TITLE

AN INVESTIGATION OF POSITIVE-FINDINGS BIAS IN EVALUATION OF ORGANIZATION DEVELOPMENT INTERVENTIONS

AUTHOR(S)
Woodman, Richard W.; Wayne, Sandy J.
PUB. DATE
December 1985
SOURCE
Academy of Management Journal;Dec1985, Vol. 28 Issue 4, p889
SOURCE TYPE
Academic Journal
DOC. TYPE
Article
ABSTRACT
This study investigated the possibility of an inverse relationship between methodological rigor and positive results from organization development (OD) interventions in OD evaluations published between 1978 and 1983. The present study attempted to improve upon earlier investigations of the same issue by using (1) the most recent published work, (2) an expanded scope of studies considered, (3) an improved scale for assessing methodological rigor, and (4) a panel of judges to assess the rigor and outcomes of the published studies. Results of the overall analysis indicated no support for the notion of a positive-findings bias in organization development research. However, when we examined only process interventions there was some evidence of a positive-findings bias in published work.
ACCESSION #
4315371

 

Related Articles

  • The Consequences of Large System Change in Practice: An Empirical Assessment. Harris, Reuben T.; Porras, Jerry I. // Academy of Management Proceedings (0065-0668);1978, p298 

    The impact of a multiple-intervention OD program, involving a number of semi-autonomous units within a large, geographically dispersed organization, was assessed. The research utilized a multiple time-series, quasi-experimental design. The change activities, asserted to be representative of...

  • Development of the OCIR Model of the Intervention Process. Pate, Larry E. // Academy of Management Review;Apr1979, Vol. 4 Issue 2, p281 

    This article reviews recent efforts to develop a new model of the intervention process called the Organization--Change Agent--Interventions--Results (OCIR) model. He examines a traditional model for organizational change called the Truth--Love model and discusses how OCIR differentiates from...

  • STUDYING ORGANIZATIONAL CHANGE AND DEVELOPMENT: CHALLENGES FOR FUTURE RESEARCH. Pettigrew, Andrew M.; Woodman, Richard W.; Cameron, Kim S. // Academy of Management Journal;Aug2001, Vol. 44 Issue 4, p697 

    This article presents several studies that examine organizational change. The authors note that certain issues should be addressed when examining the studies including an examination of the multiple contexts and levels of analysis in studying organizational change, the inclusion of time,...

  • The Persistence of Flexible Organizational Routines: The Role of Agency and Organizational Context. Howard-Grenville, Jennifer A. // Organization Science;Nov/Dec2005, Vol. 16 Issue 6, p618 

    Once regarded as stable and inflexible, organizational routines are increasingly seen as capable of being adapted to the situation at hand and a potentially important source of endogenous change in organizations. This paper considers why routines that are performed flexibly may nonetheless...

  • A Political Approach to Organizations: A Review and Rationale. Tushman, Michael L. // Academy of Management Review;Apr1977, Vol. 2 Issue 2, p206 

    In ignoring the implications of systems thinking at the intra-organizational level of analysis, organizational literature has obscured the fact that organizational behavior (OB) occurs as a result of subunit dynamics within the organization. Several assumptions are basic to a political approach...

  • Organization Context and Structure: An Abbreviated Replication. Inkson, J. H. K.; Pugh, D. S.; Hickson, D. J. // Administrative Science Quarterly;Sep70, Vol. 15 Issue 3, p318 

    The present study establishes the reliability and validity of short forms for the measurement of four previously established dimensions of organizations: two contextual--technology and dependence--and two structural-structuring of activities and concentration of authority--based on information...

  • Does Cognitive Style Affect Diagnosis and Intervention Strageties of Change Agents? Slocum Jr., John W. // Academy of Management Proceedings (0065-0668);1978, p142 

    One hundred and fifty-two change agents were presented with a list of 24 diagnostic questions they might ask the client organization. These diagnostic questions were related to the change agents cognitive style and the tactics most likely used by the change agent to bring about organizational...

  • Una experiencia práctica en el estudio de valores organizacionales. GONZÁLEZ, NÚÑEZ A. L.; PARERA, MONFORT I. // Transporte Desarrollo y Medio Ambiente;sep-dic2011, Vol. 31 Issue 2/3, p31 

    The present article approaches the results obtained in a study of organizational values carried out in an entity of the MITRANS. For the realization of the same one several investigation methods were used, among them, the application of four surveys, through which it could be determined the...

  • A Practical Application of Management and Organization Theory for Academic Administrator. Baltz, Gerald W. // Academy of Management Review;Jul1976, Vol. 1 Issue 3, p129 

    In this article the author examines the communication gap the exists between practitioners and theorists in the management and organizational fields and attempts to bridge this divide. He presents his case in hopes of demonstrating to academic administrators that having a recognition of...

Share

Read the Article

Courtesy of THE LIBRARY OF VIRGINIA

Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics