Extreme and acquiescence bias in a bi-ethnic population

Baron-Epel, Orna; Kaplan, Giora; Weinstein, Ruth; Green, Manfred S.
October 2010
European Journal of Public Health;Oct2010, Vol. 20 Issue 5, p543
Academic Journal
Background: Extreme and acquiescence biases are the tendency to give a positive or extreme answer regardless of the ‘true’ answer. These biases may compromise comparisons of attitudes regarding health between population groups. The aim of the study was to measure the extent of extreme and acquiescence biases and identify factors associated with them in two ethnic groups: Jews and Arabs in Israel. Methods: A random telephone survey was conducted during 2006, interviewing 2322 Jews and 809 Arabs. Three attitude questions were presented twice with opposite wording to measure extreme and acquiescence biases in these two groups. Results: Extreme bias ranged from 2 to 14% among Jews and from 6 to 29% among Arabs, depending on the question. Acquiescence bias ranged from 2 to 10% among Jews and 5–19% among Arabs. The less educated respondents gave more extreme biased responses for all items. The older respondents gave more extreme answers for two out of the three questions tested. After adjusting for age and education the odds ratio (OR) of giving more extreme biased answers was higher among Arabs compared with Jews for all three questions [OR = 2.49, confidence interval (CI) = 1.87, 3.31; OR = 2.33, CI = 1.75, 3.10; and OR = 2.94, CI = 1.83–4.71, respectively, for each question]. Conclusions: Levels of response biases are higher in the Arab minority population compared with the majority Jewish population and depended on the subject, age and education.


Related Articles

  • Locating a Special Population Using Random Digit Dialing. Blair, Johnny; Czaja, Ronald // Public Opinion Quarterly;Winter82, Vol. 46 Issue 4, p585 

    Frequently, researchers are only interested in specific subgroups of the total population. Waksberg (1978) has designed a two-stage method of selecting equal- probability samples of the general population using random digit dialing. The present research proposes and illustrates a modification of...

  • FIREARMS AND COMMUNITY FEELINGS OF SAFETY. Hemenway, David; Solnick, Sara J.; Azrael, Deborah R. // Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology;Fall95, Vol. 86 Issue 1, p121 

    The article explores whether increased gun ownership raises or lowers the perceived safety of others in the community by looking at subjective beliefs. Data were gathered from a national random-digital-dial telephone survey of adults eighteen years and older. Due to stratification, gun owners...

  • Reliability of Random Digit Dialing Calls to Enumerate an Adult Female Population. Glaser, Sally L.; Stearns, Cynthia B. // American Journal of Epidemiology;May2002, Vol. 155 Issue 10, p972 

    Challenges to random digit dialing have been documented, but the reliability of random digit dialing outcomes from telephone number calling, household identification, and enumeration has never been addressed, despite its potential to bias population representativeness by affecting completeness...

  • Bluetooth? That's an Odd Name.  // Wireless Review;02/01/2000, Vol. 17 Issue 3, p64 

    Presents information on a series of random calls to carriers of wireless telephones in the United States to determine how a customer might be treated and the accuracy of distributed information about a technological innovation.

  • Attributes of questions and interviewers as correlates of interviewing performance. Presser, Stanley; Zhao, Shanyang // Public Opinion Quarterly;Summer92, Vol. 56 Issue 2, p236 

    The article examines the contribution of questionnaire design in controlling interviewer's performance in asking question. For the study, two trained students monitored 79 interviews conducted by 40 interviewers at the "Maryland Survey Research Center," in Maryland on a statewide random digit...

  • Motivators for Seeking Gambling-Related Treatment Among Ontario Problem Gamblers. Suurvali, Helen; Hodgins, David; Toneatto, Tony; Cunningham, John // Journal of Gambling Studies;Jun2012, Vol. 28 Issue 2, p273 

    A random digit dialing telephone survey was used to interview 8,467 adults in Ontario, Canada. The NODS-CLiP was used to identify a representative sample of 730 gamblers (54.3% male, mean age 45.3 years) with possible past year gambling problems in order to explore factors that might affect...

  • CAN YOU ASK THAT OVER THE TELEPHONE? CONDUCTING SENSITIVE OR CONTROVERSIAL RESEARCH USING RANDOM-DIGIT DIALING. Bell, H.; Busch, N. Bridget; DiNitto, D. // Medicine & Law (World Association for Medical Law);2006, Vol. 25 Issue 1, p59 

    Social science, medical, and legal researchers often study sensitive or controversial topics and behaviors. This research raises methodological and ethical issues. Using examples from the literature and a recent statewide telephone prevalence survey on sexual assault, we focus on the relative...

  • Q&A with MANISH BHATIA.  // Editor & Publisher;Jan2008, Vol. 141 Issue 1, p26 

    An interview with Manish Bhatia, president of global services for Nielsen Online, is presented. He says that user panel is the product that the company is known for the most. He states that random digit dialing (RDD) gives the company a better quality panel. He mentions that the panel members...

  • Validity of Random-Digit-Dialing in Recruiting Controls in a Case-Control Study. Wang, Peizhong Peter; Dicks, Elizabeth; Xianying Gong; Buehler, Sharon; Jinhui Zhao; Squires, Josh; Younghusband, Banfield; McLaughlin, John R.; Parfrey, Patrick S. // American Journal of Health Behavior;Sep/Oct2009, Vol. 33 Issue 5, p513 

    Objectives: To evaluate whether the participating controls represented the underlying population In a colorectal cancer case-control study In a geographically Isolated North American population. Methods: The characteristics of the study controls recruited through Random-digit-dialing (RDD) were...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics