Counterpoint: Separatism Is the Wrong Choice for Canadians and Quebecers

Yip, Jerome
January 2015
Canadian Points of View: Quebec Separatism;2015, p3
The article presents an argument against Quebec separatism. It is the author's opinion that separatism would endanger the rights of minority communities, harm the province's economy, and contradict the wishes of most Quebecers. The protection of French language and educational rights under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedom is discussed. The potential threat to public services such as healthcare and education is examined. Discrimination against linguistic minorities is explored.


Related Articles

  • Ottawa's nonchalance seems to play right into the separatists' hands. Byfield, Ted // Alberta Report / Newsmagazine;7/11/94, Vol. 21 Issue 30, p44 

    Criticizes the Ottawa federal government and Prime Minister Jean Chretien in particular for policies concerning the Quebec separatist movement. Assertion that Mr. Chretien and his associates are too accommodating to the separatists.

  • Meanwhile, deepening contempt in the West. T.M. // Alberta Report / Newsmagazine;9/26/94, Vol. 21 Issue 41, p8 

    States that with recent polls showing some Canadians to be fed up with Quebec's relentless complaints and bluster, some observers suggest that the West's political leaders should openly start addressing the question of how best to advance their regional interest in a Quebec-less Canada. Alberta...

  • The Irish precedent for Quebec.  // Alberta Report / Newsmagazine;9/26/94, Vol. 21 Issue 41, p19 

    States that it's not assured that Quebeckers will elect the Parti Quebecois, but forever reject separation. Historical perspective; The Irish Nationalist Party; Conclusions of the `National Review.'

  • Quebec's X-files.  // Alberta Report / Newsmagazine;11/20/95, Vol. 22 Issue 49, p43 

    Reports that Quebec, Canada's chief electoral officer, Pierre Cote, will investigate voting irregularities in the referendum that led to the rejection of thousands of ballots for minor technical reasons. What the Parti Quebecois' ballot scrutineers had been instructed.

  • Two languages, two propagandas. Robson, John // Alberta Report / Newsmagazine;1/8/96, Vol. 23 Issue 4, p6 

    States that Ottawa preaches generosity to Quebec and restraint to the English. Issues of Quebec sovereigntists; Suppression by Quebec's Economic Restructuring Minister Richard Le Hir of studies showing that separation would hurt the economy; Federal government advertisements fueling the fire.

  • Quebec puts Martin in one big dilemma but the solution is plain as the prairie. Byfield, Ted // Alberta Report / Newsmagazine;9/26/94, Vol. 21 Issue 41, p52 

    Focuses on two developments that occurred in Septermber 1994 that have decisive and ominous implications for western Canada. How a government dedicated to the break up of the country was elected in Quebec; How the federal government's fiscal estimates were disclosed to be billions of dollars off...

  • Just say Yes to a tax break.  // Alberta Report / Newsmagazine;3/27/95, Vol. 22 Issue 15, p51 

    Looks at the efforts of the Parti Quebecois to woo Quebeckers to vote yes in the sovereignty referendum. Comments made by Premier Jacques Parizeau; Question from Action Democratique Leader Mario Dumont; Consequences of voting yes.

  • Could it be that those suave Quebec separatists are a bunch of amateurs? Byfield, Ted // Alberta Report / Newsmagazine;6/13/94, Vol. 21 Issue 26, p52 

    Comments on the actions of the leaders of the Quebec separatist movement. Details of the happenings at the recent western premiers' conference in Gimli; Actions of Prime Minister Jean Chretien.

  • That's Kay-beck, not Kwee-beck.  // Alberta Report / Newsmagazine;9/5/94, Vol. 21 Issue 38, p43 

    Comments on `Globe and Mail' journalist Andre Picard, and his compilation of a handy reference guide for all the foreign journalists covering the Quebec election. Helpful tidbits when speaking English to `les Quebecois'; Warning about La Fin du Monde brand of beer; Significance of numbers 101...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics