Trading Refugees for Land and Symbols: The Palestinian Negotiation Strategy in the Oslo Process

Hovdenak, Are
March 2009
Journal of Refugee Studies;Mar2009, Vol. 22 Issue 1, p30
Academic Journal
This article analyses the negotiation strategy of the Palestine Liberation Organization regarding the refugee issue in the failed Israeli-Palestinian peace process from 1993 to 2001. It is argued that the PLO was on the brink of conceding the 'right of return' for the sake of territorial concessions from Israel. The author discusses the implications of this strategy for the domestic legitimacy of the Palestinian leadership, as giving up the right of return would violate a core tenet in Palestinian national mythology. The PLO negotiators tried to solve that dilemma by, first, separating the principle of return from its implementation-making it possible for the PLO to remain committed to the principle, while offering compromises on physical return-and, second, by demanding symbolic gestures from Israel, including acknowledgment of Israel's historic responsibility for the refugee problem. It is argued that Israel's refusal to offer a minimum of face-saving gestures prevented the PLO from formalizing its compromise proposal.


Related Articles

  • 'Delaying the inevitable'. Schaeffer-Duffy, Claire // National Catholic Reporter;1/19/2007, Vol. 43 Issue 12, p11 

    The article presents an interview with Afif Safieh, the Palestine Liberation Organization ambassador to the U.S. who is now based in Washington. When asked about the recent developments of the Palestinian national movement efforts of statehood, he stressed that there is now an international...

  • Who are the Palestinians? Usher, Graham // New Statesman;7/12/2004, Vol. 133 Issue 4696, p18 

    Focuses on the Arab-Israeli conflict and discusses the identity of people called Palestinians. The Arab stereotype; How they changed with the first and second intifada; Displacement of Palestinians in refugee camps administered by the United Nations after Israel conquered Palestine; Statistics...

  • Grounds for Hope?  // Bulletin with Newsweek;11/23/2004, Vol. 122 Issue 6448, p36 

    This article focuses on the effect of the death of Palestinian leader Yasir Arafat on the peace negotiations in Israeli-Palestinian conflict. For 35 years, Arafat dominated the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and refused to accept that his rule would end. A look at the men who must fill Abu Ammar's...

  • Palestine Goes to the UN. Elgindy, Khaled // Foreign Affairs;Sep/Oct2011, Vol. 90 Issue 5, p102 

    The article focuses on the Palestinian bid for statehood in the United Nations (UN) membership in 2011. Topics include the symbolic nature of the bid by Palestinian leader Mahmoud Abbas, the failure of peace talks with Israel facilitated by the U.S., internal struggles between the political...

  • Israel strikes at Palestinian nationalism itself. Lynfield, Ben // Christian Science Monitor;8/13/2001, Vol. 93 Issue 181, p1 

    Reports on the campaign of Israel against Palestinian nationalism. Effect of suicide bombings on the Israeli campaign; Flying of the Israeli flag over the headquarters of the Palestinian Liberation Organization in Jerusalem; Outlook for relations between Israelis and Palestinians.

  • Background & Analysis. Jaffe, Maayan // Baltimore Jewish Times;12/7/2012, Vol. 329 Issue 6, p27 

    The article presents information on the decision of the United Nations General Assembly to upgrade the Palestine Liberation Organization to a nonmember observer state. Several U.S. lawmakers stood against Palestinian Authority leader Mahmoud Abbas' decision to appeal to the decision. U.S....

  • Europe and the Middle East.  // America;6/28/1980, Vol. 142 Issue 25, p533 

    The author talks about the consensus on the Middle East by the members of the European Economic Community (EEC) at the end of its meeting in Venice, Italy in 1980. According to the author, the statement issued by the EEC says nothing new compared to what the U.S. had noted already. One reason...

  • The PLO Since the 1982 War. Khalidi, Rashid // Harvard International Review;Dec1984, Vol. 7 Issue 3, p18 

    The article an analysis two years after the Israeli invasion of Lebanon in its quest to finally destroy the Palestine Liberation Organization. The goal of Israeli for the invasion was not achieved and thus it becomes impossible to draw a line on what is conceived as an ongoing war. The only...

  • Don't Bank On It. Dowty, Alan // New Republic;8/20/77, Vol. 177 Issue 8/9, p15 

    Presents information on Arab-Israel settlement related issues. Proposal for the establishment of a West Bank Palestinian state; Recommendation of United Nations to partition Palestine into Arab and Jewish states; View that the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) essentially represents the...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics