TITLE

The use of legal software by non-lawyers and the perils of unauthorised practice of law charges in the United States: a review of Jayson Reynoso decision

AUTHOR(S)
Oriola, Taiwo
PUB. DATE
September 2010
SOURCE
Artificial Intelligence & Law;Sep2010, Vol. 18 Issue 3, p285
SOURCE TYPE
Academic Journal
DOC. TYPE
Article
ABSTRACT
This paper critically reviews the judgment of the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit In re: Jayson Reynoso: Frankfort Digital Services et al., v. Sara L. Kistler, United States Trustee et al. (2007) 447 F.3d 1117. The appellants, who were non-lawyers, were indicted with unauthorised practice of law for offering bankruptcy petition services via online legal software or expert systems in law configured for filing bankruptcy petition forms. The United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit found inter alia that appellants were bankruptcy petition preparers, and not being lawyers, had exceeded their clerical remit by offering legal advice and legal services in contravention of California law regulating legal practice and 11 U.S.C. Sect. 110 of the Bankruptcy Code (2002). While examining the legal ramifications of the use of legal software by non-lawyers in the preparation of legal documents, the paper critically reviews the factual circumstances of the Reynoso decision in the context of juridical and statutory constructs of unauthorised practice of law in the United States. The paper poses the question whether Reynoso should be viewed as a one-off decision bound by its peculiar facts, or good law for the broad proposition that non-lawyers cannot use legal software in legal documents preparation. The paper also notes the possible legal barriers to an unconditional ban on the design, sale, distribution, and uses of legal software by non-lawyers. These range from the First Amendment right to free speech, constitutional right to pro se legal representation, interstate commerce doctrine, to antitrust provisions of the Sherman Act. A regime of best practices for the use of legal software or expert systems in law by non-lawyers is proffered.
ACCESSION #
55983376

 

Related Articles

  • Lawyers Must Manage and Avoid Internet Contamination in Jury Trials. Keene, Douglas L. // Young Lawyer;Dec2010, Vol. 15 Issue 3, p3 

    The article discusses how lawyers can avoid Internet contamination in jury trials. It is stated that jurors often conduct Internet research on the cases they are judging, and improperly communicate their impressions about the guilt or innocence of a defendant before the end of jury...

  • Not as bound by books anymore: Distribution of judicial decisions still evolving. Hoskins, Michael W. // Indiana Lawyer;2/16/2011, Vol. 21 Issue 25, p3 

    The article reports on the judicial decisions whose distribution is still evolving. It states that in the early 1800s, the Supreme Court justices published books on judicial decisions that motivates legislators to create an office that will handle that task. It notes on the current status of law...

  • BANKRUPTCY. Stern, Marc S. // GPSolo;Oct2010, Vol. 27 Issue 7, p22 

    The article discusses importance of knowing the clients in legal profession especially in case of bankruptcy. It states that in case of representing a corporation, the trustee will derive all information from the lawyer and waive any privilege. In case of representing an individual, it is...

  • Landmark Supreme Court Cases.  // Library Media Connection;Oct2006, Vol. 25 Issue 2, p91 

    The article reviews the web site www.landmarkcases.org, from McGraw Hill.

  • Letters. Carter, David P.; Brown, Kerry H.; Wagner, Bill; Shakfeh, Abraham // Florida Bar News;4/1/2015, Vol. 42 Issue 7, p2 

    Several letters to the editor are presented in response to articles including the decline and eclipse of the legal profession in Florida, the major modifications to the profession being considered by Commission on Access to Civil Justice, and the unsubstantiated claim of public records lawsuits.

  • Preference Lawsuits in Bankruptcies. Hawkins, Chris // Facts & Findings;Jul/Aug2012, Vol. 39 Issue 1, p8 

    The article discusses the preferential payments of creditors to companies in the U.S. It mentions the intricacies involved in the transfer of property or property of interests and preference lawsuits that limit the exposures of several legal professionals on bankruptcy courts. It further imparts...

  • Welcome to the new asbestos scandal. Parloff, Roger; Tkaczyk, Christopher // Fortune International (Europe);9/6/2004, Vol. 150 Issue 4, p76 

    This is an article that focuses on the efforts of lawyer Joe Rice in helping companies deal with asbestos litigation. Joe Rice is smokestack industry's new best friend. That's an unaccustomed role for Rice, since he is the co-leader of Motley Rice (formerly Ness Motley), the most feared...

  • Welcome to the new asbestos scandal. Parloff, Roger; Tkaczyk, Christopher // Fortune;9/6/2004, Vol. 150 Issue 5, p186 

    This is an article that focuses on the efforts of lawyer Joe Rice in helping companies deal with asbestos litigation. Joe Rice is smokestack industry's new best friend. That's an unaccustomed role for Rice, since he is the co-leader of Motley Rice (formerly Ness Motley), the most feared...

  • Got Grievance? Morrissey, Siobhan // Time;8/25/2008, Vol. 172 Issue 8, p51 

    The article reviews the web site WhoCanISue.com, founded by Curtis Wolfe.

Share

Read the Article

Courtesy of THE LIBRARY OF VIRGINIA

Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics