Metz, Thaddeus
July 2000
Law & Philosophy;Jul2000, Vol. 19 Issue 4, p491
Academic Journal
Many philosophers and laypeople have the following two intuitions about legal punishment: the state has a pro tanto moral reason to punish all those guilty of breaking a just law and to do so in proportion to their guilt. Accepting that there can be overriding considerations not to punish all the guilty in proportion to their guilt, many philosophers still consider it a strike against any theory if it does not imply that there is always a supportive moral reason to do so. In this paper. I demonstrate that censure theory accounts for these intuitions much better than any other theory, including forms of retributivism such as desert theory and fairness theory, and explain why censure theory is able to do so.


Related Articles

  • Deterrence Theory. Bourassa, Cheryl // Deterrence Theory -- Research Starters Sociology;4/1/2018, p1 

    A prime purpose of punishment has long been to deter future illicit behavior. Deterrence works on two levels. Specific deterrence occurs when an individual is punished for wrongdoing, and learns the price of misbehavior. General deterrence affects the population at large who observes the fact...

  • Misapplications Reviews: The Capital Punishment Controversy: Part I. Barnett, Arnold // Interfaces;Jun83, Vol. 13 Issue 3, p24 

    The article discusses the effectiveness of capital punishment in restraining the act of murder. An odd collection of inquirers that includes sociologists, lawyers, economists, psychologists, statisticians and philosophers have examined data that cross the boundaries between nations and...

  • Think Nationally, Act Locally: The Municipal-Level Effects of the National Crime Prevention Program in Finland. Savolainen, Jukka // European Journal on Criminal Policy & Research;2005, Vol. 11 Issue 2, p175 

    This paper gauges the effects of the National Crime Prevention Program (NCPP) on the level of crime in Finland. The research design involves comparisons between municipalities that vary in terms of their participation in the NCPP. Is this characteristic related to improvements in community...

  • Trying, Acting and Attempted Crimes. Yaffe, Gideon // Law & Philosophy;Mar2009, Vol. 28 Issue 2, p109 

    The article provides information on the system of punishment on crimes committed from minor to major. The elements of crimes are accordingly subjected to the law which constitutes the grounds outlined for the crime committed. Obviously, actions and justifications done in response to such illegal...

  • The idea of creating "succession crime" theory. Zhang Dong-chao // Journal of China Lawyer & Jurist;Jan2008, Vol. 4 Issue 1, p26 

    Owing to a research about three similar doubtful cases appeared within 3 years or so, the author has discovered for the first time that this kind of crime (that is "succession crime") is another form of imperfect crime besides getting ready to commit a crime, an attempted crime and breaking off...

  • COMMUNITY JUSTICE FILES 6. Dominey, Jane // British Journal of Community Justice;Spring2004, Vol. 2 Issue 3, p73 

    The article presents various reports published in the previous issues of "Community Justice File 6" in Great Britain. The reports include "Managing Offenders, Changing Lives: Correctional Services," "Youth Justice 2004: A Review of the Reformed Youth Justice System" and "Victims and Witnesses:...

  • Punishment and prevention. Wollan Jr., Laurin A. // World & I;Apr94, Vol. 9 Issue 4, p36 

    Advocates punishment and prevention as an approach to control violent crime in the United States. Criminologists' rejection of the theory that violence is the result of the absence of punishment; Theories explaining the factors that contribute to delinquency; Incarceration as a form of...

  • STATE INTENTIONS AND THE LAW OF PUNISHMENT. RISTROPH, ALICE // Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology;Summer2008, Vol. 98 Issue 4, p1353 

    Forget dogs: do people distinguish between being stumbled over and being kicked? Assessments of intentions are considerably more complex than Holmes's classic quip suggests. This Article examines the substantial, but so far overlooked, role of intent analysis in the constitutional law of...

  • PUNISHMENT AS DETERRENCE: REPLY TO SPRAGUE. Ellis, Anthony // Philosophical Quarterly;Jan2005, Vol. 55 Issue 218, p98 

    In my‘A Deterrence Theory of Punishment’, I argued that a deterrence system of punishment can avoid the charge that it illegitimately uses offenders if its punishments are carried out‘quasi-automatically’: threats are issued by a legislature for deterrent purposes, but...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics