Justice, legal validity and the force of law with special reference to Derrida, Dooyeweerd and Habermas

Strauss, D. F. M.
February 2009
South African Journal of Philosophy;2009, Vol. 28 Issue 1, p65
Academic Journal
Philosophy, political philosophy and legal philosophy are all concerned with issues of justice and the validity of law (also known as the force of law). These two problem areas are discussed against the background of the intersection of traditional theories of natural law and legal positivism, mediated by the contribution of the historical school. In addition the influence of the two neo-Kantian schools of thought (Baden and Marburg) required attention, particularly because certain elements in the thought of Derrida, Dooyeweerd and Habermas are (implicitly) influenced by these schools. Derrida positions the problem of justice within the context of distinguishing universality and singularity (what is unique) and he alludes to the difficulty of bridging the gap between the two. It turned out that modern nominalism had an important effect on all three of the mentioned thinkers, in spite of their willingness to recognize "extra-mental" forms of universality. The problem of legal validity (the "force of law") appears to be an instance of the interconnectedness between different aspects of reality, namely the jural and the physical. In order to account for this coherence Dooyeweerd developed a theory in which both the uniqueness and coherence between different aspects are explained in terms of inter-modal analogies. On this basis the difference between law and justice is specified by distinguishing between constitutive legal principles and the regulatively deepened (disclosed) principles of legal morality (such as fault, equity, bona fides and so on). It will be shown that the idea of positivization, shared by thinkers coming from different backgrounds, is an important ingredient of an understanding of the nature of legal validity. Explaining it will require a focus on the nature of state law, of the power of the state, and of the legal competence entailed in the office of government.


Related Articles

  • The transcendental theory of experience and modern philosophy of science. Katrechko, S. L. // Kantian Sbornik / Kantovskij Sbornik;2012, Vol. 42 Issue 4, p22 

    This article sets out to develop a transcendental theory of science based on the original interpretation and modern development of Kant's transcendentalism (theory of experience). The author shows that modern (postpositivistic and analytical) philosophy of science follows the spirit of Kant's...

  • There is No Question of Physicalism. CRANE, TIM; MELLOR, D. H. // Mind;Apr1990, Vol. 99 Issue 394, p185 

    The article examines a number of proposed definitions of physicalism, also known as logical positivism. The article discusses physicalism as a doctrine about the empirical world. Physicalism is not discussed as the matter of universal and abstract objects. It is stated that nominalism and...

  • Realism in the Study of Entrepreneurship. Alvarez, Sharon A.; Barney, Jay B.; McBride, Russ; Wuebker, Robert // Academy of Management Review;Apr2014, Vol. 39 Issue 2, p227 

    The authors present a response to an article in a prior issue by S. Ramoglou entitled "On the Misuse of Realism in the Study of Entrepreneurship" that itself was a comment on their own earlier article entitled"Epistemology, Opportunities, and Entrepreneurship: Comments on Venkataraman et al...

  • On the Misuse of Realism in the Study of Entrepreneurship. Ramoglou, Stratos // Academy of Management Review;Jul2013, Vol. 38 Issue 3, p463 

    The article presents the authors' critique of studies on entrepreneurship, with a focus on realism and empirical research on entrepreneurial opportunities. Topics include the discovery approach to entrepreneurship, the realist philosophy of business science, and theories of existence, meaning,...

  • Comments on Sleeper and Edel. Rorty, Richard // Transactions of the Charles S. Peirce Society;Winter1985, Vol. 21 Issue 1, p39 

    Presents a response to commentaries on an article which focuses on thinker Richard Rorty's interpretation of pragmatism. Overview of the article; References to pragmatism; Arguments raised in the commentaries.

  • Sociology Within the Limits of Reality. Prandini, Riccardo // Sociologia e Politiche Sociali;2004, Vol. 7 Issue 3, p73 

    The author analyzes the place of sociology in the contemporary scientific field. Today sociology is in a predicament between neurocognitive sciences and historical ontologies, between a strong empirical positivism and a relativistic idealism. To avoid this difficulty sociologists should work out...

  • The Myth about "Myths of the Chicago School": Evidence from Floyd Nelson House. Nock, David // American Sociologist;Spring2004, Vol. 35 Issue 1, p63 

    Some important work (Bulmer, Harvey) in the history of sociology questions whether the Chicago School should be identified with qualitative as opposed to more quantitative, statistical, and correlational methods. This paper will examine whether this characterization is a "myth" or whether there...

  • PRAGMATISM AND CRITICAL REALISM IN MANAGEMENT RESEARCH. Sek Khin, Edward Wong; Lee Yow Fui // Actual Problems of Economics / Aktual'ni Problemi Ekonomìki;Mar2012, Vol. 129 Issue 3, p359 

    The paper explores the development of pragmatic-critical realism in management research. It is to transcend positivism thesis of a foundational-absolute stance and postmodernist antithesis of chaotic relativism. Knowledge is more than what can be measured or observed through human senses....

  • THE PRESENT POSITION OF POSITIVISM. Swinny, S.H. // Sociological Review (1908-1952);Jul09, Vol. 2 Issue 3, p278 

    This article presents the author's comments on an article on positivism. The friendly criticism of Mr. Oliphant in the April issue of this Review raise several points in general interest. But when he objects to the employment of such words as love and gratitude applied of collective units, he is...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics