TITLE

From Plato to Frege: Paradigms of Predication in the History of Ideas

AUTHOR(S)
Meixner, Uwe
PUB. DATE
October 2009
SOURCE
Metaphysica;Oct2009, Vol. 10 Issue 2, p199
SOURCE TYPE
Academic Journal
DOC. TYPE
Article
ABSTRACT
One of the perennial questions of philosophy concerns the simple statements which say that an object is so and so or that such and such objects are so and so related: simple predicative statements. Do such statements have an ontological basis, and if so, what is that basis? The answer to this question determines—or in any case, is expressive of—a specific fundamental outlook on the world. In the course of the history of Western philosophy, various philosophers have given various answers to the question of predication. This essay presents the main, crucial answers: the paradigms and theories of predication of the Sophists (and of all later radical relativists), of Plato, of Aristotle, of the Aristotelian-minded non-nominalists, of Leibniz, and of Frege. In addition, the essay follows (to some extent) the most influential— the Aristotelian or mereological—paradigm of predication in its continuity and modification through the many centuries of its reign. However, the essay is not content to adopt the merely historical point of view; it also poses the question of adequacy. Prior to Frege, there was no philosophically adequate theory of predication, and the essay points out the shortcomings (besides aspects that can be viewed as advantages) of each pre-Fregean predication theory considered in it. Frege, in the nineteenth century, brought the philosophy of predication on the right track, but his own theory of predication has its own deficits. The essay ends with the presentation of a theory of predication that the author himself considers adequate.
ACCESSION #
49013518

 

Related Articles

  • The Idea of a Highest Divine Principle--Founding Reason and Spirituality. A Necessary Concept of a Comparative Philosophy? Bickmann, Claudia // Religions;Dec2012, Vol. 3 Issue 4, p1025 

    By reference to the Platonic, Aristotelian, and Neo-Platonic philosophical traditions (and then to German Idealism, including Husserl and Heidegger), I will indicate the way in which the concept of reason--on the one side--depends on the horizon of spirituality (by searching for the ultimate...

  • SOCIOLOÅ KI ZNAKOVI ESTETIKE U LUÄŒI MIKROKOZMA. Živković, Predrag // Socioloska Luca;2011, Vol. 5 Issue 1, p17 

    Our works presents comparison of esthetic methods of two majestics Plato and Petar II Petrovic Njegos. Plato's methodological contemplation is related with his metaphysics reflections. So his dialectical method does not only depends on the public speaking skills and rotation of questions and...

  • El argumento del objeto del pensamiento en el tratado aristotélico Sobre las Ideas (Peri ideōn). Varela, José Edgar González // Diánoia;may2008, Vol. 53 Issue 60, p53 

    There are five platonic arguments for the existence of Ideas in Aristotle's treatise On Ideas (Peri ideōn). According to Metaphysics A 9 two of these arguments are "more accurate" than the others. The standard interpretation of this distinction claims that the "more accurate" arguments are...

  • The King of Philosophers. Robinson, Dave // Introducing Plato;9/ 1/2005, p3 

    The article focuses on philosopher Plato. Plato is considered as the greatest philosopher of all time. He is the first to collect all sorts of ideas and arguments and compile them into books that can be read by everyone. He is the type of person who wanted to know everything and even pestered...

  • Why Plato Needed the Forms. Robinson, Dave // Introducing Plato;9/ 1/2005, p66 

    The article presents a discussion about knowledge and gaining it, according to Plato. He asserted that there is an alternative world of unchangeable ideas were true knowledge can be found. It is noted that Circularity is an ideal concept made in the mind. It is asserted that mathematics...

  • Forms and Particulars. Robinson, Dave // Introducing Plato;9/ 1/2005, p73 

    The article presents a discussion about the search for perfect definitions, according to Plato. He asserted that it is possible to find perfect definitions by differentiating between all things on Earth that exude beauty and the idea of the concept of beauty. It is noted that individual know...

  • PLATO BETWEEN ORALITY AND WRITING. NICOARĂ, Marius Marin // Research & Science Today;2013 Supplement, p255 

    UNDERSTANDING PLATO'S THINKING MAY BE ACHIEVED ONLY BY STANDING IN THE CONTEXT OF HIS LANGUAGE. THE LANGUAGE OF PLATO'S PHILOSOPHY IS UNDER THE FUNDAMENTAL DISTINCTION MADE BY PLATO HIMSELF BETWEEN ORALITY AND WRITING. OUR TEXT ASKS QUESTIONS AND SEEKS ANSWERS ON THIS DISTINCTION. WHY DID PLATO...

  • A Novel Interpretation of Plato�s Theory of Forms. Monaghan, P. X. // Metaphysica;May2010, Vol. 11 Issue 1, p63 

    In several recent issues of this journal, I argued for an account of property possession as strict, numerical identity. While this account has stuck some as being highly idiosyncratic in nature, it is not entirely something new under the sun, since as I will argue in this paper, it turns out to...

  • FAIDONAS: FILOSOFAVIMAS KAIP „ANTRASIS PLAUKIMAS“. JANKAUSKAS, SKIRMANTAS // Logos (08687692);2012, Issue 72, p19 

    This article continues my analysis and interpretation of Phaedo's arguments for the soul's immortality. However, the article begins with the analysis of a counterargument, i.e. with the analysis of Platonic criticism of the view that the soul is a harmony. While the criticism stands in disarray...

Share

Read the Article

Courtesy of THE LIBRARY OF VIRGINIA

Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics