Belief, Knowledge, and Science Education

Southerland, Sherry A.; Sinatra, Gale M.; Matthews, Michael R.
December 2001
Educational Psychology Review;Dec2001, Vol. 13 Issue 4, p325
Academic Journal
Epistemological questions about the nature of knowledge and belief underlie many of the controversial issues fundamental to research and practice in science teaching and learning. In an effort to bring some clarity to questions of knowledge and belief embedded within science education research and teaching, we first describe the distinctions drawn between knowledge and belief in both philosophy and educational psychology, each of which have shaped the various definitions employed within science education. This discussion is followed by an examination of the distinctions drawn between knowledge and belief employed by three groups of science educators: the traditional distinctions of the foundationalists that are co-opted by researchers focusing on teacher thinking/cognition, the nonfoundational epistemology of the fallibilists and the evolution educators working from this framework, and the radical constructivists who react to and attempt to move past the limitations of these other positions. In this analysis, we explicate the different ways in which knowledge and belief are understood and operationalized in a broad spectrum of research, we describe the theoretical and philosophical assumptions underlying these approaches, and we explore the important areas of contention (both theoretical and empirical) surrounding each of these distinctions.


Related Articles

  • Measures of People's Beliefs About Knowledge and Learning. Duell, Orpha K.; Schommer-Aikins, Marlene // Educational Psychology Review;Dec2001, Vol. 13 Issue 4, p419 

    Different measures of people's beliefs about the nature of knowledge and learning are described along with the theories upon which they are based. The initial theories tended to be unidimensional developmental theories and their measuring instruments lengthy, in-depth interviews. More recently,...

  • Waiting With Brother Thomas. Sagers, Christopher L. // UCLA Law Review;Dec98, Vol. 46 Issue 2, p461 

    Argues that those schools of thought that is predicated on suspicion of belief to some degree share a range of similarities and are attacked through a set of common criticisms. Clearing the underbrush; Facing doubt on the merits; Illogic of the reductio; Defanging doubt; Consequences.

  • Warrant and analysis. Pust, Joel // Analysis;Jan2000, Vol. 60 Issue 1, p51 

    Analyzes the concepts of knowledge and justified belief. Use of the term warrant in referring the epistemic property; Distinction between knowledge and justified belief; Use of the intuitive grasp of knowledge and the functional role definition of warrant in determining a particular belief;...

  • Belief Auto-pilot. Wright, Malcolm // Personal Excellence Essentials;Jan2015, Vol. 20 Issue 1, p24 

    A reprint of the article "Belief Auto-Pilot," by Malcolm Wright, which was posted on the website LinkedIn is presented.

  • INFERENCES, EXPERIENCES, AND THE MYTH OF THE GIVEN: A REPLY TO CHAMPAGNE. WILK, Thomas // Logos & Episteme;2017, Vol. 8 Issue 1, p155 

    In a recent article in this journal, Marc Champagne leveled an argument against what Wilfrid Sellars dubbed 'the Myth of the Given.' Champagne contends that what is given in observation in the form of a sensation must be able to both cause and justify propositionally structured beliefs. He...

  • Knowledge and the trustworthiness of instruments. Lehrer, Keith // Monist;Apr95, Vol. 78 Issue 2, p156 

    Explores the trustworthiness of an instrument of knowledge as a source of information about the world. Analysis of knowledge; Evaluation system of the person; Skepticism and trustworthiness; Externalist objection that knowledge is acceptance connected to the external condition in a reliable...

  • On the logic of common belief and common knowledge. Lismont, Luc; Mongin, Philippe // Theory & Decision;Jul94, Vol. 37 Issue 1, p75 

    Surveys currently available axiomizations of common belief (CB) and common knowledge (CK) by means of modal propositional logics. Formal method of axiomization; Notion of soundness and completeness theorem; Syntactical concepts and their motivations; Kripke structures; Neighborhood structures;...

  • THE TRANSMISSION OF KNOWLEDGE. Welbourne, Michael // Philosophical Quarterly;Jan79, Vol. 29 Issue 114, p1 

    Comments on the idea that knowledge is transmissible. Mechanisms involved in the transmission of knowledge; Conditions for the successful transmission of knowledge; Role of belief in knowledge transmission; Transmission of knowledge through a chain of authorities;

  • The inescapability of Gettier problems. Zagzebski, Linda // Philosophical Quarterly;Jan94, Vol. 44 Issue 174, p65 

    Argues that it is not possible to avoid Gettier counter-examples given the assumption that the relation between justification and truth is close but not inviolable. Claim that either justified true beliefs are insufficient for knowledge or justification must be reconceived to make it...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics