Naturalism in Epistemology and the Philosophy of Law

Greenberg, Mark
July 2011
Law & Philosophy;Jul2011, Vol. 30 Issue 4, p419
Academic Journal
In this paper, I challenge an influential understanding of naturalization according to which work on traditional problems in the philosophy of law should be replaced with sociological or psychological explanations of how judges decide cases. W.V. Quine famously proposed the 'naturalization of epistemology'. In a prominent series of papers and a book, Brian Leiter has raised the intriguing idea that Quine's naturalization of epistemology is a useful model for philosophy of law. I examine Quine's naturalization of epistemology and Leiter's suggested parallel and argue that the parallel does not hold up. Even granting Leiter's substantive assumption that the law is indeterminate, there is no philosophical confusion or overreaching in the legal case that is parallel to the philosophical overreaching of Cartesian foundationalism in epistemology. Moreover, if we take seriously Leiter's analogy, the upshot is almost the opposite of what Leiter suggests. The closest parallel in the legal case to Quine's position would be the rejection of the philosophical positions that lead to the indeterminacy thesis.


Related Articles

  • On Naturalizing Jurisprudence: Some Comments on Brian Leiter's View of What Jurisprudence Should Become. Dickson, Julie // Law & Philosophy;Jul2011, Vol. 30 Issue 4, p477 

    In a series of powerful and challenging articles emerging since the mid-1990s, Brian Leiter has argued that certain theoretical strains in contemporary legal philosophy are 'epistemologically bankrupt', in virtue of their reliance on misguided argumentative devices: analysing concepts, such as...

  • Implications of Indeterminacy: Naturalism in Epistemology and the Philosophy of Law II. Greenberg, Mark // Law & Philosophy;Jul2011, Vol. 30 Issue 4, p453 

    In a circulated but heretofore unpublished 2001 paper, I argued that Leiter's analogy to Quine's 'naturalization of epistemology' does not do the philosophical work Leiter suggests. I revisit the issues in this new essay. I first show that Leiter's replies to my arguments fail. Most...

  • Interpreting Natural Hostory ON ONE HAND. SMITH, WREN // Legacy (National Association for Interpretation);Jan/Feb2016, Vol. 27 Issue 1, p6 

    The author discusses the interpreting natural history. It mentions the need of inquiry approach in group exploration of naturalist, and the importance of for questioning during cultivating curiosity and discovery. It also mentions that the need of curiosity for interpreters and inquiry and...

  • METHODOLOGICAL VERSUS NATURALISTIC LEGAL OBJECTIVITY. CHING, KENNETH K. // St. Louis University Law Journal;Fall2012, Vol. 57 Issue 1, p59 

    The article discusses the methodological and naturalistic conception of law and legal objectivity based on the writings by Judge Richard Posner and legal scholar Brian Leiter. It informs that the naturalistic approach to law and legal objectivity is based on the methods and results of empirical...

  • Leiter on the Legal Realists. Green, Michael // Law & Philosophy;Jul2011, Vol. 30 Issue 4, p381 

    In this essay reviewing Brian Leiter's recent book Naturalizing Jurisprudence, I focus on two positions that distinguish Leiter's reading of the American legal realists from those offered in the past. The first is his claim that the realists thought the law is only locally indeterminate -...

  • The Missing Normative Dimension in Brian Leiter's "Reconstructed" Legal Realism. Ursin, Edmund // San Diego Law Review;Winter2012, Vol. 49 Issue 1, p1 

    The article presents information on a normative dimension that was missing in legal scholar Brian Leiter's philosophical reconstruction of Legal Realism, a school of legal philosophy associated with attack on the orthodox claims of late-nineteenth-century classical legal thought in the U.S. It...

  • Experiment in Education. Dewey, John // New Republic;2/3/17, Vol. 10 Issue 118, p15 

    Focuses on the experimental school launched by the General Education Board in the United States and financed by David Rockefeller. Impact of Rockefeller's involvement in the program on publicity; Response to criticisms against the program; Intention of the people behind the efforts to make...

  • Brian Leiter: Naturalizing Jurisprudence: Essays on American Legal Realism and Naturalism in Legal Philosophy. Kramer, Matthew // Criminal Law & Philosophy;Jan2009, Vol. 3 Issue 1, p107 

    The article reviews the book "Naturalizing Jurisprudence: Essays on American Legal Realism and Naturalism in Legal Philosophy," by Brian Leiter.

  • Naturalising Jurisprudence: Essays on American Legal Realism and Naturalism in Legal Philosophy. Rodriquez-Blanco, Veronica // Mind;Oct2008, Vol. 117 Issue 468, p1091 

    The article reviews the book "Naturalising Jurisprudence: Essays on American Legal Realism and Naturalism in Legal Philosophy," by Brian Leiter.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics