Reconsidering Relational Autonomy. Personal Autonomy for Socially Embedded and Temporally Extended Selves

Baumann, Holger
December 2008
Analyse & Kritik;dez2008, Vol. 30 Issue 2, p445
Academic Journal
Most recent accounts of personal autonomy acknowledge that the social environment a person byes in, and the personal relationships she entertains, have some impact on her autonomy. Two kinds of conceptualizing social conditions are traditionally distinguished in this regard: Causally relational accounts hold that certain relationships and social environments play a causal role for the development and ongoing exercise of autonomy. Constitutively relational accounts, by contrast, claim that autonomy is at least partly constituted by a person's social environment or standing. The central aim of this paper is to raise the question how causally and constitutively relational approaches relate to the fact that we exercise our autonomy over time. I argue that once the temporal scope of autonomy is opened up, we need not only to think differently about the social dimension of autonomy. We also need to reconsider the very distinction between causally and constitutively relational accounts, because it. is itself a synchronic (and not a diachronic) distinction.


Related Articles

  • Impacts of Face Concerns on Interpersonal Conflict Management Strategies in Japan. Moriizumi, Satoshi; Nakatsugawa, Satomi; Takai, Jiro // Conference Papers -- National Communication Association;2008, p1 

    The present study examines the impacts of face concerns and relational factors on interpersonal conflict management styles and their language expressions. A total of 389 Japanese university students responded to rate (1) intimacy and social status, (2) face concerns (i.e., self, self-autonomy,...

  • Gender and Willingness to Confront Hurtful Messages from Romantic Partners. Miller, Courtney Waite; Roloff, Michael E. // Communication Quarterly;Aug2005, Vol. 53 Issue 3, p323 

    Based on a social role perspective, an individual's hurt and willingness to confront a face attack expressed by a romantic partner were hypothesized to vary with gender, type of face attack, and social context. Undergraduates responding to hypothetical scenarios revealed that when teased, women...

  • "Die Ränder brechen auf und sie brechen herein": Ein interkultureller Blick auf Ilma Rakusa und Karl-Markus Gauβ. Horvat, Vesna Kondrič // Modern Austrian Literature;2008, Vol. 41 Issue 3, p55 

    The article deals with two language-aware and form-conscious artists who express a strong drive toward aesthetic expression but never forget their immersion in social and historical environments. Karl-Markus Gauß and Ilma Rakusa, who gained their reputations as very subtle mediators between...

  • A Trouble Shared Is a Trouble Halved: Social Context and Status Affect Pain in Mouse Dyads. Laura Gioiosa; Chiarotti, Flavia; Alleva, Enrico; Laviola, Giovanni // PLoS ONE;2009, Vol. 4 Issue 1, p1 

    In mice behavioral response to pain is modulated by social status. Recently, social context also has been shown to affect pain sensitivity. In our study, we aimed to investigate the effects of interaction between status and social context in dyads of outbred CD-1 male mice in which the...

  • Social mobility and demographic behavior: Long term perspectives. Dribe, Martin; Van Bavel, Jan; Campbell, Cameron // Demographic Research;Jan-Jun2012, Vol. 26, p173 

    We introduce a collection of papers that examine interactions between demographic behavior and social mobility via analysis of historical and contemporary longitudinal, individual- and household-level socioeconomic and demographic data. The authors originally presented these papers at "The...

  • Learners' Use of Interactional Particles in Student-Teacher Conversations. Masuda, Kyoko // Japanese Language & Literature;2009, Vol. 43 Issue 2, p335 

    The article presents a study on the use of Japanese interactional particles (IPs) for learners in student-teacher conversations. These interjections play a significant role in building interpersonal relationships. The IPs are used to indicate the relevance of the marked units in a conversation....

  • Call of the Wild: The Negative Tendency in the Nature Religions of American Youth. Kramp, Joseph // Journal of Religion & Health;Feb2015, Vol. 54 Issue 1, p61 

    The author argues that the paucity of options for sanctioned rebellion in contemporary American society drive an ever-increasing number of idealistic youth in search of isolation in nature, where they construct what the author here calls 'nature religions.' These worldviews focus on purification...

  • How Schools Inhibit the Autonomy of the Middle Class. Merry, Michael S. // Philosophy of Education Yearbook;2007, p417 

    The article presents the author's reaction to Peter Giampietro's essay about autonomy, identity, and the role of narrative. The author disagrees with Giampietro's argument that working-class children in the main are simply incapable of autonomy under the current schooling regime. He also notes...

  • The roles of a Grandmother in African societies - please do not send them to old people's homes. Michel, Janet; Stuckelberger, Astrid; Tediosi, Fabrizio; Evans, David; van Eeuwijk, Piet; van Eeuwijk, Peter // Journal of Global Health;Jun2019, Vol. 9 Issue 1, preceding p1 

    No abstract available.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics