TITLE

The force of dissimilar analogies in bioethics

AUTHOR(S)
Mertes, Heidi; Pennings, Guido
PUB. DATE
April 2011
SOURCE
Theoretical Medicine & Bioethics;Apr2011, Vol. 32 Issue 2, p117
SOURCE TYPE
Academic Journal
DOC. TYPE
Article
ABSTRACT
lthough analogical reasoning has long been a popular method of reasoning in bioethics, current literature does not sufficiently grasp its variety. We assert that the main shortcoming is the fact that an analogy's value is often judged on the extent of similarity between the source situation and the target situation, while in (bio)ethics, analogies are often used because of certain dissimilarities rather than in spite of them. We make a clear distinction between dissimilarities that aim to reinforce a similar approach in the source situation and the target situation and dissimilarities that aim to undermine or denounce a similar approach. The former kind of dissimilarity offers the analogy more normative force than if there were no dissimilarities present; this is often overlooked by authors who regard all relevant dissimilarities as detrimental to the analogy's strength. Another observation is that an evaluation of the normative force of an analogy cannot be made independently of moral principles or theories. Without these, one cannot select which elements in an analogy are morally relevant nor determine how they should be interpreted.
ACCESSION #
59398703

 

Related Articles

  • Ethical Issues in the Biotechnology Industry: Introduction to the Special Issue. MacDonald, Chris // Journal of Business Ethics;Jan2008, Vol. 77 Issue 1, p1 

    The article discusses various reports published within the issue, including one by Melissa Whellams regarding the ethical aspects of a company which offers home testing kits for HIV and another by Cheryl Berg and Kelly Fryer-Edwards regarding direct marketing efforts for genetic testing services...

  • IMMORTALITY. Lustig, Andrew // Commonweal;2/13/2004, Vol. 131 Issue 3, p7 

    Defends the Council on Bioethics under the administration of U.S. President George W. Bush for its stand on ethical issues related to biotechnology. Highlights of the report released by the Council on Bioethics titled "Beyond Therapy: Biotechnology and the Pursuit of Happiness"; Criticism...

  • Nanomedicine–emerging or re-emerging ethical issues? A discussion of four ethical themes. Christian Lenk; Nikola Biller-Andorno // Medicine, Health Care & Philosophy;Jun2007, Vol. 10 Issue 2, p173 

    Abstract  Nanomedicine plays a prominent role among emerging technologies. The spectrum of potential applications is as broad as it is promising. It includes the use of nanoparticles and nanodevices for diagnostics, targeted drug delivery in the human body, the production of new...

  • Chapter 4: Cooperation with institutions and organizations. Laursen, Thomas // Danish Council of Ethics Annual Report;2005, p21 

    The article focuses on the collaboration partners of the Danish Council of Ethics, made up of political stakeholders as well as groups involved in biotechnological consultancy. It notes that the Council and the Central Scientific Ethical Committee hold sessions every quarter for the purpose of...

  • Ultimate Therapy. Rifkin, Jeremy // Harvard International Review;Spring2005, Vol. 27 Issue 1, p44 

    Maintains that ethical considerations of genetic technology should not be overshadowed by its alluring scientific promise. Business fields benefiting from biotechnology; Implications of market-driven eugenics; Ethical issues facing the advancement of genetic engineering; Arguments raised by...

  • Applied Christian Bioethics: Counseling on the Moral Edge. Greggo, Stephen P. // Journal of Psychology & Christianity;Fall2010, Vol. 29 Issue 3, p252 

    Biotechnological developments have brought critical moral decisions into the everyday lives of ordinary people. Christian bioethicists are increasing awareness of value conflicts embedded in health care but fastened to worldview. Yet, to who can earnest Christians turn for assistance in...

  • Thinking across species—a critical bioethics approach to enhancement. Richard Twine // Theoretical Medicine & Bioethics;Dec2007, Vol. 28 Issue 6, p509 

    Abstract  Drawing upon a concept of ‘critical bioethics’ [7] this paper takes a species-broad approach to the social and ethical aspects of enhancement. Critical Bioethics aims to foreground interdisciplinarity, socio-political dimensions, as well as...

  • LIMITS OF LIFE SHAPED BY ETHICS: A SHORT INTRODUCTION TO TADEUSZ ÅšLIPKO'S BIOETHICS. Aszyk, Piotr // Forum Philosophicum;2005, Vol. 10, p19 

    Discusses several bioethical issues in the works of philosopher Tadeusz Åšlipko. Definition of bioethics; Association of life and ethics in the concept of modern biotechnologies; Significance of bioethics in the progress in modern medical technologies.

  • Bioethics and Self-Governance: The Lessons of the Universal Declaration on Bioethics and Human Rights. SNEAD, O. CARTER // Journal of Medicine & Philosophy;Jun2009, Vol. 34 Issue 3, p204 

    The following article analyzes the process of conception, elaboration, and adoption of the Universal Declaration of Bioethics and Human Rights, and reflects on the lessons it might hold for public bioethics on the international level. The author was involved in the process at a variety of...

Share

Read the Article

Courtesy of THE LIBRARY OF VIRGINIA

Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics