TITLE

VALIDATION OF TIME-OF-VOTING-DECISION RECALL

AUTHOR(S)
Fournier, Patrick; Nadeau, Richard; Blais, André; Gidengil, Elisabeth; Nevitte, Neil
PUB. DATE
March 2001
SOURCE
Public Opinion Quarterly;Spring2001, Vol. 65 Issue 1, p95
SOURCE TYPE
Academic Journal
DOC. TYPE
Article
ABSTRACT
The article assesses the reliability of time-of-voting decision recall in Canada. The quality of information provided by individuals in response to recall questions can be influenced by several factors, notably, the complexity of the question, the deficiencies of memory, and the inclination to give socially acceptable answers. This study draws on data that allow for a precise test of the validity of responses to time-of-voting-decision recall. The 1997 Canadian Election Study contains a rolling cross-sectional component and a panel component. A representative sample of 80-140 respondents was interviewed each day of the 36-day campaign to track the dynamics of vote intentions. The results for both close- and open-ended questions display an impressive degree of consistency. There is evidence of great stability among individuals who claim to have decided before the campaign. But similarly stable vote choices are also evident among all groups interviewed after their reported time of decision. By contrast, there is little stability among respondents who say they decided after their preelection interview. To put a summary statistic on these findings, we can estimate the proportion of respondents whose behavior and reported time of decision coincide. All in all, the behavioral pattern of some 80 percent of the respondents turns out to be consistent with their reported time of decision.
ACCESSION #
4431873

 

Related Articles

  • Results on Sophisticated Voting in an Experimental Setting. Herzberg, Roberta Q.; Wilson, Rick K. // Journal of Politics;May88, Vol. 50 Issue 2, p471 

    This research explores the extent of sophisticated voting in a simplified agenda setting. We begin from the commonly held presumption that decision makers (whether legislators or school board members) employ sophisticated strategies when voting. This viewpoint has been rigorously modeled under a...

  • THE HARE VOTING SYSTEM IS INCONSISTENT. Doron, Gideon // Political Studies;Jun79, Vol. 27 Issue 2, p283 

    Demonstrates the inconsistency of the Hare System, a proportional representation scheme of the type used in the elections for the parliament in the Republic of Ireland, for the senates in Australia and South Africa, and in numerous local and academic institutions in Europe and the U.S. Failure...

  • ALEX3: a Simulation Program to Compare Electoral Systems. Bissey, Marie-Edith; Carini, Mauro; Ortona, Guido // Journal of Artificial Societies & Social Simulation;Jun2004, Vol. 7 Issue 3, p1 

    An electoral system affects many aspects of the political process, though there is a general agreement that two of them are of paramount relevance: the efficiency of the system in representing voters' will and its effect on the efficiency of the resulting government. The article describes a...

  • Voter Decision Making 1972 and 1974. O'Keefe, Garrett J.; Mendelsohn, Harold; Liu, Jenny // Public Opinion Quarterly;Fall76, Vol. 40 Issue 3, p320 

    A panel study of decision making by Ohio voters found differences between the 1972 and 1974 general election campaigns in terms of attributes the voters used to choose candidates, when they chose, and how difficult their choices were to make. The study explored relations between these...

  • How Do I Find Information About Candidates and Officials in My Home State? Wright, Samuel F. // Officer;Oct2004, Vol. 81 Issue 8, p50 

    Presents a question and answer advisory regarding how to find information about candidates, officials, and public affairs in Florida for the 2004 elections. Function of the Voting Information Center established by the Federal voting Assistance Program; Opportunity for candidates to record their...

  • Policy Voting in Senate Elections: The Case of Abortion. Highton, Benjamin // Political Behavior;Jun2004, Vol. 26 Issue 2, p181 

    Questions about whether voters rely on their policy preferences when casting ballots have been present since scholars first began examining the determinants of voting behavior. This paper seeks to contribute to research in this area by analyzing abortion policy voting in Senate elections....

  • Changing Patterns in American Voting Behavior, 1914-1980. Tuckel, Peter S.; Tejera, Felipe // Public Opinion Quarterly;Summer83, Vol. 47 Issue 2, p230 

    This paper analyzes voting behavior for President, Senate, and House at the state level for the period 1914-80. The major finding of this study is that since World War II, there has been a pronounced trend toward "particularization" in voting for federal offices. This trend consists of more than...

  • ROLE OF ATTRIBUTE GENERALITY IN COGNITIONS OF POLITICAL CANDIDATES. Omura, Glenn S. // Advances in Consumer Research;1979, Vol. 6 Issue 1, p635 

    Following empirical developments in the study of the attribution process and voter decision making, it was proposed that image-related attributes would be more generally used than issue-related attributes to describe political candidates, but that the generality of the two types of attributes...

  • WHEN THE VOTER DECIDES. Riedel, James A.; Dunne, James R. // Public Opinion Quarterly;Winter69-Winter70, Vol. 33 Issue 4, p619 

    This article discusses an exploratory research design developed for implementation in a suburban election district in upstate New York to test the voter's perception of his moment-of-decision prior to actually casting his ballot. It was hypothesized that the majority of voters would affirm their...

Share

Read the Article

Courtesy of THE LIBRARY OF VIRGINIA

Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics