The Embryo in Relationships: A French Debate on Stem Cell Research

Maio, Giovanni
October 2004
Journal of Medicine & Philosophy;Oct2004, Vol. 29 Issue 5, p583
Academic Journal
While many European countries are entering unknown legal terrain where the embryo in vitro is concerned, France can already look back on a long tradition of public discussion and legal codification of ways of dealing with in vitro embryos. In its comprehensive law of 1994, France had still rejected embryo research; however, due to the promising perspectives of stem cell research, the new law now pending implies a clear liberalization of the 1994 provisions. Both the French lawmakers and the National Ethics Commission have repeatedly argued that possible utilization of embryos for research purposes may seem legitimate from the moment that there is no more”parental project.”De facto, this concept implies that an embryo can be transformed into an object from the moment that the parents cease to desire it and that the value of protection is solely dependent on the will of third persons. At the same time, France is still speaking of guaranteeing respect for the“dignity of the embryo,”which would mean that an embryo must not be reduced to a thing and treated for purposes which are not his own. Therefore, the French solution is not a consistent and honest solution, and in its new legal provisions, France has involved herself in manifold contradictions. France has rejected the conception of pre-embryo, but is de facto following Britain’s model without making it explicit.


Related Articles

  • Live forever: stem cell science drives ethical controversy.  // PharmaWatch: Biotechnology;May 2005, Vol. 4 Issue 5, p23 

    Comments on the declaration of the United Nations on the use of human embryos in scientific research. Failure to distinguish adequately between the twin spheres of reproductive cloning and therapeutic cloning, which includes stem cell research; Consternation of some people in the scientific...

  • Ethical sourcing? Harrison, Charlotte // Nature Reviews Drug Discovery;Feb2007, Vol. 6 Issue 2, p114 

    The article discusses research being done on the isolation of stem cells from amniotic fluid with potential for therapy. It references a study by P. De Coppi and colleagues, published in a 2007 issue of "Nature Biotechnology." Immunoselection was used to isolate cells positive for c-kit, the...

  • Surplus Embryos, Nonreproductive Cloning, and the Intend/Foresee Distinction. FitzPatrick, William // Hastings Center Report;May/Jun2003, Vol. 33 Issue 3, p29 

    Focuses on the moral difference between creating embryos expressly for medical research and conducting research on embryos that are left over from infertility treatments. Issue which emerged from the stem cell debate; Manner in which moral difference is identified by the proponents of the...

  • Stem cells today: B1. Bone marrow stem cells. Edwards, R. G. // Reproductive BioMedicine Online;Nov2004, Vol. 9 Issue 5, p541 

    This review is the second in a series of four devoted to the analysis of recent studies on stem cells. The first considered embryo stem cells (ES). This review covers bone marrow stem cells. They are analysed initially in a historical perspective, and then in relation to foundation studies in...

  • Centriolar Mechanisms of Differentiation and Replicative Aging of Higher Animal Cells. Tkemaladze, J.V.; Chichinadze, K.N. // Biochemistry (00062979);Nov2005, Vol. 70 Issue 11, p1288 

    The centrosome (centriole) and the cytoskeleton produced by it are structures, which probably determine differentiation, morphogenesis, and switching on the mechanism of replicative aging in all somatic cells of multicellular animals. The mechanism of such programming of the events seems to...

  • Is teratoma formation in stem cell research a characterization tool or a window to developmental biology? Aleckovic, Masa; Simón, Carlos // Reproductive BioMedicine Online (Reproductive Healthcare Limited;Aug2008, Vol. 17 Issue 2, p270 

    Transplantation of pluripotent embryonic stem cells (ESC) into immune-deficient mice results in the formation of complex teratomas consisting of derivatives from all three germ layers. The highly sophisticated tissue organization found therein resembles structures normally found in the embryo...

  • Developmental Origin of Neural Stem Cells: The Glial Cell That Could. Grabel, Laura // Stem Cell Reviews & Reports;Jun2012, Vol. 8 Issue 2, p577 

    Since their identification, there has been tremendous interest in adult neural stem cells, in part based upon their potential therapeutic uses in understanding and treating neurological disorders. But what's the origin of these cells in the embryo? We outline here the onset of neural...

  • Origin and use of embryonic and adult stem cells in differentiation and tissue repair. Passier, Robert; Mummery, Christine // Cardiovascular Research;May2003, Vol. 58 Issue 2, p324 

    Stem cells are self-renewing, unspecialised cells that can give rise to multiple cell types of all tissues of the body. They can be derived from the embryo, foetus and adult. The ability of stem cells to divide but also to differentiate to specialised cell types like nerve and muscle, have made...

  • The human stem cells debate: A UK perspective. Lezemore, T.; Bull, S. // Journal of Commercial Biotechnology;Summer2001, Vol. 8 Issue 1, p31 

    The potential use of embryonic stem cells for the treatment of common diseases raises a number of ethical concerns relating to the use of embryos in research and the possibility of human reproductive cloning. This paper assesses the debate about the moral permissibility of research using...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics