Scientific Experts and the Controversy About Teaching Creation/Evolution in the UK Press

Allgaier, Joachim
June 2010
Science & Education;Jun2010, Vol. 19 Issue 6-8, p797
Academic Journal
The issue whether creationist accounts of the origins of life should be taught in science education alongside or even instead Darwin’s theory of evolution is controversial in many countries. In 2002 there was a controversy around teaching creationism in science classes at a secondary school in England. The research presented in this paper uses this controversy around teaching creationism/evolution as case study to find out more about the public representation of science education. Here it focuses on the question who the experts were that appeared in the press coverage and examines the role of scientific experts in this controversy. Expertise is a key resource in many public controversies involving science and can also have an impact on decision-making processes and on the public opinion. Also the way expert sources are presented in media accounts of socio-scientific controversies can have an effect on how their credibility is perceived and the arguments being made.


Related Articles

  • Teaching Darwinian Evolution: Learning from Religious Education. Stolberg, Tonie L. // Science & Education;Jun2010, Vol. 19 Issue 6-8, p679 

    This article examines what science education might be able to learn from phenomenological religious education’s attempts to teach classes where students hold a plurality of religious beliefs. Recent statements as to how best to accomplish the central pedagogical concept of ‘learning...

  • From the President. Ward, Daniel // American Biology Teacher (National Association of Biology Teache;Feb2011, Vol. 73 Issue 2, p64 

    A message from the president of the U.S. National Association of Biology Teachers (NABT) is presented. Topics include a brief overview of Darwin Day, which is a global celebration held on or around the birth date of English naturalist Charles Darwin, February 12th, the mission of Darwin Day,...

  • Darwin's "Imaginary Illustrations": Creatively Teaching Evolutionary Concepts & the Nature of Science. Love, Alan c. // American Biology Teacher (National Association of Biology Teache;Feb2010, Vol. 72 Issue 2, p82 

    An overlooked feature of Darwin's work is his use of "imaginary illustrations" to show that natural selection is competent to produce adaptive evolutionary change When set in the context of Darwin's methodology, these thought experiments provide a novel way to teach natural selection and the...

  • Darwin Digital Library of Evolution.  // Natural History;Feb2006, Vol. 115 Issue 1, p61 

    This article focuses on the launch of the Darwin Digital Library of Evolution, as of February 2006. Launched in conjunction with the exhibition Darwin, the Darwin Digital Library of Evolution (DDLE), at http://darwinlibrary.amnh.org, is the first Web site dedicated to the intellectual genesis...

  • Was Louis Pasteur Anti-Evolution? Cross, John // Skeptic;2007, Vol. 13 Issue 1, p13 

    The article discusses French chemist Louis Pasteur's view of Darwin's theory of evolution. According to Nobel Laureate Joshua Lederberger, Pasteur was somewhat skeptical of the theory, but not an opponent. He expressed an open mind on the subject and wanted to see more proof. The author also...

  • Winter 1859. Dorit, Robert L. // American Scientist;Jul/Aug2010, Vol. 98 Issue 4, p286 

    The article discusses the history of biology, focusing on transitions in understanding that occurred in November and December 1859 with the publication of "On the Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection," by Charles Darwin and the presentation of experimental results by scientist Louis...

  • Darwin's dangerous idea. Dennett, Daniel C. // Sciences;May/Jun95, Vol. 35 Issue 3, p34 

    Focuses on the implications of Charles Darwin's fundamental idea on the evolution of life on earth. Creationist thinkers' opposition to Darwin's published book `The Origin of Species'; Influence of Darwin's ideas on other scientists.

  • Human origins. Johanson, Donald C. // National Forum;Winter96, Vol. 76 Issue 1, p24 

    Presents scientific explanations on the origin of man. Charles Darwin and his theory of human evolution; Fossil discoveries in support of human evolution; Advent of the new paleoanthropology as a result of the discovery of the East Africa Man.

  • Teaching Evolution: Guide to Critical Analysis.  // Points of View: Teaching Evolution;3/1/2016, p4 

    This article offers a critical guide to the controversial issue of teaching the concept of evolution. The article discusses criteria in understanding the issue, such as distinguishing between fact and opinion and recognizing point and counterpoint arguments. Also presented are exercises that...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics