Engineering responsibility: Environmental mitigation and the limits of commensuration in a Chilean mining project

Li, Fabiana
August 2011
Focaal;2011, Vol. 2011 Issue 60, p61
Academic Journal
Focusing on a controversial gold mining project in Chile, this article examines how engineers and other mining professionals perceive and help shape Corporate Social Responsibility initiatives. Compensation agreements, environmental management, and community relations programs rest on what I call a logic of equivalence that makes the environmental consequences of mining activity commensurate with the mining companies' mitigation plans. For example, legal codes enable engineers to measure, compare, and reconcile the costs and benefits of a project. However, the law is neither fixed nor uncontestable, and companies must respond to increased public scrutiny and the growing demands of communities, governments, and international actors. In Chile, campaigns against mining focused on the presence of glaciers at the mine site and the project's possible effects on water availability. By introducing new moral dimensions to debates over corporate responsibility, these campaigns challenged established strategies of commensuration and existing ethical guideposts.


Related Articles

  • GOLD METTLE.  // Concrete Products;Mar2011, Vol. 114 Issue 3, p30 

    The article focuses on the expansion project of the Barrick Cortez Hills gold mine, located approximately 35 miles from Battle Mountain, Nevada. It states that the gold mines consists of reopened, open-pit mine and new underground ramp-accessed mine. It indicates that open-pit mine features...

  • Problems with Reporting and Evaluating Mining Industry Community Development Projects: A Case Study from Tanzania. Emel, Jody; Makene, Madoshi H.; Wangari, Esther // Sustainability (2071-1050);Jun2012, Vol. 4 Issue 2, p257 

    Reporting on contributions to community development is one way gold mining companies communicate the expanse and depth of their commitment to social responsibility. These projects are intended to provide the mine-proximate communities with some of the wealth and other benefits generated by mine...

  • Barrick's Gold Canadian Mine Threatens a Children Watershed. AcuÑA, Ricardo // Canadian Dimension;Nov/Dec2006, Vol. 40 Issue 6, p39 

    The article presents information related to Canada-based Barrick Gold Corp., a gold mining company that says that its vision is to be the world's best gold mining firm by finding, acquiring, developing and producing quality reserves in a safe, profitable and socially responsible manner....

  • Corporate social responsibility in the large scale gold mining industry in Ghana. Arko, Benedict // Journal of Business & Retail Management Research;Oct2013, Vol. 8 Issue 1, p81 

    There has been large scale gold mining in Ghana for at least the last one hundred years. The mining companies with the passage of time have moved from being concerned only with profit making to 'doing well by doing good'. For some years now the gold mining companies have made some contributions...

  • Second time luckier. Forrestal, Luke // BRW;11/8/2007, Vol. 29 Issue 44, p66 

    The article reports that Hillgrove Resources has started the redevelopment of the Kanmantoo copper and gold mine in South Australia's Adelaide Hills by working with the surrounding Kanmantoo and Callington communities in order to prevent conflicts with them. According to project manager Marty...

  • Environmentally responsible business. Romani, Paul N. // Supervision;Feb1998, Vol. 59 Issue 2, p6 

    Discusses the need for businesses to assume environmental responsibility in the United States. Response of businesses to the challenge of reducing air pollutants; Role of the business sector of society in keeping pollutants from waters and take the lead in removing them where they exist;...

  • Green arches. Johnson, Jim // Waste News;4/29/2002, Vol. 7 Issue 27, p17 

    Reports the plan of McDonald's on the methodological approach for environmental sustainability in Illinois. Importance of social responsibility; Concept of environmental sustainability; Enhancement of recycling method.

  • Global Environmental Snapshot.  // Tanzania Country Review;2011, p182 

    The article presents information on the global environmental conditions including the growing concern of desertification in the Central Asian region, the deforestation risks in Central and Eastern Europe in effect of sulfur and nitrogen oxide emission, and the increasing problem on water...

  • Global Environmental Snapshot.  // Vanuatu Country Review;2011, p174 

    The article presents information on the global environmental conditions, including the growing concern on the desertification in Africa, the acidification in Asia and the Pacific and the land and soil degradation in Central Asia.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics