Foreign Assistance: Actions Needed to Better Assess the Impact of Agencies' Marking and Publicizing Efforts: GAO-07-277

Ford, Jess
March 2007
GAO Reports;3/13/2007, p1
Government Document
The negative perceptions of the United States associated with U.S. foreign policy initiatives have underscored the importance of the United States presenting a complete portrayal of the benefits that many in the world derive from U.S. foreign assistance efforts. Congress has expressed concerns that the United States has frequently understated or not publicized information about its foreign assistance programs. As requested, this report (1) describes the policies, regulations, and guidelines that agencies have established to mark and publicize foreign assistance; (2) describes how State, USAID, and other agencies mark and publicize foreign assistance; and (3) identifies key challenges that agencies face in marking and publicizing foreign assistance. Most of the agencies we reviewed involved in foreign assistance activities have established some marking and publicity requirements in policies, regulations, or guidelines. USAID has the most detailed policies and regulations relating to marking and publicity. USAID has also established a network of communications specialists at its missions to publicize its assistance efforts and has issued communications guidelines to promote that assistance. According to State officials, its policy is to allow its program managers and ambassadors to use their discretion when determining which programs and activities to mark or publicize. USDA, DOD, HHS, Treasury, and MCC have also established some policies for marking and publicizing assistance, though these policies vary in their level of formality and detail. To increase awareness of U.S. assistance abroad, key agencies that we reviewed used various methods to mark and publicize some of their activities and exercised flexibility in deciding when it was appropriate to do so. These agencies used different methods of marking, or visibly acknowledging, their assistance. In addition, agencies generally used embassy public affairs offices for publicizing, information about the source of their assistance and, in some cases, augmented these efforts with their own publicity methods. We identified some challenges to marking and publicizing U.S. foreign assistance, including the lack of (1) a strategy for assessing the impact of marking and publicity efforts on increasing the awareness of U.S. foreign assistance and (2) governmentwide guidance for marking and publicizing U.S. foreign assistance. First, although some agencies conduct surveys in recipient countries that primarily capture information on public opinion of the United States, little reliable work has been done to assess the impact of U.S. assistance on foreign citizens' awareness of the source of U.S. provided assistance. Second, while the newly appointed Director of Foreign Assistance has begun to address the issue of developing a governmentwide policy for marking and publicizing all U.S. foreign assistance, it is unclear to what extent this policy will be implemented by agencies whose foreign...


Related Articles

  • AIDED OUT.  // Institute of Public Affairs Review;Jun2003, Vol. 55 Issue 2, p39 

    Highlights a report published in the June 21, 2003 issue of 'The Economist' about the plan of India to stop accepting donation from other countries and assume the role of an aid donor. Increase in India's aid budget for other countries; Annual aid income of India; Reason for the move.

  • Donor Positioning: Development Assistance from the U.S., Japan, France, Germany, and Britain. Lebovic, James H. // Political Research Quarterly;Mar2005, Vol. 58 Issue 1, p119 

    In this study, I show that traditional models fail to account for a theoretically important, windfall profit that countries receive from their primary donors and that a consequence of neglecting this "bonus effect" is that models understate important (indirect) effects of donor interests on aid....

  • North Korea Invites China into the Inner Room of Its Economy. Nam Sung Wook // Korea Focus;May/Jun2005, Vol. 13 Issue 3, p11 

    The article presents a discussion on the North Korea's invitation to China into the inner room of its economy. With its ability to attract foreign capital and foreign currency being noticeably constrained by U.S. and Japanese economic sanctions, North Korea has felt an increasing need to...

  • QUESTION OF CURTAILING U. .S FOREIGN AID.  // Congressional Digest;Nov56, Vol. 35 Issue 11, p257 

    Chronicles the evolution of the United States' foreign aid program. Opposition to the foreign aid program; House Committee on Foreign Affairs' review of the program to be presented on February 1, 1957; Appointment of a special Senate Investigating Committee to be headed by Senator Green.

  • MAJOR STEPS TAKEN FROM 1945 TO 1955.  // Congressional Digest;Nov56, Vol. 35 Issue 11, p259 

    Chronicles major developments in the United States foreign aid program from 1945 to 1955. Responsibilities of the United Nations Relief and Rehabilitation Administration; Countries receiving military and economic aid under President Truman's administration; Secretary of State George C....

  • Development Assistance Committee High Level Meeting 15-16 April 2004.  // DAC Journal;2004, Vol. 5 Issue 2, p7 

    The DAC High Level Meeting is a unique gathering of aid ministers and heads of aid agencies from OECD governments together with senior officials from the World Bank, the IMF and UNDP. They met in Paris on 15-16 April to review aid and security issues; aid volume and effectiveness; and the growth...

  • Progress since the Millennium Declaration in 2000.  // DAC Journal;2005, Vol. 6 Issue 1, p55 

    The Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) are driving the development agenda through strategies for improved results. Countries in most of Asia and northern Africa are largely on track for the goals; West Asia, the Caribbean and Latin America are progressing on education but less so on poverty;...

  • Exploring the failure of foreign aid: The role of incentives and information. Williamson, Claudia // Review of Austrian Economics;Mar2010, Vol. 23 Issue 1, p17 

    The stated purpose of foreign aid is to promote economic and human development. Recently, the ability of foreign aid to achieve its goals is called into question. Widespread conceptual and empirical literature suggests that foreign aid is ineffective. This paper explores the failure of foreign...

  • Foreign Aid Strategies: China Taking Over? Kjøllesdal, Kristian; Welle-Strand, Anne // Asian Social Science;Oct2010, Vol. 6 Issue 10, p3 

    Over the past decade China has emerged as an important source of foreign aid for African countries. Providing aid on terms of its own choosing, China challenges the current foreign aid paradigm in four main ways: The donor-recipient relationship is challenged by a partnership of equals; The...


Read the Article

Other Topics