Why Science cannot be Value-Free

Lekka-Kowalik, Agnieszka
March 2010
Science & Engineering Ethics;Mar2010, Vol. 16 Issue 1, p33
Academic Journal
Against the ideal of value-free science I argue that science is not––and cannot be––value-free and that relevant values are both cognitive and moral. I develop an argument by indicating various aspects of the value-ladenness of science. The recognition of the value-ladenness of science requires rethinking our understanding of the rationality and responsibility of science. Its rationality cannot be seen as merely instrumental––as it was seen by the ideal of value-free science––for this would result in limiting the autonomy of science and reducing scientists to “minds to hire”. The scientific rationality must be seen as practical rationality which takes into account the full horizon of values. The scientific responsibility must also be broaden in scope and type. On this basis I draw three practical conclusions concerning the organization of research and training of young scientists, appealing to Plato’s claim that those most capable of healing are also those most capable of harming.


Related Articles

  • Plato's Marionette. Schofield, Malcolm // Rhizomata;Dec2016, Vol. 4 Issue 2, p128 

    This paper takes a fresh look at the marionette image introduced by Plato in a famous passage of Book I of the Laws, as he undertakes to explain the bearing of self-rule upon virtue (644 b-645 e). I argue that the reader of the passage is first offered a cognitive model of a unitary self,...

  • The Order of Speeches in Plato's Symposium: A New Ascent Interpretation. Buchbinder, Adrian // Lyceum;Spring2014, Vol. 13 Issue 1, p1 

    An interpretation of Plato's Symposium according to which the order of speeches represents an ascent is attractive for a number of reasons. However, two major challenges have stood in the way of such an interpretation: to explain how Aristophanes' speech can represent an advancement over...

  • The Choice of Lives and the Virtue of Moderation. LORCH, BENJAMIN // Interpretation: A Journal of Political Philosophy;Fall2012, Vol. 39 Issue 3, p235 

    An essay is presented which discusses the problem of the choice of lives scenario in Plato's "Republic." It notes that the myth of Er in the "Republic" illustrates the virtue of moderation as an ability to overcome moral weakness. It proposes that a decent person's choice to live the life of a...

  • Affective Intuition and Rule Deployment: The Dénouement of Moral Judgment. Dhar, Sharmistha // International Journal on Humanistic Ideology;2010, Vol. 3 Issue 1, p141 

    What faculty of our mind is best suited to endow us with all that is required to carry forth our moral enterprise? In other words, what are the cognitive resources that subserve the moral mind? This is a core empirical question, raised much to the delight of the investigative inquisitiveness of...

  • Teaching the Questions: Aristotle's Philosophical Pedagogy in the Nicomachean Ethics and the Politics. Salkever, Stephen // Review of Politics;Spring2007, Vol. 69 Issue 2, p192 

    It is widely acknowledged that the style of Plato's political philosophizing is radically different from the systems and doctrines approach established by Hobbes and confirmed and redirected by Kant. But what about Aristotle? Does he intend to produce systematic political theory in sharp...

  • APOLOGY TO AUTOLYCUS, II.4.  // American Theological Inquiry;2011, Vol. 4 Issue 2, p6 

    The article discusses the ability of God to make as what he pleases, endowed with reason, life, and sensation. It notes the equality of God to what he has made as mutable and alterable. It also highlights the acknowledgement of Plato that God is uncreated while maintaining that God is the...

  • Plato's Eros, Camus' Sisyphus, and the Impossibility of Philosophical Satisfaction. Gilead, Amihud // Clio;Summer88, Vol. 17 Issue 4, p323 

    The article discusses that Plato and Camus both agreed with the impossibility of philosophical satisfaction. This sameness in reasons and opinions is grounded in a common understanding of the nature of the erotic drive of philosophy, since Plato's Eros and Camus' Sisyphus share much in common....

  • The Idea of a Highest Divine Principle--Founding Reason and Spirituality. A Necessary Concept of a Comparative Philosophy? Bickmann, Claudia // Religions;Dec2012, Vol. 3 Issue 4, p1025 

    By reference to the Platonic, Aristotelian, and Neo-Platonic philosophical traditions (and then to German Idealism, including Husserl and Heidegger), I will indicate the way in which the concept of reason--on the one side--depends on the horizon of spirituality (by searching for the ultimate...

  • Myth and Philosophy: From a Problem in Phaedo. Rui Zhu // Journal of the American Academy of Religion;Jun2005, Vol. 73 Issue 2, p453 

    This article investigates the relation between myth and philosophy in Greek philosophy in general and in Plato in particular. Although philosophical thinking and mythical thinking are in general mutually opposed, Greek reason is yet to be separated from its fantastic temperament. The mythic...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics