The care of patients with subthreshold depression in primary care: Is it all that bad? A qualitative study on the views of general practitioners and patients

Backenstrass, Matthias; Joest, Katharina; Rosemann, Thomas; Szecsenyi, Joachim
January 2007
BMC Health Services Research;2007, Vol. 7, p190
Academic Journal
Background: Studies show that subthreshold depression is highly prevalent in primary care, has impact on the quality of life and causes immense health care costs. Although this points to the clinical relevance of subthreshold depression, contradictory results exist regarding the often selfremitting course of this state. However, first steps towards quality improvement in the care of subthreshold depressive patients are being undertaken. This makes it important to gather information from both a GPs' and a patients' point of view concerning the clinical relevance as well as the status quo of diagnosis and treatment in order to appraise the need for quality improvement research. Method: We conducted qualitative, semi-structured interviews for the questioning of 20 GPs and 20 patients with subthreshold depression on aspects of clinical relevance and on the status quo of diagnosis and treatment. Interviews were transcribed and analyzed on a content analytical theoretical background using Atlas.ti software. Results: Most of the GPs found subthreshold depression to be clinically significant. Although some problems in diagnosis and treatment were mentioned, the GPs had sensible diagnostic and treatment strategies at hand which resulted from the long and trustful relationship with the patients and which corresponded to the patients' expectations. The patients rather expected their GP to listen to them than to take specific actions towards symptom relief and, in the main, were satisfied with the GPs' care. Conclusion: The study shows that subthreshold depression is a clinically relevant issue for GPs but raises the possibility that quality improvement might not be as necessary as past studies showed. Further quantitative research using larger random samples is needed to determine the effectiveness of the strategies used by the GPs, patients' satisfaction with these strategies and the course of these patients' symptoms in primary care.


Related Articles

  • Factors associated with the use of primary care services: the role of practice nurses. Vallejo-Torres, Laura; Morris, Stephen // European Journal of Health Economics;Aug2011, Vol. 12 Issue 4, p373 

    Rising demand for and costs of health care have led to an increasing role of practice nurses in primary care in many countries, including the United Kingdom. Previous research has explored how practice nurse care differs from that provided by general practitioners (GPs) in terms of costs and...

  • How are PCTs coping with the new contract?  // Pulse;7/12/2004, Vol. 64 Issue 28, p14 

    Examines the progress of the implementation of the general medical service contracts by four primary care trusts in Great Britain in 2004. Number of general practitioners (GP); Prescribing overspend; Percent of GP opting out of out-of-hours; Increases in the cost of prescribing; Issue of when...

  • Access target endangers patient choice.  // Medeconomics;Oct2004, Vol. 25 Issue 10, p13 

    This article focuses on the alternatives available to patients in England who have to wait for more than six months for operations. But at the other end of the care spectrum, choice of another sort is being eroded. Incentivised under the new contract, the 48-hour access target is being achieved...

  • Should treatment depend on BMI? Bostock, Nick // GP: General Practitioner;12/2/2005, p21 

    The article reports that suggestions that obese patients be denied referrals have divided physicians. Spiralling deficits across the NHS have left many primary care organisations (PCOs) desperate to cut referrals to secondary care to rein in costs. GPs understand that trusts' need to work within...

  • Extended travel cost scheme consultation.  // Pulse;1/25/2007, Vol. 67 Issue 3, p20 

    The article reports on the consultation on extending the Hospital Travel Cost Scheme to cover referrals may by general practitioners and other practice staff for treatment in primary care. This is launched by the British Government to allow patients on a low income who do not need ambulance, but...

  • Clinical practice patterns of generalists and specialists in Alzheimer's disease: What are the differences, and what difference do they make? ROBINSON, L.; VELLAS, B.; KNOX, S.; LINS, K. // Journal of Nutrition, Health & Aging;Jul2010, Vol. 14 Issue 7, p545 

    Optimising the roles played by both generalists and specialists in the diagnosis and treatment of Alzheimer's disease (AD) could have a major impact on the quality and cost of patient care. Therefore, one aim of the IMPACT survey was to characterise the similarities and differences between these...

  • Independent Nurse: Opinion - Don't compare NPs and GPs on cost alone. Bower, Emma // GP: General Practitioner;8/12/2005, p80 

    The article focuses on primary care costs related to employment of nurse practitioner (NP) and salaried general practitioner (GP) in primary care. According to a study, employing NP in primary care costs much the same as employing a salaried GP. The time spent by a GP contributing to an NP...

  • More patients will get free scripts.  // Pulse;4/5/2004, Vol. 64 Issue 14, p4 

    Reports on the efforts of the government to provide free prescriptions to several patients after the reduction of the workload of various physicians in Great Britain. Affordability on the costs of medical care; Improvement on the quality of life.

  • Tendering costs at PCTs varies hugely.  // Pulse;5/13/2009, Vol. 69 Issue 16, p8 

    The article reports on a survey about the primary care trusts (PCTs ) in Great Britain. The survey found that the spending on PCTs continue to increase with an average of £3,000 on procurement. The survey also revealed that the tendering costs of PCTs varies hugely on the nationwide...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics