TITLE

UNDOCUMENTED CRIMINAL PROCEDURE

AUTHOR(S)
Carbado, Devon W.; Harris, Cheryl I.
PUB. DATE
August 2011
SOURCE
UCLA Law Review;Aug2011, Vol. 58 Issue 6, p1543
SOURCE TYPE
Academic Journal
DOC. TYPE
Article
ABSTRACT
For more than two decades, criminal procedure scholars have debated what role, if any, race should play in the context of policing. Although a significant part of this debate has focused on racial profiling, or the practice of employing race as basis for suspicion, criminal procedure scholars have paid little attention to the fact that the U.S. Supreme Court has sanctioned this practice in a number of cases at the intersection of immigration law and criminal procedure. Notwithstanding that these cases raise similar questions to those at the heart of legal and policy debates about racial profiling, they are largely overlooked in the criminal procedure scholarship on race and policing. We refer to these cases as the undocumented cases. While there are a number of doctrinal and conceptual reasons that explain their marginalization, none of these reasons are satisfying given the importance of the undocumented cases to debates about race, racial profiling, and the Fourth Amendment. The undocumented cases import a pernicious aspect of immigration exceptionalism into Fourth Amendment doctrine--namely, that the government can legitimately employ race when it is enforcing immigration laws. In so doing, the cases constitutionalize racial profiling against Latinos and unduly expand governmental power and discretion beyond the borders of immigration enforcement. This weakens the Fourth Amendment and enables racial profiling in the context of ordinary police investigations.
ACCESSION #
65998603

 

Related Articles

  • WHERE TO DRAW THE LINE: THE EGREGIOUSNESS STANDARD IN THE APPLICATION OF THE FOURTH AMENDMENT IN IMMIGRATION PROCEEDINGS AND THE RACIAL PROFILING EXCEPTION. Groff, Stephanie // George Mason University Civil Rights Law Journal;Fall2015, Vol. 26 Issue 1, p87 

    The article examine the egregiousness standard in the application of the Fourth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution in immigration proceedings and the racial profiling exception in the U.S. Topics discussed include decision of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit in the case...

  • TO EXCLUDE OR NOT TO EXCLUDE: THE FUTURE OF THE EXCLUSIONARY RULE AFTER HERRING V. UNITED STATES. Josephson, Matthew Allan // Creighton Law Review;Dec2009, Vol. 43 Issue 1, p175 

    The article reports on the decision of the U.S. Supreme Court on the case of Herring v. United States. In this case, the court has issued a criminal procedure opinion that will reshape the meaning of the Fourth Amendment exclusionary rule. The court also determined whether the amendment rule...

  • PREDICTIVE POLICING AND REASONABLE SUSPICION. Guthrie Ferguson, Andrew // Emory Law Journal;2012, Vol. 62 Issue 2, p259 

    The article discusses the roles of predictive policing and reasonable suspicion in American criminal procedure as of November 2012, focusing on an analysis of police departments and their use of computer programs to predict the locations of crimes that have not been committed yet. The Fourth...

  • DNA, Dogs, the Nickel, and Other Curiosities: Criminal Law Cases in the Supreme Court's 2012-2013 Term. Weisselberg, Charles D. // Court Review;2013, Vol. 49 Issue 4, p178 

    The article report on the several decisions of the U.S. Supreme Court in different court cases regarding criminal law cases during 2012-2013. It mentions the decision of the court in "Maryland v. King" regarding Fourth Amendment and arrestees' DNA analysis, ruling of the court in "Salinas v....

  • Gratitude for Arizona. CastaƱeda, Jorge // Newsweek (Pacific Edition);5/24/2010 (Pacific Edition), Vol. 155 Issue 21/22, p36 

    The article discusses a law signed by Arizona governor Jan Brewer in which the police can question anyone at anytime regarding their immigration status. Topics discussed in the article include concerns that have been raised regarding the possibility of racial profiling, speculation regarding the...

  • RANDOMIZING IMMIGRATION ENFORCEMENT: EXPLORING A NEW FOURTH AMENDMENT REGIME. BENIN, CYNTHIA // New York University Law Review;Nov2013, Vol. 88 Issue 5, p1735 

    This Note draws upon immigration law to analyze a new Fourth Amendment regime put forth by criminal law scholars Bernard Harcourt and Tracey Meares. In Randomization and the Fourth Amendment, Harcourt and Meares propose a model for reasonable searches and seizures that dispenses with...

  • Suppressing Evidence in Immigration Proceedings: The Need for a Lenient Egregiousness Standard and Rebellious Lawyering. Devine, Mikaela A. // Minnesota Law Review;2014, Vol. 99 Issue 1, p313 

    The article discusses the suppression of evidence in U.S. immigration law proceedings, focusing on the author's claim that America needs a lenient egregiousness standard and rebellious lawyering. Violations of the Fourth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution are mentioned, along with motions to...

  • Lopez-Rodriguez v. Mukasey: The Ninth Circuit's Expansion of the Exclusionary Rule in Immigration Hearings Contradicts the Supreme Court's Lopez-Mendoza Decision. Clarke, Eric W. // Brigham Young University Law Review;2010, Vol. 2010 Issue 1, p51 

    The article discusses the court case Lopez-Rodriguez v. Mukasey wherein the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit applied the reasonable standard to the immigration officials' actions and ruled that the evidence should be suppressed on the ground that the entry was a violation of...

  • ARIZONA SENATE BILL 1070: STATE SANCTIONED RACIAL PROFILING? Williams, India D. // Journal of the Legal Profession;Fall2011, Vol. 36 Issue 1, p269 

    The article presents information on the presence and entry of aliens lacking lawful status as per the federal immigration law. Senate Bill 1070 was enacted by Arizona which requires local and state law enforcing officials to detect the unauthorized aliens and their activities. A study is...

Share

Read the Article

Courtesy of THE LIBRARY OF VIRGINIA

Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics