Realization and the Formulation of Physicalism

Melnyk, Andrew
October 2006
Philosophical Studies;Oct2006, Vol. 131 Issue 1, p127
Academic Journal
Twenty years ago, Richard Boyd suggested that physicalism could be formulated by appeal to a notion of realization, with no appeal to the identity of the non-physical with the physical. In (Melnyk 2003), I developed this suggestion at length, on the basis of one particular account of realization. I now ask what happens if you try to formulate physicalism on the basis of other accounts of realization, accounts due to LePore and Loewer and to Shoemaker. Having explored two new formulations of physicalism, I conclude that my 2003 formulation remains the most promising.


Related Articles

  • Why property dualists must reject substance physicalism. Schneider, Susan // Philosophical Studies;Jan2012, Vol. 157 Issue 1, p61 

    I argue that property dualists cannot hold that minds are physical substances. The focus of my discussion is a property dualism that takes qualia to be sui generis features of reality.

  • Conclusion. PETTIT, PHILIP // Mind;Oct1991, Vol. 100 Issue 400, p622 

    The article summarizes various philosophical theories, including realism, conceptualism, and descriptivism. It is stated that the most logical way of taking a concept is to adopt an ethocentric view of its genealogy. The article also talks about the theory of ethocentric admission of...

  • There is No Question of Physicalism. CRANE, TIM; MELLOR, D. H. // Mind;Apr1990, Vol. 99 Issue 394, p185 

    The article examines a number of proposed definitions of physicalism, also known as logical positivism. The article discusses physicalism as a doctrine about the empirical world. Physicalism is not discussed as the matter of universal and abstract objects. It is stated that nominalism and...

  • Indétermination de la traduction et sous-détermination chez Quine. Gaudet, Eve // Dialogue: Canadian Philosophical Review;Spring2005, Vol. 44 Issue 2, p313 

    I propose an interpretation of Quine's position on the asymmetry between indeterminacy of translation and underdetermination of theory. The positions of Chomsky, Rorty, and Friedman, who reject the asymmetry, are presented and criticized. The same is done with Follesdal's and Gibson's views,...

  • Locating the Overdetermination Problem. Witmer, D. Gene // British Journal for the Philosophy of Science;Jun2000, Vol. 51 Issue 2, p273 

    Assesses the use of the term physical in physicalism. Reasons for making physics as reference in physicalism; Notion on the existence of causal overdetermination; Claims on the causal impact of mental on the physical; Justification of physicalism; Correlation between the ordinary-physical and...

  • Bhaskar on Open and Closed Systems. Spurrett, David // South African Journal of Philosophy;2000, Vol. 19 Issue 3, p188 

    Examines Bhaskar's argument for emergence. Philosophy of science of Bhaskar; Rejection of physicalism; Articulation of transcendental realism; Argument for weak stratification.

  • PHYSICALISM AND THE FALLACY OF COMPOSITION. Elder, Crawford L. // Philosophical Quarterly;Jul2000, Vol. 50 Issue 202, p332 

    Focuses on the concept of modest physicalism. Factors affecting the stability of modest physicalism; Account on the fallacy of composition; Assumptions about causation; Rationale for collecting microparticles realizing the event identified as cause; Importance of physicalism in understanding...

  • Conceptual gaps and odd possibilities. Sturgeon, Scott // Mind;Apr99, Vol. 108 Issue 430, p376 

    Defends the author's views on the Overdetermination Argument for Physicalism. Principles supporting the argument; Assumptions on physics and the casue-and-essence principle; Conceptual gap between macro movements and micro spatial phenomena.

  • TINKERING TOWARD SUCCESS: Prelude to a Theory of Scientific Practice. Knorr, Karin D. // Theory & Society;Nov79, Vol. 8 Issue 3, p347 

    The article discusses theoretical aspects involved in conducting scientific research. The constructed character of scientific reality suggests an interpretation of knowledge which directly relates to the question of scientific realism. Empirical observation and experimentation can be seen as...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics