Eastern Jews vs. Western Jews: the Ahad Ha'am-Herzl dispute and its cultural and social implications

Goldstein, Yossi
December 2010
Jewish History;Dec2010, Vol. 24 Issue 3/4, p355
Academic Journal
The conflict between Herzl and Ahad Ha'am encapsulated the cultural divide that separated the two, as well as it reflected the political and ideological rift separating East from West. The Eastern block wished Zionism to maintain strong ties to a sense of Jewish continuity (if not necessarily to traditional Jewish practice). The Western one was more cosmopolitan and assimilationist in its bent. From the first Zionist Congress onward, Ahad Ha'am assumed the role of Herzl's chief opponent. At first, he was a voice crying in the wilderness, but within seven years, he headed a united front whose members sought to remove Herzl or at least force him into a minority. The point of no return was reached in a clash known as the 'Alteneuland Affair,' whose personal side was as strong as its other aspects, if not more so. For after this episode concluded with this defeat and Herzl's victory, Ahad Ha'am bowed out of all active Zionist political life.


Related Articles

  • Theodor Herzl: Political Activity and Achievements. Friedman, Isaiah // Israel Studies;Fall2004, Vol. 9 Issue 3, p46 

    Looks into the Zionist movement led by Theodor Herzl to combat anti-Semitism. Views of Herzl on anti-Semitism and Zionism; Steps taken by Herzl to promote the Zionist movement in anti-Semitic countries; Support gained by the Zionist movement from philosemites and the German government.

  • Roots of Modern Conspiracy Theories. Khan, Aftab Ahmad // Defence Journal;2012, Vol. 15 Issue 7, p51 

    It is noted that in the latter part of the 19th century, Zionism originated in eastern and central Europe and a new impetus was given to it by Austrian journalist Theodor Herzl. It is stated that the "Protocols of elders of Zion" adds credibility to the conspiracy theories, through the Russian...

  • THE GOD THAT DID NOT FAIL. Peretz, Martin // New Republic;09/08/97-09/15/97, Vol. 217 Issue 10/11, Zionism at 100 p2 

    Describes the efforts of Theodor Herzl in founding a Jewish homeland in Palestine. History of the Zionist movement; Highlights of the First Zionist Congress; Overview of his book "The Jewish State"; Obstacles to Zionism; Clashes between Israelis and Palestinian Arabs; Examination of Zionism as...

  • Zionism's Illusions Become Clear: Israel Has Failed as a Sanctuary for Jews. Brownfeld, Allan C. // Washington Report on Middle East Affairs;Jul/Aug2004, Vol. 23 Issue 6, p73 

    As a prophet, Theodor Herzl, Zionism's primary architect and founding father, seems to have failed in his understanding of the future and where his philosophy would lead. Far better prophets were the founding fathers of American Reform Judaism, who rejected Jewish nationalism and looked forward...

  • Gentile reception of Herzlian zionism, a reconsideration. Levenson, Alan // Jewish History;Jun2002, Vol. 16 Issue 2, p187 

    This paper examines the gentile reception of Herzlian Zionism in its first decade as reflected in the journal Die Welt and in the writings of three supporters of Herzl. Despite defining itself as the party of Autoemancipation, Herzlian Zionists avidly sought to demonstrate gentile concern,...

  • The Utopia of Theodor Herzl. Zilbersheid, Uri // Israel Studies;Fall2004, Vol. 9 Issue 3, p80 

    Discusses the utopian vision of Zionist leader Theodor Herzl. Concept of utopianism and the place of Herzl in the general and Zionist utopian tradition; Transformation of Herzl into a utopist; Preconditions for the realization of the utopian vision and the transition to the utopian stage.

  • The Purge of the Dissidents, Hebrew Union College and Zionism, 1903--1907. Parzen, Herbert // Jewish Social Studies;Summer/Fall75, Vol. 37 Issue 3/4, p291 

    The article focuses on the role of the dissidents at the Hebrew Union College in New York City in promoting the cause of Zionism. Theodor Herzl published his Judenstaast in 1896 which provided Herzl's plan for creating a Jewish state arrived at after contemplating other solutions as well as...

  • Theodore Herzl's The Jewish State: Prophetic Rhetoric in the Service of Political Objectives. Kiewe, Amos // Journal of Communication & Religion;Sep2003, Vol. 26 Issue 2, p208 

    Theodore Herzl's The Jewish State, published in 1896 ushered in a new and productive era of modem Zionism. Herzl's tract was successful beyond expectations as his thoughts outlined in the text culminated in the actualization of his dream and the establishment of the State of Israel some 50 years...

  • BASILEA 1897: QUANDO IL SIONISMO SI FECE PARLAMENTO. Compagna, Luigi // Nuova Rivista Storica;set-dic2011, Vol. 95 Issue 3, p977 

    The article discusses the First Zionist Congress, the inaugural congress of the Zionist Organization (to become the World Zionist Organization-WZO in 1960) held in Basel, Switzerland, from August 29 to August 31, 1897. It was convened and chaired by Theodor Herzl, the founder of the modern...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics