A Comparative Analysis of the Darwin-Wallace Papers and the Development of the Concept of Natural Selection

November 2003
Theory in Biosciences;Nov2004, Vol. 122 Issue 4, p343
Academic Journal
The classical theory of descent with modification by means of natural selection had no mother, but did have two English fathers, Charles Darwin (1809-1882) and Alfred Russel Wallace (1823-1913). In 1858, the Linnean Society of London published two contributions of these naturalists and acknowledged both authors as the proponents of a novel hypothesis on the driving force of organismic evolution. In the present report the most important sections of the Darwin-Wallace papers are summarized. This close reading of both publications reveals six striking differences in emphasis: Darwin and Wallace did not propose identical ideas. The species definitions of both authors are described and the further development of the concept of natural selection in wild populations is reviewed. It is shown that the contributions of A.R. Wallace, who died 90 years ago, are more significant than usually acknowledged. I conclude that natural selection's lesser known co-discoverer should be regarded as one of the most important pioneers of evolutionary biology, whose original contributions are underestimated by most contemporary scientists.


Related Articles

  • Triumph of the root-heads. Gould, Stephen Jay // Natural History;Jan96, Vol. 105 Issue 1, p10 

    Discusses how root-heads or Rhizocephala can be used to evaluate several aspects of the concept of evolution. Consideration of Darwin's theories of natural selection; Sources of nutrition necessary for the function of externa; Research on barnacle parasites by zoologists; Use of Rhizocephala to...

  • The tallest tale. Gould, Stephen Jay // Natural History;May96, Vol. 105 Issue 5, p18 

    Raises questions about the classic textbook version of giraffe evolution, which is based on the ideas of Charles Darwin. Consideration of the author's review of high school textbooks on biology; Lamarck's theory of the inheritance of acquired characters; Evolution of the long neck of the...

  • What's at stake in the evolution debate. Trail, Pepper // High Country News;10/3/2005, Vol. 37 Issue 18, p21 

    This article presents the author's views about the debate on evolution. Naturalist Charles Darwin's concept of evolution and natural selection asserts that life is so complex that it must reflect a guiding intelligence. Mindful that the teaching of creationism has been barred by the courts,...

  • Pangenesis as a Source of New Genetic Information The History of a Now Disproven Theory. Bergman, Gerald // Biology Forum / Rivista di Biologia;2006, Vol. 99 Issue 3, p425 

    Evolution is based on natural selection of existing biological phenotypic traits. Natural selection can only eliminate traits. It cannot create new ones, requiring a theory to explain the origin of new genetic information. The theory of pangenesis was a major attempt to explain the source of new...

  • The process whereby species originate. Carson, Hampton L. // BioScience;Nov87, Vol. 37 Issue 10, p715 

    Discusses current evolution theory which combines the views of little-known 19th century biologist John Thomas Gulick with those of Charles Darwin. Consideration of Darwin's voyage to the Galapagos Islands and his theory of natural selection; Gulick's work in Hawaii and his theory concerning...

  • The power of this view of life. Gould, Stephen Jay // Natural History;Jun94, Vol. 103 Issue 6, p6 

    Offers comments on Charles Darwin and his views in 'The Origin of Species.' Consideration of evolution as a fundamental notion associated with biological science; Components of Darwin's revolution; His proposition of the theory of natural selection; Why Darwin's revolution remains incomplete.

  • The games species play.  // Natural History;Jun94, Vol. 103 Issue 6, p31 

    Introduces a series of studies that reveal scientific progress in understanding how life works and the continued significance of the Darwinian perspective. Theory of evolution by Charles Darwin; Natural selection.

  • THE Ascent of Darwin. Wright, Karen // Discover;Mar2009, Vol. 30 Issue 3, p34 

    The article discusses the ever-developing nexus between Darwin's theory of biological evolution (i.e., natural selection and survival of the fittest) and developing concepts or explanatory models in other fields. The author discusses evolution-like concepts used in social science, psychology,...

  • Evolution's inside man. Waller, John // New Scientist;8/20/2005, Vol. 187 Issue 2513, p42 

    This article discusses the scientific accomplishments of naturalist Charles Darwin. In early September 1830, Charles Darwin, just 21 years old, nervously approached the Admiralty buildings in London, England. On at least one thing most Darwin scholars agree. Had Darwin not sailed aboard the...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics