Getting to Darwin: Obstacles to Accepting Evolution by Natural Selection

Thagard, Paul; Findlay, Scott
June 2010
Science & Education;Jun2010, Vol. 19 Issue 6-8, p625
Academic Journal
Darwin’s theory of evolution by natural selection is central to modern biology, but is resisted by many people. This paper discusses the major psychological obstacles to accepting Darwin’s theory. Cognitive obstacles to adopting evolution by natural selection include conceptual difficulties, methodological issues, and coherence problems that derive from the intuitiveness of alternative theories. The main emotional obstacles to accepting evolution are its apparent conflict with valued beliefs about God, souls, and morality. We draw on the philosophy of science and on a psychological theory of cognitive and emotional belief revision to make suggestions about what can be done to improve acceptance of Darwinian ideas.


Related Articles

  • Charles Darwin and Evolution: Illustrating Human Aspects of Science. Kampourakis, Kostas; McComas, William F. // Science & Education;Jun2010, Vol. 19 Issue 6-8, p637 

    Recently, the nature of science (NOS) has become recognized as an important element within the K-12 science curriculum. Despite differences in the ultimate lists of recommended aspects, a consensus is emerging on what specific NOS elements should be the focus of science instruction and inform...

  • Why Evolution Is the Organizing Principle for Biology. Zimmerman, Michael // Phi Kappa Phi Forum;Spring2009, Vol. 89 Issue 1, p4 

    The article provides an explanation on why the theory of evolution formulated by scientist Charles Darwin is considered as the organizing principle for biology. It notes that Darwin's reasoning on the theory of natural selection is being adopted by biologists. It also cites the statement of...

  • Arts and the peacock's tail that wagged evolutionary aesthetics. ACHRATI, AHMED // Rock Art Research;Nov2011, Vol. 28 Issue 2, p174 

    The article discusses evolutionary aesthetics in response to an article by Marco Antônio Corrêa Varella, Altay Alves Lino de Souza, and José Henrique Benedetti Piccoli Ferreira. Topics addressed include the relationship between evolution and aesthetics, scientist Charles Darwin's theory...

  • DARVINIZAM I EVOLUCIJA ÄŒOVEKA. Aćimović, Mirko // Annual Review of the Faculty of Philosophy / Godisnjak Filozofsk;2009, Vol. 34 Issue 1/2, p125 

    In this paper the author deals with the basis of modern anthropology, in the way it is given by Darwin's biological anthropology and Hekels monistic philosophy, and continued by neo-darwinists, especially by Dobzanski and Dockins.

  • Let's Have No More Monkey Trials. Krauthammer, Charles // Time;8/8/2005, Vol. 166 Issue 6, p78 

    Comments on the attempts in the U.S. to invade science, and most particularly evolution, with religion. Efforts of conservative school-board members in Kansas to rewrite statewide standards for teaching evolution; Examples of similar anti-Darwinian mandates; Reference to the notorious Scopes...

  • Darwinismo y religión en el Reino Unido durante el periodo Mid-Victoriano. PEREIRO, James // Anuario de Historia de la Iglesia;2009, Vol. 18, p27 

    The impact of Darwin's Origin of Species was reinforced in the religious sphere by the publication of Essays and Reviews a few months later. Evolutionism and German exegetical theories seemed to undermine the foundations of the faith. The negative reactions to evolutionism, however, were not...

  • Spin doctoring Darwin. Gould, Stephen Jay // Natural History;Jul95, Vol. 104 Issue 7, p6 

    Provides observations about the origin of man. Theories of Sigmund Freud and Charles Darwin on natural selection; Physical reconstruction; Impact of evolution on species; Evolution as a summation of fortuitous contingencies; Consideration of the organs and devices that aid individuals in sexual...

  • Darwin's Impact on Paleontology. Valentine, James W. // BioScience;Jun1982, Vol. 32 Issue 6, p513 

    Darwin converted most paleontologists to evnlutiun but not to natural selection; the patterns of fossil groups were not what Darwin supposed. Therefore a number of mostly vitalistic explanations were preferred or embraced and belatedly discarded as the evolutionary synthesis developed. Today,...

  • Darwin's Untimely Burial. Gould, Stephen Jay // Natural History;Oct76, Vol. 85 Issue 8, p24 

    Illustrates the essence of Darwinian theory of natural selection. Principles of natural selection; Analogy of natural selection with artificial selection; Assessment of independent criterion of fitness in terms of differential survival; Failure of scientist Charles Darwin to undermine his...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics