Nothing for something? Estimating cost and value for beneficiaries from recent medicare spending increases on HMO payments and drug benefits

Pizer, Steven; Frakt, Austin; Feldman, Roger
March 2009
International Journal of Health Care Finance & Economics;Mar2009, Vol. 9 Issue 1, p59
Academic Journal
The Medicare Modernization Act of 2003 added a new outpatient prescription drug benefit to Medicare and increased payments to HMOs. We estimate a nested logit model of plan choice to quantify the welfare benefits from these two expansion paths. We find that the addition of stand-alone prescription drug plans was welfare improving and produced nine times as much value per government dollar as the increase in payments to HMOs. In light of these results, we suggest that HMO bidding procedures should be modified to reduce payments to HMOs by about $67 billion over the next 10 years.


Related Articles

  • The Effects Of The Coverage Gap On Drug Spending: A Closer Look At Medicare Part D. Yuting Zhang; Donohue, Julie Marie; Newhouse, Joseph P.; Lave, Judith R. // Health Affairs;Mar/Apr2009, Vol. 28 Issue 2, pw317 

    We calculated prescription drug usage in two groups of Medicare beneficiaries: employer group with no coverage gap, and individual Part D group with no coverage or some generic drug coverage in the coverage gap. Among those with employer coverage, 40 percent reached the doughnut hole, compared...

  • Fostering Accountable Health Care:Moving Forward In Medicare. Fisher, Elliott S.; McClellan, Mark B.; Bertko, John; Lieberman, Steven M.; Lee, Julie J.; Lewis, Julie L.; Skinner, Jonathan S. // Health Affairs;Mar/Apr2009, Vol. 28 Issue 2, pw219 

    To succeed, health care reform must slow spending growth while improving quality. We propose a new approach to help achieve more integrated and efficient care by fostering local organizational accountability for quality and costs through performance measurement and "shared savings" payment...

  • Is Medicaid Sustainable? Spending Projections For The Program's Second Forty Years. Kronick, Richard; Rousseau, David // Health Affairs;2007 Supplement, Vol. 26, pw271 

    We constructed long-term projections of Medicaid spending and compared projected growth in spending with that of state and federal revenues. Notwithstanding the anticipated decline in employer-sponsored insurance and the long-term care needs of the baby boomers, we project that Medicaid spending...

  • Using Medicare Payment Policy To Transform The Health System: A Framework For Improving Performance. Guterman, Stuart; Davis, Karen; Schoenbaum, Stephen; Shih, Anthony // Health Affairs;Mar/Apr2009, Vol. 28 Issue 2, pw238 

    As the largest payer for health services in the United States, Medicare has the potential to use its payment policies to stimulate change in the organization of care to improve quality and mitigate cost growth. This paper proposes a framework in which Medicare would offer an array of new bundled...

  • Small Steps or a Giant Leap for the Uninsured? Bindman, Andrew B.; Haggstrom, David A. // JAMA: Journal of the American Medical Association;8/13/2003, Vol. 290 Issue 6, p816 

    Editorial. Discusses health insurance in the United States. Origins of health insurance; Introduction of Medicare and Medicaid; Number of Americans who lacked health insurance in 2001; Reference to a study by McWilliams et all in the August 13, 2003 issue of 'The Journal of the American Medical...

  • High and Rising Health Care Costs. Part 3: The Role of Health Care Providers. Bodenheimer, Thomas // Annals of Internal Medicine;6/21/2005, Vol. 142 Issue 12, p996 

    One commonly held explanation for high and rising health care costs in the United States points to the market power of health care providers. This third article of a 4-part series examines how the prices and quantities of health care services interact to influence health care expenditures. The...

  • The Risks of an Ownership Society. Swartz, Katherine // Inquiry (00469580);Winter2004/2005, Vol. 41 Issue 4, p357 

    Comments on the rising cost of medical care in the U.S. Association of the ownership society with the desire of employers to reduce their role in the system of health insurance; Importance of the Medicare Modernization Act for an individual's health savings account (HSA); Contributions of...

  • It can't Last....  // New Republic;10/18/69, Vol. 161 Issue 16, p4 

    Focuses on health insurance services offered by the U.S. government to its citizens. Information that seven of the 10 provinces of Canada have compulsory health insurance; Claim that except the U.S., every industrial nation in the world today, has some form of compulsory health care; Cost of...

  • Lessons from Canada.  // Clinical Pediatrics;Dec1975, Vol. 14 Issue 12, p1124 

    This article presents a suggestive note regarding the administration of health programs. It is suggested that Canadian experience with health programs should be studied carefully, but should not be emulated without question. The United States, hopefully, can learn from neighboring Canada, but...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics