Perceptions of medical school graduates and students regarding their academic preparation to teach

Henry, B. W.; Haworth, J. G.; Hering, P.
September 2006
Postgraduate Medical Journal;Sep2006, Vol. 82 Issue 971, p607
Academic Journal
Purpose: How medical students learn and develop the characteristics associated with good teaching in medicine is not well known. Information about this process con improve the academic preparation of medical students for teaching responsibilities. The purpose of this study was to determine how different experiences contributed to the knowledge, skills, and attitudes of medical school graduates and students regarding medical teaching. Methods: A questionnaire was developed, addressing reliability and validity considerations, and given to first year residents and third year medical students (taught by those residents). Completed questionnaires were collected from 76 residents and 110 students (81% of the sample group). Item responses were analysed using descriptive and inferential statistics. Results: Most residents (n = 54; 71%) positively viewed opportunities they had to practice teaching when they were seniors. Residents rated three activities for learning to teach highest: (1) observing teachers as they teach; (2) reviewing the material to be taught; and (3) directly teaching students; representing both individual and participatory ways of learning. Residents' self ratings of teaching behaviours improved over time and this self assessment by the residents was validated by the students' responses. Comparison between residents' self ratings and students' views of typical resident teaching behaviours showed agreement on levels of competence, confidence, and motivation. The students rated characteristics of enthusiasm, organisation, and fulfilment lower (p<0.002) than residents rated themselves. Conclusions: The residents and students in this study viewed academic preparation for teaching responsibilities positively and showed agreement on characteristics of good teaching that may be helpful indicators in the process of developing medical teachers.


Related Articles

  • The modern scientific physician: 8. Educational preparation. Miettinen, Olli S. // CMAJ: Canadian Medical Association Journal;11/27/2001, Vol. 165 Issue 11, p1501 

    Comments on medical education, and how the beginning of a physician's education must be an intellectually tenable conceptualization of medicine itself. View that the first concerns in medicine are cognitive, having to do with illness or sickness; Idea that the student needs to proceed from a...

  • Global health opportunities within pediatric subspecialty fellowship training programs: surveying the virtual landscape. Dixon, Cinnamon A.; Castillo, Jonathan; Castillo, Heidi; Hom, Katherine A.; Schubert, Charles // BMC Medical Education;2013, Vol. 13 Issue 1, p1 

    Background: There is growing interest in global health among medical trainees. Medical schools and residencies are responding to this trend by offering global health opportunities within their programs. Among United States (US) graduating pediatric residents, 40% choose to subspecialize after...

  • The control of medical education. Parkhouse, James // Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine;Jun1979, Vol. 72 Issue 6, p453 

    The article analyzes the factors that influence the control of medical education in Great Britain. Medical graduates must be accepted for training in a specialty in an uncontrolled way. In the British system, there are advantages and disadvantages in which it is hard to define the point at which...

  • Clinical and communication skills. Kidd, Jane; Patel, Vinod; Peile, Ed; Carter, Yvonne // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);2/19/2005, Vol. 330 Issue 7488, p374 

    Comments on the teaching of clinical skills to undergraduate medical students. Belief that communication and clinical skills need to be practiced together rather than separately; Trials which have shown that interactive medical education is effective in changing clinical performance positively;...

  • ICRAM (the International Campaign to Revitalise Academic Medicine): agenda setting. Wilkinson, David // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);10/2/2004, Vol. 329 Issue 7469, p787 

    Introduces ICRAM (the International Campaign to Revitalise Academic Medicine). Working party of medical academics seeking to improve the education of physicians around the world; Three roles of academic medicine and how they are changing; Failures in the current system; Suggested changes that...

  • Graduate medical education research in the 21st century and JAMA on call. Lim, Joseph K.; Golub, Robert M. // JAMA: Journal of the American Medical Association;12/15/2004, Vol. 292 Issue 23, p2913 

    Presents an editorial on graduate medical education research in the 21st century. Comments on a report in this issue on residency burnout; Belief that the methodological weakness of the evidence leaves as many questions as answers; Increase in studies of graduate medical students over the years...

  • Career Aspirations and Apprehensions Regarding Medical Education Among First Year Medical Students in Delhi. Lal, Panna; Malhotra, Chetna; Nath, Anita; Malhotra, Rahul; Ingle, G. K. // Indian Journal of Community Medicine;Jul2007, Vol. 32 Issue 3, p217 

    The article discusses a study on the career aspirations and apprehensions concerning medical education among first year medical students in Delhi, India. The study was conducted among medical students of Maulana Azad Medical College during their preadmission check-up. Majority or 74.6% cited...

  • Accreditation Status of U.S. Military Graduate Medical Education Programs. De Lorenzo, Robert A. // Military Medicine;Jul2008, Vol. 173 Issue 7, p635 

    Context: Military graduate medical education (GME) comprises a substantial fraction of U.S. physician training capacity. The wars in Iraq and Afghanistan have placed substantial stress on military medicine, and lay and professional press accounts have raised awareness of the effects on military...

  • Quest for excellence.  // British Medical Journal;8/19/1978, Vol. 2 Issue 6136, p519 

    Focuses on the assessment of training post for postgraduate medical students in Great Britain. Inflexibility of training programs; Lack of facilities for career guidance; Importance of participation for student learning.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics