Use of Theory in Behavior Change Interventions: An Analysis of Programs to Increase Physical Activity in Posttreatment Breast Cancer Survivors

Bluethmann, Shirley M.; Bartholomew, L. Kay; Murphy, Caitlin C.; Vernon, Sally W.
April 2017
Health Education & Behavior;Apr2017, Vol. 44 Issue 2, p245
Academic Journal
Objective. Theory use may enhance effectiveness of behavioral interventions, yet critics question whether theory-based interventions have been sufficiently scrutinized. This study applied a framework to evaluate theory use in physical activity interventions for breast cancer survivors. The aims were to (1) evaluate theory application intensity and (2) assess the association between extensiveness of theory use and intervention effectiveness. Methods. Studies were previously identified through a systematic search, including only randomized controlled trials published from 2005 to 2013, that addressed physical activity behavior change and studied survivors who were <5 years posttreatment. Eight theory items from Michie and Prestwich's coding framework were selected to calculate theory intensity scores. Studies were classified into three subgroups based on extensiveness of theory use (Level 1 = sparse; Level 2 = moderate; and Level 3 = extensive). Results. Fourteen randomized controlled trials met search criteria. Most trials used the transtheoretical model (n = 5) or social cognitive theory (n = 3). For extensiveness of theory use, 5 studies were classified as Level 1, 4 as Level 2, and 5 as Level 3. Studies in the extensive group (Level 3) had the largest overall effect size (g = 0.76). Effects were more modest in Level 1 and 2 groups with overall effect sizes of g = 0.28 and g = 0.36, respectively. Conclusions. Theory use is often viewed as essential to behavior change, but theory application varies widely. In this study, there was some evidence to suggest that extensiveness of theory use enhanced intervention effectiveness. However, there is more to learn about how theory can improve interventions for breast cancer survivors.


Related Articles

  • Moderators of Theory-Based Interventions to Promote Physical Activity in 77 Randomized Controlled Trials. Bernard, Paquito; Carayol, Marion; Gourlan, Mathieu; Boiché, Julie; Romain, Ahmed Jérôme; Bortolon, Catherine; Lareyre, Olivier; Ninot, Gregory // Health Education & Behavior;Apr2017, Vol. 44 Issue 2, p227 

    A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials (RCTs) has recently showed that theory-based interventions designed to promote physical activity (PA) significantly increased PA behavior. The objective of the present study was to investigate the moderators of the efficacy of these theory-based...

  • Psychosocial Benefits of Cooking Interventions: A Systematic Review. Farmer, Nicole; Touchton-Leonard, Katherine; Ross, Alyson // Health Education & Behavior;Apr2018, Vol. 45 Issue 2, p167 

    Objectives. Cooking interventions are used in therapeutic and rehabilitative settings; however, little is known about the influence of these interventions on psychosocial outcomes. This systematic review examines the research evidence regarding the influence of cooking interventions on...

  • Cost-effectiveness of Occupational Therapy in Older People: Systematic Review of Randomized Controlled Trials. Nagayama, Hirofumi; Tomori, Kounosuke; Ohno, Kanta; Takahashi, Kayoko; Yamauchi, Keita // Occupational Therapy International;Jun2016, Vol. 23 Issue 2, p103 

    The article discusses a study which evaluates the cost-effectiveness of occupational therapy for older people compared to standard care or no intervention. Results showed that occupational therapy was more clinically- and cost-effective than standard care or other therapies, and it motivates...

  • Developing Behavioral Theory With the Systematic Integration of Community Social Capital Concepts. Samuel, Laura J.; Commodore-Mensah, Yvonne; Dennison Himmelfarb, Cheryl R. // Health Education & Behavior;Aug2014, Vol. 41 Issue 4, p359 

    Health behavior theories state that social environments influence health behaviors, but theories of how this occurs are relatively underdeveloped. This article systematically surveys community social capital concepts in health behavior literature and proposes a conceptual framework that...

  • The Chronic Care Model, Kidney Disease, and Primary Care: A Scoping Review. Llewellyn, Sarah // Nephrology Nursing Journal;May/Jun2019, Vol. 46 Issue 3, p301 

    Early diagnosis and management of chronic kidney disease (CKD) in primary care settings remains complex. Nephrology nurses have the opportunity to positively impact this care trajectory. The Chronic Care Model has been applied as a means to improve chronic care management. A scoping review was...

  • Playground Designs to Increase Physical Activity Levels During School Recess: A Systematic Review. Escalante, Yolanda; García-Hermoso, Antonio; Backx, Karianne; Saavedra, Jose M. // Health Education & Behavior;Apr2014, Vol. 41 Issue 2, p138 

    School recess provides a major opportunity to increase children’s physical activity levels. Various studies have described strategies to increase levels of physical activity. The purpose of this systematic review is therefore to examine the interventions proposed as forms of increasing...

  • Essentials of Nursing Care in Randomized Controlled Trials of Nurse-Led Interventions in Somatic Care: A Systematic Review. Fridlund, Bengt; Jönsson, A. C.; Andersson, E. K.; Bala, S.-V.; Dahlman, G.-B.; Forsberg, A.; Glasdam, S.; Hommel, A.; Kristensson, A.; Lindberg, C.; Sivberg, B.; Sjöström-Strand, A.; Wihlborg, J.; Samuelson, K. // Open Journal of Nursing;Mar2014, Vol. 4 Issue 3, p181 

    No abstract available.

  • Maternal and Cord Blood Adiponectin Concentrations in Small for Gestational Age: A Meta-Analysis. Goto, Eita // Annals of Nutrition & Metabolism;Feb2018, Vol. 72 Issue 1, p57 

    Background: Adiponectin, which may have a growth-promoting effect through its insulin-sensitizing action, is thought to play a key role in fetal growth. This study was performed to determine whether maternal and/or cord blood adiponectin concentrations differ between small for gestational age...

  • A Systematic Review of Youth Participatory Action Research (YPAR) in the United States: Methodologies, Youth Outcomes, and Future Directions. Anyon, Yolanda; Bender, Kimberly; Kennedy, Heather; Dechants, Jonah // Health Education & Behavior;Dec2018, Vol. 45 Issue 6, p865 

    Objectives. To use a systematic review methodology to describe the state of the youth participatory action research (YPAR) literature and synthesize findings about the youth outcomes reported in these studies. Methods. We screened and coded studies using a process consistent with the Preferred...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics