protection of rights. This category, which appeared linked...

  • TRANSJUDICIAL DIALOGUE AND CONSTITUTIONALISM: A RISK OR AN OPPORTUNITY FOR DEMOCRACY? Ferrarese, Maria Rosaria // Sociologia del Diritto;2009, Vol. 36 Issue 2, p113 

    After briefly explaining how constitutional dialogue works and has mostly been elaborated, together with how it is encouraged and made possible by some of the institutional characteristics of the judiciary, this paper addresses a specific issue: the link between the position adopted by the...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics