TITLE

THE POSITIVISTIC FALLACY: 'COGNITIVE TRANSLATABILITY' IN CRITICISM

AUTHOR(S)
Pradhan, S. V.
PUB. DATE
April 1987
SOURCE
British Journal of Aesthetics;Spring87, Vol. 27 Issue 2, p138
SOURCE TYPE
Academic Journal
DOC. TYPE
Article
ABSTRACT
The article focuses on cognitive translatability in criticism. It states that the attempt to define sincerity, spontaneity and authenticity with reference to semantics and syntax is an instance of what one may call literary positivism. It mentions that the neo-positivist, philosophical programme of reduction and verification bases itself on an analysis of the structure of scientific discourse and tries to adjust itself to it as its grasp of science becomes firmer. It notes that a half-baked theory of positivist inspiration has ruled the mainstream of Anglo-American criticism for decades, legislated for critics and censured critical vocabulary for vagueness, imprecision and affectivity. It adds that if physicalism is the language of physics, it can be the language of criticism too.
ACCESSION #
33296947

 

Related Articles

  • Free Beauty, Dependent Beauty, and Art. Stecker, Robert // Journal of Aesthetic Education;Spring87, Vol. 21 Issue 1, p89 

    The article focuses on the implication of the various perception of people in appreciating and judging beauty to the justification of aesthetic education and arts. Immanuel Kant, a philosopher, suggests that proper understanding of the appreciation of most art is not captured by the notion of a...

  • Dialectics, dialogics and other ways of reading us. Weinstein, Matthew; Broda, Matthew // Cultural Studies of Science Education;Dec2009, Vol. 4 Issue 4, p799 

    In this response to Reis’s and Zuss’s responses to our meditation on the grotesque, we attempt to draw distinctions between positivist, empiricist, and realist (including grotesque realist) projects. We also, drawing on Bakhtin, consider the difference between dialogic and...

  • LEX NATURALIS AND THE MODERN POLITICAL STATE: RECONCILING THE HISTORICAL EVOLUTION OF JURISTIC PHILOSOPHY WITH CONTEMPORARY STATUTORY LEGITIMACY. Crook, Jason A. // Slovenian Law Review;Dec2009, Vol. 6 Issue 1/2, p11 

    Although the debate between the positivist and the naturalist schools over which philosophical approach offers the best explanation of juristic legitimacy may appear to the casual observer to be little more than an exercise in semantics, the consequences of this discussion can have a significant...

  • SESSÄ°Z EV'Ä°N HAYALETÄ°: GÃœDÃœK BÄ°R AYDINLANMA PROJESÄ°. Uğurlu, Seyit Battal; Balik, Macit // Electronic Turkish Studies;2009, Vol. 4 Issue 8, p2307 

    Dr. Selahattin DarvinoÄŸlu, who is in the first one of the three generations that are told in Orhan Pamuk's (b. 1954) second novel The House of Silence is an atypical and encyclopedist intellectual, who represents the positivist thinking which entered Turkish thinking and cultural history in...

  • Physicalism and overdetermination. Sturgeon, Scott // Mind;Apr98, Vol. 107 Issue 426, p411 

    Focuses on physicalism, with reference to the paper `The Overdetermination Argument for Physicalism.' What is physicalism; What are the three principles that exploit the idea that events compose one another.

  • Reply to my critics. Shoemaker, Sydney // Philosophical Studies;Mar2010, Vol. 148 Issue 1, p125 

    The article presents the reply of the author to his critics on his book regarding physicalism. He explains the physicality of mental properties and the concept of thin and thick properties. Further, he justifies his opinion on the coincidence of humans with other entities and their...

  • The overdetermination argument versus the cause-and-essence principle--no contest. Noordhof, Paul // Mind;Apr99, Vol. 108 Issue 430, p367 

    Criticizes Scott Sturgeon's thoughts on the Overdetermination Argument for Physicalism. Relationship between actuality and physical reality; Counterfactual activity for truths in causal statements concerning the mental and physical; Analysis of the cause-and-essence principle.

  • The Generalization Argument, Multiple Realization, and Special Science Properties. Campbell, Neil // International Journal of Interdisciplinary Social Sciences;2010, Vol. 5 Issue 1, p457 

    Kim's supervenience/exclusion argument is designed to show that if nonreductive physicalists insist that mental properties are physically irreducible, their causal (and explanatory) status is preempted by the physical properties on which they supervene or depend. Numerous critics have responded...

  • BERTOLT BRECHT, LOGICAL EMPIRICISM, AND SOCIAL BEHAVIOURISM. Giles, Steve // Modern Language Review;Jan95, Vol. 90 Issue 1, p83 

    Describes the impact of logical empiricism on Bertolt Brecht's theory in the early 1930s and the precise nature of his response to it. Outline of the epistemological concerns of logical empiricism, positivism and pragmatism; Review of existing accounts of Brecht's reception of logical empiricism.

Share

Read the Article

Courtesy of THE LIBRARY OF VIRGINIA

Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics