Medicaid: States' Efforts to Maximize Federal Reimbursements Highlight Need for Improved Federal Oversight: GAO-05-836T

Allen, Kathryn G.
June 2005
GAO Reports;6/28/2005, p1
Government Document
Medicaid--the federal-state health care financing program covering almost 54 million low-income people at a cost of $276 billion in fiscal year 2003--is by its size and structure at significant risk of waste and exploitation. Because of challenges inherent in overseeing the program, which is administered federally by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), GAO added Medicaid to its list of high-risk federal programs in 2003. Over the years, states have found various ways to maximize federal Medicaid reimbursements, sometimes using consultants paid a contingency fee to help them do so. From earlier work and a report issued today (GAO-05-748), GAO's testimony addresses (1) how some states have inappropriately increased federal reimbursements; (2) some ways states have increased federal reimbursements for school-based Medicaid services and administrative costs; and (3) how states are using contingency-fee consultants to maximize federal Medicaid reimbursements and how CMS is overseeing states' efforts. For many years, GAO has reported on varied financing schemes and questionable methods used by states to increase the federal reimbursements they receive for operating their state Medicaid programs. These schemes and methods can undermine Medicaid's federal-state partnership and threaten its fiscal integrity. For example, some states make large supplemental payments to government-owned or government-operated entities for delivery of Medicaid services while requiring these entities to return the payments to the state. This process creates the illusion of valid expenditures in order to obtain federal reimbursement, effectively shifting a portion of the state's share of program expenditures to the federal government and increasing the federal share beyond that established by formula under law. Medicaid funding is available for local school districts for certain health services for eligible children and for administrative costs. To claim increased federal Medicaid reimbursement, however, some states and school districts have used methods lacking sufficient controls to ensure that claims were legitimate. GAO also found funding arrangements among schools, states, and private consulting firms where some states retained up to 85 percent of reimbursements for administrative costs. In some cases, school districts paid contingency fees to consultants. A growing number of states are using consultants on a contingency-fee basis to maximize federal Medicaid reimbursements. As of 2004, 34 states--up from 10 states in 2002--used contingency-fee consultants for this purpose. GAO identified claims in each of five categories of claims from contingency-fee projects that appeared to be inconsistent with current CMS policy, inconsistent with federal law, or that undermined the fiscal integrity of the Medicaid program. Problematic projects often were in categories where federal requirements were inconsistently applied, evolving, or not specific. CMS has taken steps to improve its fiscal management of Medicaid, but a lack of oversight and clear guidance from CMS has allowed states to develop new financing methods or continue existing ones that take advantage of ambiguity and generate considerable additional federal costs.


Related Articles

  • GAO: 5% of Medicaid-only Enrollees Account for Nearly Half of Costs. Slabodkin, Greg // Healthdatamanagement.com;5/11/2015, p1 

    A small percentage of Medicaid-only enrollees--those who were not also eligible for Medicare--consistently accounted for a large percentage of total Medicaid expenditures, according to the Government Accountability Office.

  • Medicaid Fraud and Abuse: CMS's Commitment to Helping States Safeguard Program Dollars Is Limited: GAO-05-855T. Aronovitz, Leslie G. // GAO Reports;6/28/2005, p1 

    Today's hearing addresses fraud and abuse control in Medicaid, a program that provides health care coverage for eligible low-income individuals and is jointly financed by the federal government and the states. In fiscal year 2003, Medicaid covered nearly 54 million people and the program's...

  • Comparisons of Selected Services under Fee-for-Service, Managed Care, and Private Insurance. Yocom, Carolyn L. // GAO Reports;7/15/2014, preceding pi 

    A report to the U.S. Congressional Committees by the U.S. Government Accountability Office entitled "Comparisons of Selected Services under Fee-for Service, Managed Care, and Private Insurance" is presented. Topics discussed include a comparison between payments to physicians under Medicaid...

  • GAO finds AMP reimbursement 36% below acquisition cost.  // Drug Topics;2/5/2007, Vol. 151 Issue 3, p8 

    The article reports on the findings of the U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) regarding pharmacy reimbursement for generics under Medicaid. According to GAO, pharmacy reimbursement for generics under the Medicaid program would be less than their acquisition costs by an average of 36...

  • Characteristics, Financial Risks, and Disenrollment Rates of Beneficiaries in Private Fee-for-Service Plans. Cosgrove, James C. // GAO Reports;12/15/2008, preceding p1 

    The article provides information on the study made by the U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) on private fee-for-service plans (PFFS). It cites that the report tries to compare PFFS plans to Medicare fee-for-service (FFS) in three aspects which are the characteristics of the...

  • EQUITY AND MEDICAID. Stuart, Bruce // Journal of Human Resources;Spring72, Vol. 7 Issue 2, p162 

    ABSTRACT This paper is concerned with the differential impact of the Medicaid program on state incomes in 1967-68. Benefits and costs of the program are calculated for each state and the results are evaluated in terms of the perceived original intent of the program planners. It was found that...

  • Pharmacy gets congressional support on Medicaid issue. Frederick, Jim // Drug Store News;3/19/2007, Vol. 29 Issue 4, p3 

    The article reports that retail pharmacy leaders gets congressional support to preserve a fair reimbursement system due to a proposed changes in the Medicaid prescription in Washington, D.C. Pharmacy leaders fear that the change will severely reduce payments, undermine pharmacy profitability,...

  • Child restraints. Webster, Richard A. // New Orleans CityBusiness (1994 to 2008);4/4/2005, Vol. 25 Issue 39, p29 

    The article reports that low federal reimbursement rates and proposed cuts to the Medicaid program have administrators worried about the future of approximately 250 Children's Hospitals in the United States. Children's Hospital of New Orleans is projected to lose more than $18 million on...

  • States invoke emergency rules to cut Medicaid rates. Sipkoff, Martin // Drug Topics;2/7/2005, Vol. 149 Issue 3, p82 

    In efforts to reduce Medicaid rates across the United States, local governments and states invoke a budgetary emergency then declare rules and regulations influencing reductions in Medicaid reimbursements and dispensing of fees. Under state and federal laws, adjustments in Medicaid...


Read the Article

Other Topics