Elections: All Levels of Government Are Needed to Address Electronic Voting System Challenges: GAO-07-576T

Hite, Randolph C.
March 2007
GAO Reports;3/7/2007, p1
Government Documents
Since the 2000 national elections, concerns have been raised by various groups regarding the election process, including voting technologies. Beginning in 2001, GAO published a series of reports examining virtually every aspect of the elections process. GAO's complement of reports were used by Congress in framing the Help America Vote Act of 2002, which, among other things, provided for replacement of older voting equipment with more modern electronic voting systems and established the Election Assistance Commission (EAC) to lead the nation's election reform efforts. GAO's later reports have raised concerns about the security and reliability of these electronic voting systems, examined the EAC's efforts to address these concerns, and surveyed state and local officials about practices used during the 2004 election, as well as plans for their systems for the 2006 election. Using its published work on electronic voting systems, GAO was asked to testify on (1) the contextual role and characteristics of electronic voting systems, (2) the range of security and reliability concerns that have been reported about these systems, (3) the experiences and management practices of states and local jurisdictions regarding these systems, and (4) the longstanding and emerging challenges facing all levels of government in using these systems. Voting systems are one facet of a multifaceted, year-round elections process that involves the interplay of people, processes, and technology, and includes all levels of government. How well these systems play their role in an election depends in large part on how well they are managed throughout their life cycle, which begins with defining system standards; includes system design, development, and testing; and concludes with system operations. Important attributes of the systems' performance are security, reliability, ease of use, and cost effectiveness. A range of parties knowledgable about elections or voting systems have expressed concerns about the security and reliability of electronic voting systems; these concerns can be associated with stages in the system life cycle. Examples of concerns include vague or incomplete voting system standards, system design flaws, poorly developed security controls, incorrect system configurations, inadequate testing, and poor overall security management. For the 2004 national elections, states' and local governments' responses to our surveys showed that they did not always ensure that important life cycle and security management practices were employed for their respective electronic voting systems. In particular, responses indicated that the most current standards were not always adopted and applied, security management practices and controls were employed to varying degrees, and certain types of system testing were not commonly performed. Moreover, jurisdictions' responses showed that they did not consistently monitor the performance of their systems. In GAO's view,...


Related Articles

  • Early Voting.  // East Bernard Express (TX);11/2/2006, Vol. 63 Issue 45, p7 

    The article announces the ongoing early voting procedure for the 2006 general election in Texas as of November 2006. The early voting period will officially end on November 3, 2006. Polls for early voting include the Wharton Courthouse Annex, the El Campo Courthouse Annex, and the East Bernard...

  • Election Day Guide.  // Time International (South Pacific Edition);11/1/2004, Issue 43, p26 

    The article presents information related to the 2004 election in the U.S. Conventional wisdom holds that if most states go just as they did in 2000, the 2004 winner must take two of Florida, Pennsylvania and Ohio. Voters will also decide the fate of 163 ballot initiatives, sponsored by voters or...

  • Hot hunches for the politics of tomorrow. McCarthy, Colman // National Catholic Reporter;12/8/2006, Vol. 43 Issue 7, p18 

    The article comments on the noisy and less knowledgeable politicians in the November 7, 2006 election in the U.S. The author cites the forecast of the mouthiest people in Washington by "The Washington Post," which include Christopher Matthews and Mary Matalin. Among eleven forecasters, one was...

  • Imagining independence. Goddard, Ben // Hill;6/14/2007, Vol. 14 Issue 71, p29 

    The author reflects on several voters' opinions regarding the 2008 elections in the U.S. He asserts that some voters have developed the Ernest Hemingway principle called "built-in crap detector" which enables them not to trust much on the promises of the politicians during the campaign period....

  • ELECTION CORRECTIONS. Brush, Silla // U.S. News & World Report;7/17/2006, Vol. 141 Issue 2, p45 

    The article focuses on America's efforts to fix its voting machinery. Following the 2000 election, flaws in the country's voting process became public. In Washington state, the 2004 governor's election took more than six months to resolve. Some liberal activists believe that vote tampering and...

  • Turnout: The Spillover Effect. Barnes, James A. // National Journal;5/6/2006, Vol. 38 Issue 18, p65 

    The article presents an outlook for the voter turnout in the U.S. in the 2006 midterm elections. The rise in voting sparked by the 2004 presidential race could aid 2006 Democrats. Republican prospects for capturing the Senate looked better, but the consensus among political forecasters was that...

  • Elections will never be a problem in Winstonia. Winston, Paul // Business Insurance;11/6/2006, Vol. 40 Issue 45, p6 

    The author reflects on the November 2006 midterm elections in the U.S. He states that he has been receiving messages from candidates in the House and Senate races and from their political parties urging him to support their campaigns. He observes that the political advertisements of some...

  • Off Center. Judis, John B. // New Republic;4/15/2002, Vol. 226 Issue 14, p10 

    Examines the implications of the unwillingness of state and local Republican organizations to back moderate candidates for the administration of U.S. President George W. Bush. Impact of the failure of Los Angeles, California Mayor Dick Riordan to win the Republican gubernatorial primary on the...

  • THE VEXATIONS OF VOTING MACHINES. Novak, Viveca; Locke, Laura A.; Hylton, Hilary; Land, Greg; Morrissey, Siobhan; Thigpen, David; Underwood, Jill // Time;5/3/2004, Vol. 163 Issue 18, p42 

    Reports on growing concerns surrounding the use of electronic voting machines in the wake of problems experienced in a number of districts that have used them during the primary season. Report that the campaign of Sen. Barbara Mikulski has collected complaints among Maryland voters that her race...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics